RHYS BOWEN: I have been extra busy recently, firstly with the edits for my next stand alone, then helping Clare plot the next Molly book, then come up with a story suggestion for next year's stand alone while at the same time writing the twentieth Royal Spyness book.
One of the things I'm passionate about is playing fair with the reader. That means dropping subtle and appropriate clues. I've noticed that not all writers do this. Agatha Christie, for all her brilliance, did not always play fair. Poirot says "I happen to know that she was once wardress of a prison." Okay. We didn't know that! And the books in which the first person narrator is the killer. I have to say in Roger Ackroyd she was pretty good about leaving subtle hints, but in another, which I won't name in case it's a spoiler for those who haven't read it, the narrator says near the end that he's been getting funny black turns when he doesn't quite know what he's doing. We did not know that before!
So what kind of clues do you appreciate? Which authors do them well?
This Royal Spyness book, that I am calling TO CROWN IT ALL, takes place at the coronation of King George and Queen Elizabeth in 1937. a group of Georgie's friends and relatives are staying at her house before the coronation, plus a German man who has escorted Mummy from Germany. Oh, and there's a village fair going on outside the house. So it's quite a challenge to drop clues without being over obvious. I'm not normally the spent match type of cluemaker. It's usually what somebody says, or doesn't say, or reacts to a statement by someone else.
But this time I am using fingerprints. But what if they show the wrong person? What if one of Georgie's family actually seems to be the main suspect?
It's quite a complicated plot: one thread involving Mummy, another involving security for the coronation and the crown jewels and yet another involving poor Georgie: here are a few tell-tale lines about that plot. Georgie has been worrying about what to wear to the coronation. Since her husband has is only Mr. O'Mara she can't wear her peeress's robes if she's to sit with him. And she has no fabulous outfits.
Then this happens:
At that very moment I heard a telephone ringing in the front foyer. I froze. Mrs. Holbrook appeared, looking scared. “You’re wanted on the telephone, my lady,” she said in an awed voice. “It’s the palace.”
I couldn’t stop my heart from racing as I went down the hallway. Was it good news or bad? What if the secretary said he was sorry but could do nothing for my mother. What then? Then I would go over and bring her back myself, I decided. It didn’t matter what Darcy or anybody said. She was my mother.
“Hello?” I said into the receiver, hearing my voice shake a little.
“Lady Georgiana?” It was a woman’s voice, a brisk efficient sort of voice.
“Yes,” I said. “This is she.”
“I’m sorry to disturb you but this is Lady Pierpoint, telephoning on behalf of Her Majesty. We’ve had a last minute set back for the coronation ceremony. Do you happen to know Lady Veronica Featherstone-Smythe? Lord Blanchley’s daughter?”
“I believe we’ve met,” I said, hesitantly, wondering what on earth this had to do with me.
“Horse mad, of course. Rode in a point to point and broke her ankle, stupid girl.”
I was still completely in the dark.
“She was to be one of the maids of honor for the queen at the ceremony,” Lady Pierpoint went on. “ Naturally carrying a train is quite out of the question and her majesty suggested that you would be a most suitable replacement.”
“Me?” The word came out as a squeak. “You want me to carry the queen’s train?”
“My dear, you are an obvious selection. Closely related to his majesty and both their majesties report being extremely fond of you. You were mentioned at the very start but it was considered that the words maids of honor should primarily include unmarried girls.
But given the circumstance and the late hour it was decided you would fit the bill perfectly.”
I was glad she couldn’t see me blushing. “Golly,” I said. “Well, I’d be honored.”
“Splendid. I’ll tell their majesties. We shall need you up in London right away for a dress fitting. I think you’re about the same size as Lady Veronica, which is most fortunate, but small alterations will need to be made. Then you will be required to attend several rehearsals, the first at the palace, learning the correct way to walk with the train, then in the abbey knowing the procedure of where to stand. You are free to come when summoned, I presume?”
“Yes, yes of course,” I said.
“Jolly good. Well done. Then I look forward to meeting you. Good evening.”
I put down the telephone and stared at the marble staircase, curving upward into darkness. What had I just agreed to? Carrying a train up steps, through the vast nave of the abbey with the whole world watching. Not dropping it, tripping up, tripping someone else. Oh golly, I said.
A wave of panic swept over me. I tried to remember her name. Lady Point to point? I had to stop myself from calling the palace and telling them that I had changed my mind. But the king and queen had asked for me. And it was a huge honor. I could hardly turn them down, could I?
Poor Georgie. You know she tends to be accident prone. Nothing could go wrong, could it?
And while we're on the subject of Royal Spyness books, then next one, FROM CRADLE TO GRAVE is published in just six days from now. I'll be holding a launch event at the POISONED PEN IN SCOTTSDALE with two other Jungle Reds, Julia, whose book is out the same day, and Jenn, whose book was out a couple of weeks ago. It's November 18th. Who will come to support us?
What an honor for Georgie! Thanks for sharing this with us, Rhys . . . .
ReplyDeleteRhys, you made my day ! One Royal Spyness to come shortly and an other one in processing, wow !
ReplyDeleteWonderful. Poor Georgie! What could possibly go wrong?
ReplyDeleteI just finished Mrs. Endicott's Splendid Adventure and thoroughly enjoyed it. WWII Resistance feels particularly close to home at the moment.
Isn’t that the truth!
DeleteLooking forward to Georgie's next adventure Rhys!!
ReplyDeleteOh I love this! It is always such a treat to get a new Georgie book! And I am so with you on fairness in mysteries… It’s very annoying when the author springs something on us that we could not have known.
ReplyDeleteBut I am a big fan of Roger Aykroyd, I hear to say. I hear you, it really isn’t fair in a way, but she manages it so beautifully.
Yes, Roger was ground breaking!
DeleteMe! Me! I want to be in Scottsdale for the JRW! Alas, guess I'll just have to settle for the bounty of new releases! Three terrific books now and more to come! My cup truly runneth over, Rhys!
ReplyDeleteThat's so interesting about Agatha Christie not playing fair. I just recently saw three books by "The Detection Club" on my library's e-book app and was intrigued. I checked out the first one and also did a bit of research on the club. It turns out that it was formed by a group British crime writers in the 1930s. They created rules for writing fair mystery stories and agreed to stick to them. Christie was a founding member! I haven't read any of her work in years, but I'm disappointed to hear she didn't always follow the rules she agreed to. (Sadly, I don't recommend the Detection Club's collaborative novels. The one I read is just not very good with too many authors dragging the plot back and forth. Also, I hadn't read any fiction that was written in the 1930s in a long time and had forgotten how shocking the casual racism can be.)
ReplyDeleteThose collaborative novels never work and there is a lot of anti-Semitism in that era, I’m afraid. But Dorothy Sayers especially is still worth reading
DeleteOh yes, I love Sayers' Lord Peter Wimsey - ("As My Wimsey Takes Me" - what a great family crest)
DeleteSo exciting! Three new Reds' books! I agree on the fair mystery. I love mysteries and often can guess the culprit but only if the writer is fair.
ReplyDeleteOn TV mysteries I can guess most of the time. They are so obvious!
DeleteOne of the best made for TV detective shows I've ever watched, and it's been A. L.O.T.!! is Murdock which is available on Acorn TV. Rhys I think you'd really like this show. The plots (especially the earlier ones) are very creative.
DeleteYes, our good friend Maureen Jennings wrote them. So good.
DeleteI wish I could go to Poisoned Pen - what a great treat to see three Reds. I live too far away to make it.
ReplyDeleteRhys you mentioned, "But this time I am using fingerprints. But what if they show the wrong person?" How would that work? I am, like many who might assume fingerprints would match to only one person?
I think fingerprint s in that era might still be prone to errors due to misinterpreting the results.
DeleteI wish I could attend the launch. One day...Thanks so much for the Georgie snippet. The fact that I can already envision the antics to come says something about how well-rounded and real Georgie is to your readers. Well done, you! -- Victoria
ReplyDeleteAlready preordered CRADLE TO GRAVE, Rhys. What an honour for Lady Georgie! Nothing could go wrong, right?
ReplyDeleteWhat I don't like is when the author has so many procedural mistakes in the crime detection. This bring it to the point where it is no longer about solving the crime but about the characters and their lives. Which I've come to accept.
ReplyDeleteThat's why I like writing historicals. No complicated procedures to get right.
DeleteCongrats, Rhys! Sadly, traveling to Arizona is a bit too far to go.
ReplyDeleteI try to be fair and that's what I prefer. That said, Dame Agatha did things so well and Roger Ackroyd is on my list of favorites (although not at the very top). Funny, The Hubby said he was never confused in that one and knew "whodunnit" almost immediately - although he still enjoyed it.
I'm looking forward to being at the Poisoned Pen with Rhys and Jenn! (And not just because it's thirty degrees warmer there, although that doesn't hurt.)
ReplyDeleteAs for clues, I'm an absolute believer in fair play. I still recall the lesson I learned from a widely acclaimed debut mystery, back at the turn of the century :-) when I was studying mysteries before writing my first book. It was a great tale, with a wonderful, unique heroine, and it was quite puzzling. I got to the end, eager to discover whodunnit, only to learn it was an Olympic-qualified archer who was the identical twin to another character. No, the Olympian twin had NEVER been introduced before being revealed as the killer! I went back and re-read the whole novel, convinced I had missed a clue. Nope. There was no clue.
I was SO MAD. I've always left a trail of breadcrumbs for my readers. When finding out whodunnit, (or whydunnit, or what the deadly plot is) I want them to think, "Ah, of course!" not, "What the heck??"
Not the evil twin??? That is so unfair and ridiculous.
DeleteFrom Celia: what fun Rhys and what an honor. Still if Prince George managed to carry his grandfathers train successfully I'm sure Georgie will make it work.
ReplyDeleteCan't remember if I told you how much I loved Mrs Endicott. Such a well crafted story.
If wishes were horses I would be in Scottsdale with the three of you on the 28th but I'll watch it on line. I'm lucky as I've read both Julia and Jenn's new books. All I can say is there's a real treat ahead for us fans. Travel safely everyone.
Thank you. We wish you could be there too!
DeleteI love this scene so much! I do always try to play fair with my readers, while still being as sneaky as I can. It's not an easy needle to thread (kind of like all needles are for me these days unless I'm doing it under a klieg lights...). Can't make it to Scottsdale, alas (hosting son # 2's baby shower!), but I know it will be a fabulous chat.
ReplyDeleteBaby shower. How exciting!
DeleteOh, how I wish I could be there in Scottsdale with the three of you! Congratulations, Rhys, on yet another book birthday this year! — Pat S
ReplyDeletePreordered! I've heard of riding in on someone's coattails. Will Georgie take that to a new extreme?
ReplyDeleteWho knows? I'm not sure what might happen yet!
DeleteOh, how I wish I could be in Scottsdale!! Wah!! Hopefully your combined fabulousness will be streamed.
ReplyDeleteSo happy to have a new Georgie to look forward to, and another in the works! And I do try to play fair. No unreliable narrators for me!
Come and join us!!!!
DeleteHow do you do it?! I haven't even gotten my hands on the new Royal Spyness and I'm already inpatient for the next one! Your fertile and funny imagination keeps this series fresh book after book,
ReplyDeleteThank you!
DeleteThank you, Rhys, and thank you to all the other mystery writers who follow the "rules". Nothing worse than getting to the solution of the crime and being blindsided by some secret only the sleuth or detective knew.
ReplyDeleteThinking about traveling to Scottsdale. I haven't seen my Arizona cousins in awhile!
That would be so lovely if you were there!
DeleteWhat a fun excerpt, Rhys. Lady Point-to-Point instead of Pierpoint made me laugh! And how wonderful to think of you, Julia, and Jenn in Scottsdale on November 18. I'd love to be there!
ReplyDeleteLike everyone else who's answered, I've tried to do a good job with clues in my four mysteries, and no readers have complained so far. But it's the readers who have the last word; it's hard for me to know if my clues are too obvious or not clear enough.
Rhys!!! I love all your books and cannot WAIT for the new Georgie! Thanks for the tempting tidbit you shared.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Ellen! Lovely to see you here.
DeleteI'll start with what you said last, Rhys. How thrilling it would be to attend the Poisoned Pen event with you and Julia and Jenn. It sure beats what I'll be doing the 18th, which is preparing for my knee replacement the next day. I bet there will be standing room only at the Poisoned Pen event, or is it ticketed with a limited attendance?
ReplyDeleteOh, and what a lovely fiasco we have to look forward to in To Crown It All with Lady Georgie being an attendant in the proceedings, and there's always trouble when Mummy is around. Of course before that From Cradle to Grave is sure to be a treat. I have that one and Julia's At Midnight Comes the Cry both pre-ordered--of course I do. I had Jenn's Witches of Dubious Origin pre-ordered, too, and have it on the top of my stack. I am still working on getting my reading mojo back, and, yet, I keep interfering with it by scheduling things like cataract surgery (done) and now my new knee, which sounds like I'm in for a lot of work in recovery. I think I'm too lazy to get a new knee.
Oh Kathy. Sending good wishes for your knee replacement. I hope it goes really smoothly.
DeleteLooking forward to seeing you both! It'll be a nice break from this deadline hell. LOL.
ReplyDelete"Nothing can go wrong" is the prelude to very interesting antics . . . but it does solve the problem of what to wear. ;-)
ReplyDelete-- Storyteller Mary