LUCY BURDETTE: You
may well have read on Facebook that Penguin Random House is not renewing the
Key West foodie mystery series. Though I’m sad about this, I’m not taking the
news personally. Here’s why:
1.
I don’t think it has much to do with either the quality of the books or the
sales. Lots of mass-market cozy folks are ending up in the refugee boat with
me—it’s a mysterious corporate decision over which we have no control.
2.
It’s happened before and I’ve survived and thrived.
3.
I will most likely continue the series in another form in the future.
4.
The support and enthusiasm of readers has been a huge comfort!
But
I thought it might be interesting to look back on my reaction to the news that
the golf lovers’ mystery series was not getting renewed. (Hint: devastated.) I
called this essay “Character Assassination.”
Losing a special friend hurts, even if
you’re mourning a figment of your own imagination.
I’ve been getting to know my protagonist,
professional golfer Cassie Burdette, since scratching out the opening
paragraphs of my first mystery in January 1998. As with most fictional
detectives, Cassie wrestled with skeletons in her closet: her father’s
desertion, a melancholy, alcoholic mother, a fog of self-doubt. Ambivalence
infused her relationships with men and she tended to defer soul-searching in
favor of the anesthetic effects of Budweiser.
Notwithstanding these conflicts, I imagined Cassie eventually thriving
on the professional golf circuit through a combination of talent, spunk, and
the right friends.
With five golf mysteries in print by March
2006, Cassie and I have spent the better part of eight years together. I
finally talked her into starting psychotherapy (with the help of a couple of other
characters) to address her low self-esteem and self-destructive tendencies. She
began to play better golf, choose kinder men, drink less, and reconnect with
her dad.
![]() |
| Roberta/Lucy with LPGA golfer Kate Golden |
Meanwhile, researching Cassie’s world took
me on some amazing adventures. I spent most of my first (modest) advance paying
to compete in a real professional-amateur LPGA tournament so I could absorb the
correct ambience for book two.
And I played golf at Pinehurst, Palm Springs,
and in the Dominican Republic—all tax-deductible without stretching the IRS
code. I met and corresponded with professional golfers, and many fans—mystery
fans, golf fans, and best of all, fans of both. These people worried about
Cassie: how can she drink that much before a tournament? How can she eat like
that and stay in shape? Lose the boyfriend—he’s a bum! Over coffee, my friends
were more likely to ask what was new with Cassie, than with me. And reviewers
hailed Cassie as “a character readers can root for.”
I’d begun plotting the skeleton for the
sixth installment, involving a golf reality show, a hunky cop, and murder, of
course.
Then the word came from my editor: “We’d
rather see a new idea—the numbers just haven’t been that good…”
Surprised or not, I was flooded with sadness
and disappointment. No more Cassie Burdette mysteries? Like the end of a
souring romance, I wished I’d been the one to call it quits.
![]() |
| H.R.F. Keating |
Days later, waiting to sign books at the
Malice Domestic mystery convention, I sat next to an older man with a soft
voice and a full beard. He introduced himself as H.R.F. Keating—the Malice
honoree for lifetime achievement, including twenty-five novels in his Inspector
Ghote series. In response to his kind interest, I spilled the news that
Cassie’s series was being killed. I'm quite certain that I cried. He assured me that he’d often thought his
series went on too long, that perhaps years ago he’d said all he really had to
say, and that seven books might be the optimum length for a series. Then the
doors opened and a crush of fans queued up to have him sign books that spanned
forty years.
Twenty-five novels, each one nudging back a
little further the curtain obscuring Inspector Ghote’s personality: I realized
there are many things I’ll never know about Cassie. Will she win a tournament?
Have a relationship with golf psychologist Joe Lancaster? Get married? Overcome her fear of kids? Hey, I’ll never
know if I’m a grandmother.
But life in the publishing business lumbers
on: I’ve signed a contract for my next writing adventure. The new series will
feature psychologist and advice columnist, Dr. Rebecca Butterman, a woman who
made cameo appearances in several of the golf mysteries.
Cassie wasn’t crazy about her—I can hear her
voice now: “You’re writing about a psychologist? Rebecca Butterman? Bor-ing.”
And
PS, back to me in the present, wasn't I so lucky to be seated next to that sweet man at the exact moment I needed his calm? And ps, Cassie did make a brief appearance in ASKING FOR MURDER and DEATH WITH ALL
THE TRIMMINGS. I am a fictional grandmother.
Meanwhile, I am working madly on several projects, but I'm feeling very
superstitious. So I decided not to say much about them…I'm not being a tease, I
swear, just nauseously nervously anxiously cautious.
Reds
and Red readers, how long do you think a series should run?














