Saturday, July 5, 2025

What's My Brand?

JULIA SPENCER-FLEMING: Branding. When I was a tiny tot, the only time I heard that word was while watching Bonanza or Big Valley, and it referred to Hoss or Heath ropin’ and wranglin’ a heifer and impressing the ranch mark into the poor thing’s hide. (It never seemed to bother the cow, but it’s not like she was asked her opinion.)

 


 

When I started my writing career, the concept of an author brand was just taking off, and it was strictly limited to a name. (No hot irons involved, thank goodness.) James Patterson was a brand. Danielle Steele was a brand. It meant readers were so devoted to what you wrote, they’d buy the current book, and the next, and the next, not knowing anything about what was between the covers. For a few extraordinary writers, their characters were their brand: a Jack Reacher thriller, a Dirk Pitt adventure.

 

While both those types of branding still exist (and THANK YOU, dear readers who buy one of our books automatically!!) the world has changed since the early aughts. Facebook, Instagram, Tik-Tok, YouTube - they’re all major forces in connecting with fans and developing new readers. And they all have one thing in common: visual imagery. Even author blogs and newsletters have gotten more image-heavy; those old plain-text emails you signed up for in 2000 are long gone.

 

Right now, with a new book out in five months, I’m working on a brand new website, a new email, and how to tie everything together on other social media platforms. My problem? I honestly don’t know my brand! Ideally, I should be able to put together several words encompassing feelings, images, and elements of my fiction in a way I can translate into, well, all those things online I just listed. For instance, everyone’s favorite, Louise Penny. I would say, “Canada, literary, well-travelled, small town.” And sure enough, if you go to her website or sign up for her newsletter (you should, it’s delightful) you see images and writing that conveys those very concepts.

 

Reds, do you have a solid idea of your “brand?” How did you come up with it? 

 

HANK PHILLIPPI RYAN: Ha ha ha. NO. I do not. You guys tell me, okay? I would LOVE, truly love, to hear it.

 

HALLIE EPHRON: Brand? I have never thought about my writing in terms of creating a brand. I mean, I know we’re writing “genre” fiction, but we’re storytellers and the stories we tell don’t come out of an advertising machine and none of them are cookie-cutter. They come from somewhere inside us, and I suppose the extent to which they’re similar to one another, that goes toward creating a “brand.” 

 

For me? My brand would be *creepy but not icky* *suburban* “domestic suspense* and *stuff that could really happen.* Doesn’t sound much like clever branding. But there you are.

 

JENN McKINLAY: I wish I had a brand but I’m all over the place in different genres and whatnot. I haven’t a clue. Anyone? Hit me with what you think my brand is, readers! I’m all ears.

 

JULIA: I'm not sure how to put all your books together as a brand, Jenn, but I think "brightly colored" and "fun" are definitely in your portfolio. 

 

LUCY BURDETTE: My brand would probably be Key West, food, friends and family, murder. With a good dash of psychology stirred in. And the obligatory pets, especially cats. (Sorry Lottie.). When you pick up a Key West book, it’s reasonable to assume that that’s what you’ll be reading. 

 

My question is supposing I want to take a tack that doesn’t fit into this “brand.” THE INGREDIENTS OF HAPPINESS, for example, and quite possibly UNSAFE HAVEN. Neither one takes place in Key West. Although the food remains, it’s not the same central character that it was in the other books. Hmmm…

 

So I wonder if a person really wants to make a switch, would it be best to decide which two or three of these qualities will fit the new project too? Or should we quit worrying about our brands–leave that to the marketing gurus–and write what we want to write?

 

RHYS BOWEN:  Julia, I feel your brand is the Upstate New York version of Louise’s books. Small town, cast of characters we come to know and love, evil in the most bucolic of settings. Hank, you are definitely edgy domestic suspense.

 

I know I have a brand because one of my publishers turned down the proposal for In Farleigh Field because “it was too far from her brand.”  

And if you look at my covers they definitely reflect a brand: the Royal Spyness and Molly Murphy both easily identifiable and clearly reflect the tone of the book. 

 But I’m not happy with a writer being tied to a ‘brand”. As you know, my stand-alones range from tense thriller to  warm historical. The only thing that links them is that they are all set in the past. I applaud Jenn for reaching across genres.  I read across genres, don’t you? Many readers do.

 

DEBORAH CROMBIE:  I never thought about having a brand, but I guess it would be British mystery/police procedural/contemporary. If we add “couples investigating” and take off the “British” that brand would include your books, Julia. Maybe we need to form our own brand!

 

JULIA: I can see that, Debs! "Clever couples, cottages, cultural critique and carnage." What do you think, dear readers? Help us out and let us know what words or images you'd use to describe our brands!

31 comments:

  1. I'm not quite sure why it has become so important to attach labels to everything. I think Lucy is right when she suggests "we quit worrying about our brands . . . and write what we want to write." Honestly, dear Reds, I suppose I fall into that group of readers who buy/read a book simply because of the author's name; I don't need to define you with a "brand."
    That said . . . based solely on the books you've written, Julia, I think I'd choose mystery, small town, church, faith . . . .

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yeah, it's impossible to give JENN a brand since she writes so many different series. And I agree it's also hard to pigeon-hole the REDS that write both series & stand-alones.

    HANK often calls her book "cat-and-mouse suspense" to narrow down the type of suspense she writes but is that a brand? I kinda like HALLIE's "creepy but not icky" but that's not a brand.

    JULIA: Hmmm, I agree with RHYS' descriptor of your books but that doesn't work as a brand. Adirondack Noir?

    Geez, this is really hard!!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ugh, this is a topic I'm constantly bombarded with. I've been told that we all need a tagline to identify our brand. For a long time, mine was "Crime in the Country is just as deadly..." Then I started writing the Detective Honeywell mysteries which are set in Erie, PA, not in the country. My publisher used the line "Small Towns Hold Big Secrets," which I latched onto, because... hey, I didn't have to think it up. But I'm still searching for something catchy and more of a brand than a tagline. (Open to suggestions!)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Everybody's least-favorite topic, it appears. Julia, I like Grace's Adirondack Noir!

    It's not my favorite topic, either. I call my books gentle mysteries, and they all feature small towns, food, family, and furry (or feathered) friends, even my historicals (except for the one where I branched out and set in Boston), plus murder. But is that a brand?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mysteries with characters as cool as Jack Reacher with way better food isn't a brand? :D

      Delete
    2. True, Jay! I will always be in your debt for that fabulous description.

      Delete
  5. Replies
    1. But that descriptor does not help a first-time reader know what type of book the author writes.

      Delete
    2. Small-town, character driven

      Delete
  6. I don't think in terms of brands. Julia's books aren't actually set in the Adirondacks but in the foothills just south of the park. She captures them perfectly and whenever I drive through the area I think of Russ, Lyle, and the gang in their black and whites, and wonder if there is a Clare presiding in the local Episcopal church. When I recommend them up here I say something that includes: small town, rural, mystery, relationships. If a discussion ensues, I add moral questions, suspense, frozen wipers, and Stewart's coffee. (Selden)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. True, I knew that (I am a geographer). But I did a search of recent online reviews & that is where a few of them place Julia's books.

      Delete
    2. Of course. And it doesn't matter at all. Up here in the north country folks get most tetchy when we see anything north of Manhattan labeled "upstate New York." :) I myself would be more put off by a label of "noir." I avoid dark stories and somehow, despite all the murders, don't think of Julia's books as "noir." They are threaded with humor and warmth, and for those of us who live in similar conditions, countless flashes of recognition, starting from the moment we are introduced to Russ and his glasses fog over and blind him when he walks into the warm hospital. (Selden)

      Delete
    3. I'll change my agreement with noir. You're absolutely right, Selden. Noir is a "no thanks" category for me.

      Delete
    4. And Julia's books are always a "yes, please!"

      Delete
  7. Given how Jenn is always busy running from one book to a next whether it be writing, revising, promoting or whatever other process is involved in getting her book to market, perhaps the logo of her brand should be the White Rabbit from Alice in Wonderland?

    But in general terms, I'm not sure I could come up with brands for every one of the JRW writers. Like Rhys mentioned in her response I read across genres so it is more about the actual story than what clean-cut categorization they fit into for me.

    And I like Dru's response about your name being your brand.

    As for me, if I was going to have a brand to describe ME (since I'm not a writer of stuff on your bookstore shelves) it would be best to say, "Bitterly but occasionally witty or at least humorous sarcastic cynic".

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jenn is more like the pink Energizer Bunny.

      Delete
  8. Quick think, as we are out the door:
    Rewriting Louise Penny: Quebec, Complicated, Family, Food, Ongoing
    Debs: British procedural, ongoing, contemporary, Character oriented, Evolving
    Julia: Vermont or maybe Maine, Priest, Gritty, Character oriented, Evolving
    Jenn: Since I like some of her series and not really others, as an overview: Fun, Likeable characters, Easy
    Lucy: Key West, Food, Living on a boat, Good Characters

    ReplyDelete
  9. I tend to forego branded authors. Because it seems to pigeonhole the author into writing only one sort of character/book--and makes me think of authors who would have benefited from branching off into other characters/stories/genres. All their books blur into one for me and I stop reading their next new book. Taglines are fine with me--I'll pick up a book because the story sounds intriguing--or because I already know this author's ability to write a satisfying story and willingly follow them anywhere thy choose to go.

    ReplyDelete
  10. (He's in the bathroom - I am waiting. TMI?)
    What about for many of you 'Not a cozy, Not a thriller, But something for everyone else'. Include Paige Shelton's Alaska in there, and Julia Chapman. There also has to be a way to add great seniors (not just someone who is 60).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Margo, that is a description of the kind of books I enjoy the most! And yes, I ADORE Paige Shelton's Alaska.

      Delete
  11. Lucy has the right idea - stop thinking about a "brand' which is a totally artificial construct anyway, tell a good story, write a good book and the readers will read!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Feeling especially curmudgeon-ly this morning. When you say “brand”, I get this earworm : “ Little houses on the hillside, little houses made out of ticky-tacky, and they all look just the same.” Have a non-ticky-tacky day. Elisabeth

    ReplyDelete
  13. Julia, I can’t help you at all with this.
    I hate the concept of branding I think dehumanizing.
    It’s sad that the marketing moguls establish fashions that add to the author’s workload as if writing a book was not enough.
    Yes I’ll read every book an author will write but it’s not because they are a brand but because I love their writing and their stories.

    ReplyDelete
  14. It doesn’t really describe the content of your books, Hank, but I think your brand is Investigative reporter turned novelist

    ReplyDelete
  15. This is so interesting--capitalism seems to be demanding more and more from creative people. I thought about the book Yellowface and the requirements for daily social media posts by the author involved. I think you all could fall into the #mysteries with heart category.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I wonder if the idea of branding works best with titles and covers? For example, Laura Ingalls Wilder's LITTLE HOUSE books really took off when they were reissued with identical covers and artwork. Dick Francis's thrillers were popular for years but cracked the stratosphere in the U.S. in the 1980s when G. P. Putnam's Sons began publishing them in brightly colored hardcovers without artwork aside from the same stylized small horse, all the books identical except for the color of the jacket and the title... we'd always eagerly await "this year's Dick Francis." Do Sue Grafton's alphabet mysteries fit this premise? Just thinking aloud. (Selden)

    ReplyDelete
  17. Interesting question. When you mention branding, I think of Tom Clancy, Robert Ludlum, Clive Cussler, V.C. Andrews. Those folks whose writing topics were so consistent that the brand lasted long after their lives ended. To me, that is a brand. Make sense? Do you really want your work to be so predictable that it can be manufactured after your death? Sure, its great for your heirs' bank accounts, but is that how you want to be remembered? As someone who wrote so predictably that anyone could step in and take over? I say, be bold and let your brand be "Unpredictable, but always satisfying." -- Victoria

    ReplyDelete
  18. From Celia: Brands! It's too early for me to even try to tackle such an overwhelming topic. But luckily lots of minds focused have come up with some great words. This branding stuff rather reminds me of the '90's ands trying to grapple with the "elevator or cocktail" 30 second pitch for my business as a professional organizer. I never felt totally happy with whatever I spouted as all my clever words seemed to vanish when confronted at a networking gathering.

    Perhaps we are caught up in the moment and need to take a step back. All the Reds have published along with others in the Reds community. We are our own best branding agents as we share the books we love with friends and talk up the author. Perhaps that is all that is needed once the book with its great cover and best selling line is out there.

    ReplyDelete
  19. JULIA: This is going to be a long comment because I have so many thoughts here.....

    All of the Reds have written wonderful novels for many years. There is a variety from classical (cozy?) to historical to humorous to suspense/thriller. I agree with Celia that we are our own branding agents as we share books we love with friends. Instead of "branding", I think more in terms of book recommendations. It is hard for me to think of "author brands". I wonder if it applies to American publishers. I wonder if the idea of "author branding" also applies to the International Publishing community.

    Why on earth would authors need branding???? I never understood how "branding" applies to authors and books.

    When I think of "brand", I think of a certain brand of an automobile like the Herbie car (Volkswagon) or Maybelline cosmetics. When you go shopping at the market / grocery shop, there are many choices for the same item and you may like a certain brand so you buy that brand.

    One of the commenters said it is dehumanizing and I agree. This reminded me of my job search after graduating from Uni in the 1990s. The interviewers would ask questions like "What is your brand?" Yikes!

    Never thought of Danielle Steel as a "brand". I think of her novels as my "crying" books because I always find myself crying buckets while reading her novels and I need a handkerchief.

    Regarding Alexander McCall Smith novels, I always call his novels my "happy" novels because I feel content while reading his novels.

    ReplyDelete