Tuesday, November 28, 2023

Food In Mysteries

 RHYS BOWEN:  I was being interviewed recently when the interiewer said "You have a lot of food in your mysteries. You must love to cook."

I'd never thought about this before or consciously made sure I included food in the books. The answer is that I do not love to cook. After fifty years of having to put a meal on the table every night, thinking up the menu, shopping for it, preparing it and then washing up the dishes I have lost interest in cooking. However I do like to eat well. What I'd really like is Mrs. Pattmore, or Mrs. Bridges so that I could summon them to the morning room and ask what they recommended for dinner that night.

"Oh, I'd say we start with the quail in aspic, my lady," they'd reply. "Then the turban of sole and a nice leg of lamb and a summer pudding to finish with."  Food must have been less expensive in those days! Actually I know it was less expensive because even working class families all had a Sunday roast, all bought fish and chips and even oysters. 

But it's true I do like to read about food. I'm excited that Martin Walker has just come out with a cook book for his Perigord region of France. I think how characters approach eating reveals a lot about them. If a lone male detective snatches a hamburger on his way to the crime scene you know he's due for heart problems in the future. If my spinster sleuth invites suspects to tea and we witness the bone china, the tiny cucumber sandwiches and freshly baked scones we know the sort of meticulous lady she is. (and we enjoy that tea vicariously).




Lady Georgie in the Royal Spyness books started out by fleeing from her Scottish castle and coming to London with no money and no real life skills (she knows where to seat a bishop at a dinner table. This is hardly marketable or useful unless you know a bishop.) She struggles to survive living on beans on toast, that British staple for those with little money or students in rented rooms. And so it is food that provides the contrast, that shows us how far she has come by book 17, THE PROOF OF THE PUDDING, that came out this month.

Georgie now lives in her godfather's lovely mansion, she is married, expecting a baby, AND she has just acquired a French chef. She took a gamble with him, not having tasted his cooking but it turns out to be wonderful. She gives a dinner party. Everyone is impressed. And I... I get to write about all those exquisite dishes. Duck breast a l'orange, crab mousse, chilled asparagus soup, floating islands and berry tarts (the latter play a pivotal role in the story).

One of the things I love most about going to France, which we do once a year, is the French attitude to food. They like to buy everything fresh from the market. Local food, picked that morning. There are shops that just sell cheese, shops that just sell charcuterie and boulangeries, where baguettes are always just warm from the oven. And my favorite, the patiseries. Every tiny pastry a work of art. Last fall I celebrated my birthday on a cruise up the Seine with my daughter Jane and son in law Tom. The brought back a box of tiny pastries, each exquisite. A dozen had cost ten euros! A baguette costs one Euro. 

As I'm writing this I'm thinking when can I go back? When can I have crepes and mussels and have to make the hard choice which pastries to choose?

I started to write this about food in mysteries. Somehow I wandered into France and French food. But I'd like to hear your thoughts. Does reading about food detract from the plot of the mystery for you? Or do you love to savor meals with the characters?



40 comments:

  1. Reading about food does not detract from the mystery at all . . . but I often wish I could share some of those delicious-sounding treats!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I always love reading about food, and I usually find myself writing about it, too, even when it's not a foodie mystery. Just can't help it!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I am a foodie so I love reading about food in mysteries. Culinary cozies are some of my favourite reads.

    I enjoy it when food scenes enhance the story's setting. Think of all the wonderful meals Gamache & friends ate at Three Pines while discussing the case and looking at suspects!

    ReplyDelete
  4. That's so true, Grace--I love the meals Olivier and Gabri serve in their café and the extraordinary coziness of the place! And I agree with you, Rhys, that what characters cook (or buy) and eat can tell you a lot about them. The lunches and lunchtime conversations that Guido Brunetti has with his wife and children in Donna Leon's mysteries, for example, are always a treat.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. KIm, I just listened to Leon's Death at La Fenice, and one of the scenes takes place in "the best restaurant in Venice", with a terrorizing woman ordered the customers to eat what she chooses. The fish was branzino, and Guido's companion was not a fan, so he was hiding bites in his napkin.

      Delete
    2. Oh yes. I’ve read all Donna Leon’s and when I’m in Venice I have to seek out coffee shops and sandwich bars she’s mentioned

      Delete
  5. Margaret S. HamiltonNovember 28, 2023 at 7:37 AM

    I'm a great fan of Martin Walker's Bruno, Chief of Police, and the varied and glorious descriptions of food in his books, from Bruno gathering eggs and salad ingredients and whisking up an impromptu supper to a town event roasting a wild boar. We visited Dordogne in 2022 and the meats, cheeses, and wines didn't disappoint.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Dordogne is one of my favorite places. We rented a little house in Sarlat once. The market was heaven

      Delete
  6. Replies
    1. Wouldn’t that be fun! A little house and shopping at the market!

      Delete
  7. What a delicious post to wake up to. Yum.

    ReplyDelete
  8. As with all things, it depends. Four straight pages describing nothing but food will make me start skimming so I can get back to the mystery. But if your characters are having dinner and talk of the food falls neatly into the scene, no problem. As you said, Rhys, I think a character's approach to food can be very revealing.

    ReplyDelete
  9. What a beautiful teapot in that photo!
    You are right about Louise Penny and her characters and their food. Not only do they have a superb repast, but to me, it means that they sit, and take time, and really ponder what is going on and where to go from here. It also shows the caring and ability to comfort from Gabri and Olivier who are always there with food and time and peace – oh and course Ruth!
    Kit is the comforter in Debs books, even though he is a child. In Joy Ellis’s books, Nikki Galena’s partner in crime and life Joe Easter usually provides a comforting meal – often lasagna which he makes and freezes – when they need it most. Maisie Dobbs often comes home to a bowl of soup from her landlady.
    I read a lot of books set in WW1 & 2, and feel that when food or lack there-of is in the book, that even if it is only sub conscious, we get to understand the time and place. As Rhys says, there seemed to be a lot more food in some of the times gone by. Maybe it was because more often than not, we provided our own or were close to the source.
    I recommend Jennifer Ryan’s book ‘The Kitchen Front’ to give an idea of what was available in WW2 and how it needed to be cooked.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have a lot of WW11 cookbooks, some from my mother in law. So inventive about what to do with the strangest things

      Delete
  10. What I love most about reading is learning things. Not only do I learn something about a character and a story through food and meals but , over the years, I learned tons of things about periods of time, traditions, countries and religions from what people are eating and how they are eating.

    And Rhys, I loved The Proof of the Pudding
    Danielle

    ReplyDelete
  11. Rhys: "I'm excited that Martin Walker has just come out with a cook book for his Perigord region of France."
    Me too. I just saw the cookbook in my local bookstore and it is lovely. It isn't just a cookbook but takes your through the lives of the authors, walking through markets with them, etc. It's just lovely and you somehow feel transported to the Perigord region. It's Bruno's Cookbook: Recipes and Traditions from a French Country Kitchen by Martin Walker and his wife Julia Watson.

    I'm a fan of cozy's that revolve around food. I think back to Agatha Christie, and the other many great mystery writers and don't recall much to-do about food. I do remember Dorothy Sayers did write about food and poisonous foods such as mushrooms. So intriguing.

    ReplyDelete
  12. The Proof of the Pudding is now my favorite Georgie book, Rhys. And I so agree about food in books--buying, preparing, eating, cleaning up after--any and all of those details can enrich a story. I think one of the first books in which I noticed foods was Mary Stewart's novel MADAM, WILL YOU TALK. Set in post-WWII France, two characters--Charity and Louise, set out for a holiday in France--and each meal is revealing. A hurried omelet roadside to a sumptuous meal in a fancy hotel in Marseilles--those food descriptions and the way they tie into the plot stick with me to this day. One of my favorite lines: "Bifteck, Louise; Louise, bifteck" when the two ladies were discussing the food they might have for their first meal after all the deprivations of the war.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I read that book the other day after all those years and it holds up well. ( even though the motive was a bit sketchy)

      Delete
    2. Off topic a bit, but at last month's book club, we read a book which at best got a 5/10 and even went down to a 1. Several people had read this author before, and the consensus was this book and author although being relatively modern (2004) did not hold up to time. I had the month previously read a book written in 1950, and set in 1920, which held up. I wondered how many books were such, and thought wouldn't that be a good topic of discussion.
      Back to the main topic - the Shepherd's Pie is up though I think it is properly Cottage Pie as there is no lamb in it - mores the pity.

      Delete
    3. Ooh, thanks for this, Flora. I'm going to have to reread this one. I reread My Brother Michael not too long ago and thought it held up well.

      Delete
  13. The first book I most distinctly remember reading about food, and how it informed a character, was in a Beany Malone book. Beany is a teenager who has to help raise her siblings after her mother dies, and she's in charge of cooking, along with most of the other household chores. For forgotten reasons, Beany is down to some cans her little brother removed labels from, so she decides to just open one, and whatever is in the can will be dinner. And it turns out to be something pretty useless, like pumpkin pie filling.

    That scene tells you everything you need to know about the character: her problem-solving skills, her management skills, her adaptability, and her ingenuity. Because they do, indeed, have a meal somehow.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Susan Nelson-HolmdahlNovember 28, 2023 at 1:27 PM

      Karen, I read the Beanie Malone books in the late seventies, and they held up well. They were set in the fifties, but did not seem dated. The only thing that stood out to me a middle schooler then was that the pill was not yet available. Whereas it was easily obtained in California, even for teen-agers. I really liked the books, but could not understand why Beanie had to do it all. I grew up in a household where both parents worked and shared the household chores,

      Delete
    2. Susan, I read the Malone books in the early 1960's, probably around 1964. The Pill was most definitely not available yet, and most of the families we knew had a dad who worked. (Not at our house; my mother worked at an insurance company for most of my childhood.)

      Delete
    3. Susan Nelson-HolmdahlNovember 29, 2023 at 1:15 AM

      Times changed a lot in those few years. However, even today California and Ohio might as well be in different countries, the culture and social norms are radically different. Both parents worked in more than fifty percent of the households in the Bay Area where I lived, also known as Silicon Valley.
      I remembered the unlabeled can scene very clearly.
      I do not remember what food she ultimately found to serve.

      Delete
  14. I love reading about food. There's a scene in one of Heyer's novels where the heroine has bread and butter, cold meat, and tea. It's not something I would ordinarily go for but I want it every time I read that scene. As for the scrumptious Italian food in Donna Leon's mysteries...yum!

    As for French breads... We have a friend who lives in a small town in France. Just 50 yards out his back gate there's a boulangerie. Imagine -- practically outside one's door, a bakery with fabulous French breads and croissants, some plain, some au chocolat, etc.! When in France, I can eat all the bread I like and never gain an ounce. And in Italy I can have pizza and pasta. Not so in the US, alas.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What a lucky friend Barbara! I remember being at a small inn in the south of France and close by was a wonderful bakery. We would walk over in the morning and could smell the freshly baked goods before we even got inside.

      Delete
    2. When I stayed with my sister in law in France I’d go to the Boulangerie every morning to get bread and croissants. After a few days the woman said “ attendez madame” and darted back to the kitchen to give me croissants fresh from the oven. That’s how much they value freshness

      Delete

  15. Yes, yes, yes! Food in mysteries makes such a difference… It’s a perfect way to convey setting and character too, right?

    ReplyDelete
  16. I love reading about food in a mystery. I think it adds so much detail to the story. aprilbluetx at yahoo dot com

    ReplyDelete
  17. Characters, just like *real people* need to eat! So at a minimum you need food in the story to make them feel realistic. And then they can get hungry. Or get an upset stomach... And it's a great way to *show* who characters are... the one who eats Wonderbread and Peter Pan Peanut Butter and Fluff sandwich versus the one who eats dried seaweed smeared with Kefir. Who would Nero Wolfe be without Fritz? Or Kinsey Milhone without Rosie?

    ReplyDelete
  18. Love to savor meals with characters. Like people, characters in novels have to eat. The food choices, I think, show the personalities of characters. I remember the cheese shops in Paris, especially the goat cheese, which I could eat (not cow cheese). Yum.

    Loved the scenes with Pierre the new French chef. Did your children help with meal preparation when they were little or did you do all of the work?

    Diana

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I did it all! They were all competitive swimmers-/ morning practice at 6 then after school, as well as ballet, plays etc

      Delete
  19. I love reading about food! Characters who eat make them more relatable.

    DebRo

    ReplyDelete
  20. Oh, dear, I'm going to have to set another book in Paris. :) I think food dictates so much about a novel's characters, whether they are affluent or not or even if they have a healthy relationship with food or a toxic one. And I adore reading about food in your books, Rhys, as the historic aspects are fascinating.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I checked out a book on CD by John Grisham, The Broker, about 20 years ago to keep me company on a long drive. A good portion of the book was set in Italy and there were marvelous descriptions of food. (The narrator was marvelous, too.) I arrived at my destination ravenous! — Pat S

    ReplyDelete
  22. I love to read about food in mysteries (or other books, including cookbooks). I fell in love with Danish Havarti in a PD James book. I learned some delightful early 20th century cocktails compliments of Lord Whimsey, even Georgie's beans and toast led me to seek out Heinz and homemade dark bread. Yep, I'm impressionable!

    ReplyDelete
  23. Something I never want to read in another mystery: "Just the thought of all that blood spoiled her appetite. She could not continue to eat the sumptuous meal before her, and the delicate, sugary pastries were revolting." What a waste! Don't put her in front of that fabulous food if she can't eat it. Lenita

    ReplyDelete
  24. I love reading about food in books, and you alway do such a good job using it to show both character and setting. Loved the food in Proof of the Pudding, so historically interesting!

    ReplyDelete
  25. I love hearing about food in books. Especially new to me treats. I file them away for when I travel and can sample!

    ReplyDelete