JULIA SPENCER-FLEMING: Every time I read one of Leslie Karst's Orchard Isle books, I wonder, Why didn't I set my mysteries in Hawai'i? We both like writing about the joys and travails of small town living, we both have a great couple at the center of our stories, I even have moments of humor - although considering how many times Leslie's been nominated for a Lefty Award, she's got me beat on that front.
I can only conclude it's because I settled on the frozen tundra in Maine, and she was smart enough to live on the Big Island. And we both firmly believe writing what you know creates the best experience for the reader. As you'll see when she talks about Murder, Local Style...
Traditional and cozy mysteries are often set in a small town
or village, and for good reason. People in a small town tend to know one
another, so when something goes awry—such as a murder—they make for good
suspects and witnesses. And when the amateur sleuth lives in the same
community, she too will have a special connection to and insider information
regarding the crime.
The street I live on in Hilo, Hawai‘i is in one of the town’s older neighborhoods (dating from 1930s), and many of its residents are the children or grandchildren of families who bought the properties when they were new. Although originally a Japanese-Hawaiian neighborhood, it’s now a blend of the original families along with “locals” (generally a mix of native Hawaiian, Filipino, Portuguese, and Chinese) and haoles (those of European descent).
| Our neighborhood on Boy's Day |
My wife Robin and I, of course, fall into the latter category, but we were welcomed warmly into the neighborhood when we bought our house eighteen years ago. And we love our street. Folks not only know one another, but often host social events for others on the street: Halloween parties and boxcar derbys! And it’s marvelous watching the kids play together in the street and on our front lawns—riding their bikes and playing hide-and-go-seek, just like I did when I was a kid back in the 1960s.
![]() |
| The view from my office window |
Of course no neighborhood is perfect, and ours definitely has its drawbacks. Lawnmowers, blowers, and weed whackers are a frequent background noise. People use loud pneumatic tools to work on their cars. Dogs on chains whine and bark. And neighbor disputes arise over trees blocking ocean views and the feeding of feral cats.
![]() |
| Some island dogs - not belonging to my neighbors! |
Not so fun, these things.
But, I thought one day as I slammed shut my bedroom window in a vain attempt to block out the grinding of a neighbor’s power saw, what a marvelous premise for a murder mystery!
What would happen if the resident of a tight-knit street in little Hilo town ended up dead in a highly suspicious manner? And what if he’d been having disputes—from the serious to the petty—with many of his neighbors in the months leading up to his death? And to add an additional local element to the story, what if I set it within a neighborhood orchid society? Because we all know how competitive hobbies like orchid growing can be.
Thus was born Murder, Local Style, book three in my Orchid Isle mystery series (yes, another reason for the orchids) set on the magnificent Big Island of Hawai‘i.
Mind you, this is not a critique of Hilo. Quite the opposite. In setting this series on Hawai‘i Island, my biggest desire (in addition to crafting a compelling mystery story) was to bring to readers a picture of what the place is truly like—not for tourists, but for those who actually live here.
| My beautiful neighborhood |
“Local style” is a phrase commonly heard in Hawai‘i, and means something that is typical of the way people do things in the islands. Kicking off your rubber slippahs and leaving them scattered about the front porch, eating Spam musubi for lunch, and throwing the “shaka” to say “thank you” or “hey!” are all examples of local style. The phrase signifies casual comfort, sharing food, and respecting local culture. And since this new book is set in Valerie and Kristen’s small neighborhood in Hilo and concerns the relationships between (and disputes among) the people who live there, Murder, Local Style seemed the perfect title for the story.
So, if anything, this is a love letter to my adopted town. For in the end (no spoiler here; this is after all a cozy mystery), we see how a small community in distress can come together to bring a killer to justice and restore order to their beloved neighborhood.
And yes, there’s plenty of beautiful Hawaiian culture, delicious food, and aloha spirit along the way!
| Hilo Farmers' Market |
Readers: For a chance to win a signed copy of Murder, Local Style, answer this question: Do you live in a close-knit neighborhood, and if so, are there disputes between the residents? (Sorry, US only.)
About Murder, Local Style:
It’s been an eventful transition, but retired caterer Valerie Corbin and her wife Kristen are finally settling into life on the Big Island of Hawai’i. Val’s even joined the neighborhood orchid society to make some new friends. So when she’s asked to step in to cater their latest social event, as the newbie of the group she can’t exactly say no.
But what should have been a straightforward gig is soon a dining disaster when the food from the event poisons and kills the society president. As Val herself becomes a suspect in the murder investigation, she’s determined to uncover the truth. Who would want to kill the mild-mannered president of the orchid society? Turns out the list is longer than a celebrity chef's tasting menu. Apparently some of the residents did not “love thy neighbor.” Can she reveal the killer’s identity before they strike again?
Bio: Leslie Karst is the Agatha, Lefty, and Macavity Award-nominated author of the Orchid Isle Mysteries, the Sally Solari culinary mysteries, and the memoir, “Justice is Served: A Tale of Scallops, the Law,and Cooking for RBG.” When not writing, you’ll find her cooking, cycling, gardening, and observing cocktail hour promptly at five o’clock. Leslie and her wife and their Jack Russell mix split their time between Hilo, Hawai‘i and Santa Cruz, California.



Congratulations, Leslie, on your newest book . . . what an intriguing premise for a story; I'm looking forward to reading "Murder, Local Style" . . . .
ReplyDeleteNo disputes in our little neighborhood in the Pine Barrens [at least, none that I'm aware of]; just friends watching out for each other . . . .
Lol, Joan.And glad to hear you all watch our for each other!
DeleteI always enjoy reading about folks in different settings, especially warm ones. I live in a small neighborhood in Vermont where winter seems endless. Our neighbors all pretty much get along except for disagreements about garden/lawn ornaments - what's considered good taste by one is shunned by another. I shudder every time I walk past our neighbor's granite turtle.
ReplyDeleteHa! We actually have a cement turtle in our front yard in California. And they're very popular here in Hilo, too--the "honu," i.e., green sea turtles.
DeleteMy brand new neighborhood in a 55+ community in Ocala, Florida is very close-knit as we all moved here from other places around the same time and immediately became friends. There have not been any disputes thus far in the 16 months we’ve lived here. Yet, my mind went immediately to who the victim in a cozy murder would likely be!
ReplyDeleteSounds like my kind of neighborhood, Brenda--ha!
DeleteWaving a big hi to my pal, Leslie, and congratulations on the new book! My quiet street is only one block long, but I wouldn't say it's particularly close-knit. There are some deep political divides, but neighbors do help each other out in case of need.
ReplyDeleteHey back atcha, Edith! Glad to hear your neighbors are there for you, even if you have political divides. We need more of that these days...
DeleteLeslie, your photos are beautiful and I”m looking forward to reading “Murder,Local Style “! I do not live in a close knit neighborhood but we have become friends our neighbors in either side and across the street and we do look our for each other-we shovel driveways when people are in vacation, go on walks together, attend birthday parties, sometimes have cocktails on the deck together. Our disputes are small, usuallly me muttering under my breath about the drafted leaf blowers. 😊
ReplyDeleteUgh. Don't get me started about leaf blowers. I so wish they'd ban the gasoline-powered ones, at least.
DeleteLove this article and I don't think my new neighborhood is close-knit. Congrats on your book release.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Dru! And I know you've only been in your new neighborhood for a while, so you never know what might happen as you get to know folks better!
DeleteI currently live in a housing development in an area that hosts three military bases, so there is a lot of people moving in and out and little chance to truly get to know one's neighbors. When our children were young, we lives in an isolated part of a small town so we knew most of our neighbors -- some far better than others, but our kids knew the names of every dog in the area and every house that they came from -- even if they did not know the names of the owners, because that's what kids do. When I was young, we lived in a close-knit section of a small town. Every one knew everyone else and would often socialize. We knew the good with the bad -- who drank too much, who was fooling around, who to trust and who not to trust, what kids opened the fire hydrants and flooded the street, what kid playing with matches accidently burnt their house down, which people were not playing with a full deck, and what person put out the eye of another with a dead squirrel at a community meeting. And the people in my part of town watched out and protected one another. It wasn't a bad way to live.
ReplyDeleteOkay, Jerry, hold up. You HAVE to elaborate on why someone brought a dead squirrel to a community meeting! Don't leave us hanging, dude!
Delete"person put out the eye of another with a dead squirrel at a community meeting"
DeleteNow that could be a motive for a cozy murder mystery.
I second this motion!
DeleteAnd even if you did bring a dead squirrel to a community meeting, how the heck could you put someone's eye out with it? Was it frozen? Yikes!
DeleteCongratulations on the new book -- it looks great! I currently live in a neighborhood of retirement condos and we've only been here a year. I would call it less than close knit, but at the same time very friendly.
ReplyDeletePrior to moving here we lived in the same house in a suburban subdivision for almost 30 years. That neighborhood was more close knit. Conflicts tended to be about people driving too fast on the main street through the neighborhood or kids behaving unsafely. Back during Covid someone renovated what had been a rundown old dive bar just outside the neighborhood and, taking advantage of the more relaxed zoning requirements of Covid, created a big beer garden outside. Once Covid ended, they started bringing in live entertainment on the weekends. There was a lot of conflict in the neighborhood about whether this was blessing or curse. Many appreciated the opportunity to walk over for a drink or even enjoy music wafting into their yards, but there were some who considered it noise pollution and were always angry. The bar owner worked really hard at finding the right volume level and was diligent about making the musicians stop at 10 p.m. I believe it is still a point of contention today, though less than it was at first.
It’s tough to balance the good of being close to amenities with the potential noise and traffic issues. Glad to hear the owner is listening and trying to be a good neighbor.
DeleteYes, live music is often a problem among neighbors. We have college kids in the house behind us in California who play music in their backyard, which I wouldn't mind too much if they were any good, lol.
DeleteHi Leslie, Congrats on the book. It is only today that I put your face together with you books! I heard you speak at Bouchercon, I think, and I hung on every word. Small towns: Yes, I live in what is called a small town--Ridgefield, Connecticut--which is where I set my Deadly Deadlines mysteries for all the same reasons you spoke of. There are many close knit neighborhoods and it's a picture perfect place just waiting for a tarnishing murder and then of course, all good things restored once the bad get is caught. I can't wait to read your book--actually I'm going to start with Book One.
ReplyDeleteHi, Gerri! So glad you enjoyed whatever I said at Bouchercon, lol! And yes, nothing like a close-knit neighborhood for a juicy murder mystery!
DeleteLeslie, your neighborhood looks wonderful, thanks for sharing the photos. On my one and only trip to Hawaii my husband left me for half a day so he could go up in a helicopter to photograph/tape the volcano, so I rented a car to explore Hilo-side on my own. I got fairly far north, stopped for a bite, and ended up having a delightful conversation with a group of locals who introduced me to Spam and malasadas. To get there I had to drive through at least four distinctly different climate zones, which simply awed me. Have always wanted to return.
ReplyDeleteOur neighborhood has completely changed in the seven years we have lived in this house. One by one, nearly every home has been sold and new families moved in. Two to four more will be changing in the next year or two, for various reasons. Since we live on a road, not a street with sidewalks, it's not an easy thing to meet the neighbors, especially since those on our north side all live in a different neighborhood. But before, everyone on that street were very close-knit, having mostly all lived there since the early 1990's. And they were NOT happy we were building a home right behind them, when they had enjoyed the privacy offered by OUR land behind them for almost 30 years. I can think of any number of reasons for murder now, come to think of it. She said, darkly.
So glad you got to see and enjoy Hilo and our beautiful Big Island, Karen! And yes, folks can get pretty testy over changes to their neighborhood, even if they're perfectly legal and even expected. We were upset when a house across the street from us burned down and they replaced it with a two-story building that blocked out view of Maunakea. But as Tony Soprano used to say, "Whadya gonna do?" (Oh, right--murder!)
DeleteHi Leslie, I've read many of your Sally Solari books, but haven't picked up the Orchid Isle series yet. I'm looking forward to it. Your neighborhood sounds great!
ReplyDeleteMy neighborhood is somewhere in the middle between close and distant. I would love to be closer to people, but know that as a older person who is both retired and curious, I may come across as someone who is a bit too pushy or, as my son says, "needs to stop peering out the window".My next door neighbor to the north is the best neighbor I've had. He's friendly with everyone and quick to share the neighborhood news. We ask each other for favors, and I loved hanging with his girls when they were still at home. I'm friendly with the woman on the other side, and during the pandemic, suggested a glass of wine on the deck, but she and her husband didn't seem interested. Others I wave at. A few weeks ago, I introduced myself to a neighbor a couple of blocks down. When she told me her dog's name, it took me a couple of takes to realize that she was saying, "Free Gaza". I'll definitely remember that!
Her dog's name was Free Gaza? Depending on the dog's age I wonder what it was before she changed it?
DeleteHa! You sound like me, Gillian. I'm always peering out the window at my neighbors, and then ducking back so they don't see that I'm watching them. One of the reasons I so love the movie "Rear Window."
DeleteAloha Leslie, I love the Hawaiian Islands and have been to all of them except Lanai & Molokai.
ReplyDeleteAround 1977 my sister went on to Honolulu on her spring break during her senior year of college (Oregon State), with her roommates, fell in love with a guy she met at a disco, and decided when you are in paradise why leave? She's been there ever since (still with the guy after 40 years and they have a lovely family).
My brother also headed to the North Shore of Oahu (around the same time) to "major" in surfing.
Our last trip we went to the Big Island and I loved Hilo, My favorite day out was visiting a local coffee grower.
Hub and I have lived in the same neighborhood for 50+ years. But it's not the same house - a few years ago we torn down the old house and built a new one. Over the years our ocean view has been diminished but that is to be expected when property values are so high - instead of moving people they just add on (which means adding a second story).
Sounds like your family has a real affinity for Hawai'i! "Major" in surfing--ha!
DeleteAnd my parents were married in Honolulu in 1948 before it was a state. My dad was stationed in Kaneohe. They honeymooned at the Royal Hawaiian when it was one of only two hotels in Waikiki!
DeleteThe Big Island is my favorite and I love how your books provide a virtual trip between our actual ones.
ReplyDeleteI live in a 248-unit, 2-high rise complex. I confess to having violent thoughts about the people on our floor who had a party with a live band during COVID lockdown. Any mystery set in our building would probably revolve around the former general manager, who happily left us a couple of months ago.
Oy. That sounds awful on so many levels. And my question is, does anyone know what happened to the general manager....? :)
DeleteWelcome back to Jungle Reds, Leslie! Congratulations on your newest novel. Since I already have ALL of your books, please do not add me to the giveaway. Great nugget for a mystery with the murder of a society president in your novel based on real life experiences of dealing with annoyances like unwanted noises from leaf blowers. I am not a fan of leaf blowers because they are not good for the environment. I remember the actor Peter Graves (Mission IMpossible) and his wife started a petition in Beverly Hills, California to ban leaf blowers!
ReplyDeleteAwesome that you and your wife live in Hawaii. Did you ever meet Michelle and Barack? I think they have a home in Hawaii. I visited Hawaii with my family many years ago when I was a child. I remember the Kona planation farm where they sold coffee. I remember the glass bottom boat where we could watch sea life under the boat. People were friendlier to my Mom because she looked Hawaiian while they were standoffish towards my blue eyed blonde Dad. I remember how kind they were to my 80 year old great aunt and her husband.
We never saw Barack or Michelle, alas, but when they would come to the islands every year at Christmastime, Air Force Two would be parked at the Hilo airport while they went on to O'ahu, and we'd drive down there to wave at the plane.
DeleteJulia, great interview today! May I ask if there will be a guest post about Deaf History since April is Deaf History month? I just saw this amazing story on social media about the connection between the space flight of Artemis and deaf coeds from a Deaf university.
ReplyDeleteThank you in advance.
That sounds very interesting Diana!
DeleteLeslie, Congratulations on the new Orchid Isle mystery! Here in New England we tend to keep our neighbors at what I'd call a neighborly distance. As in "good fences make good neighbors"... and in weather like this winter's blizzard we're here for each other, shovel in hand. (My one visit to Hawaii started in Hilo and I loved it. Just walking the garden around our little hotel was memorable.)
ReplyDeleteYes, I've heard that New Englanders tend to be more stand-offish than us West Coasters, but extremely helpful when needed! And in Hilo, folks are as friendly as can be. The aloha spirit really is a thing.
DeleteSo wonderful to see you! we recently had new people build a whole new house very close to ours, in a place where if anyone had asked me, which they did not, there was not enough room for another house. I have been enraged over this, quietly, for a year. But the one thing it did was bring out all the other adjacent neighbors, equally and ragged, and we all banded together in our loathing for the new house. Nothing happened as a result, and the new people are here, and I’m sure they are lovely.
ReplyDeleteOtherwise, we live in a typical New England neighborhood, where everyone is polite and waves on the street, but I’m not sure I know everyone’s names…
That is so frustrating Hank. We have that problem in our area. The are over sized homes set in residential neighborhoods where the lots are 60x100 sq. ft and most homes are under 3,000 sq. ft.
DeleteTwo down the street have new built homes well over 8,000 sq. ft. And right now as I type, the house next door which is under construction will be close to 4,000 sq. ft when they finish in Dec. Fortunately we love the young family who've lived there for about ten years. This is their dream home to continue to raise their family so we forgive them!! Maybe they'll even let us use their new pool.
I'm thinking there's going to be a book about this one of these days, Hank.... Or at least I hope so!
DeleteThe book looks delicious Leslie! and so does your neighborhood. Do they know you've set a murder mystery there:)?? Regarding neighborhoods, we were remembering last night that my first poisoned key lime pie was eaten in the condo where we now live!
ReplyDeleteYikes, luckily neither you or your hub ate it!
DeleteWas that Appetite for Murder Lucy?
DeleteHa! Yes, as a matter of fact, many of them do. And my dedication in the book says, "To my Hilo neighbors, none of whom (to my knowledge) are murderers."
DeleteAnd I love that about the pie!!
Hi Leslie!! You know I'm a fan and I just ordered my book! Can't wait to see what Val and Kristen are up to. I loved the photos of your neighborhood. Now I'll be able to picture it while I'm reading.
ReplyDeleteAw...thanks so much, dear Debs!
DeleteI love the photos too Leslie. Would love to hear more about your neighborhood.
ReplyDeleteRead the new book and you'll learn a lot about it! (Though there have been no actual murders to date in my neighborhood, thank goodness.)
DeleteCongrats, Leslie. Yes, Ligonier is a small town and yes, all the associated small-town disputes and haggling. Everything from the outside music hall built by one of the B&Bs in town to the location and vendors allowed into the summer outdoor market. Always something. But it's fun - and great ideas for murder!
ReplyDeleteNothing like a small neighborhood for a juicy murder mystery, Liz. We're all St. Mary Mead!
DeleteHi Leslie! Please don’t enter me in the giveaway as I won Waters of Destruction through JRW. (Thanks!) Congratulations on your newest book release. I will bring my copy to Bouchercon so I can, hopefully, get you to sign it there.
ReplyDeleteI grew up in the kind of neighborhood you described, where kids played out front and the parents all knew each other to lend a hand or offer a drink after a long day. We live in a neighborhood that goes all out decorating for Christmas; that’s the time when I am reminded of my childhood sense of neighbors. Unfortunately, the rest of the year we’re all busy with our own lives, it seems. — Pat S
Yes, around the holidays is definitely the time a lot of neighbors get more neighborly, which is lovely. And during disasters. After the big earthquake in Santa Cruz back in 1989, we got to know a lot of neighbors we'd never even met before, because everyone was helping everyone else.
DeleteI just wanted to let everyone know Leslie was excited to visit and chat with you all, but there's a little matter of that six hour time difference between the east coast and Hawai'i! (As an historical note, the Hawai'i-Aleutian Time Zone used to be 6 1/2 hours behind the east coast, but it got bumped up to an even 6 hours, aka GMT -10) after WWII.)
ReplyDeleteAnd yes, I'm finally here! (It's not even 9am yet here in Hawai'i). Fascinating fact, Julia--I had no idea! And thank you so much for hosting me today--I love the Jungle Red Writer family!!
DeleteConstruction equipment, lawn mowers, leaf blowers, all universal annoyances. Add to that boys with firecrackers. And overly vocal dogs! But a little of that will not provoke me to murder. That is just neighborhoods today. Every neighborhood I've lived in has had some "issues" that would cause us to roll our eyes and laugh with other neighbors about it.
ReplyDeleteAah, the dogs. Our back yard catty-corner neighbors had (have?) one of those dogs. Big loud bark, left in the yard until at least 10 pm, owners didn't care. Drove me absolutely homicidal (fictionally, mind you). I turned the situation into a murderous short story (getting rid of the owner, not the dog) that had an unfortunate twist at the end! ("Bye-Bye, Jojo" in EQMM March/April 2022 issue.)
DeleteDon't get me started about firecrackers. It's like a war zone on my street here in Hilo on New Year's Eve, and my poor dog goes nuts with fear. Aaaargh....
Delete