HANK PHILLIPPI RYAN: I met Meg Gardiner in a cab. Well, outside a cab. We were at--something in New York, I forget, going somewhere, I forget, and she was about to take the subway. Come with me! I said. I have on heels! I'm getting a cab.
So we talked the whole way to wherever it was--she was hilarious and personable and wonderful. I confess that in these situations, meeting a best-selling Edgar-winning author, I always think--here's a successful writer, I bet she could teach me a lot. But that's not the kind of thing you can ask.
So, isn't this clever? I invited her to JRW, so we can all learn. And I'll give a copy of Meg's new RANSOM RIVER to a lucky commenter! And an ARC of THE OTHER WOMAN to another.
And now..I don't want to keep you in suspense, but here's--well, no. I DO want to keep you in suspense. And here's how. Um, how NOT to.
Five Ways to Kill
Suspense
Suspense is vital to storytelling. It keeps readers turning pages,
desperate to learn what happens next. As a building block of drama, it’s as old
as literature itself—Aristotle said suspense
consists of having some real danger looming and a ray of hope.
The
word comes from the Latin suspendere—to hang up—and writers are
the hangmen. We keep readers dangling. But if we do it wrong, we kill the
story.
Here are five surefire ways to do that.
1. Sacrifice
tension for surprise. Unexpected twists can delight or terrify readers. But if you don’t
build up the tension beforehand, readers will be bored senseless long before
you get to Boo.
Hitchcock
put it this way: an audience
experiences suspense when they expect something bad to happen and know more
than the characters do—but can’t intervene to stop it. Say characters are
talking in a restaurant. If all the scene shows is their chitchat, it’s
tedious. But if the audience knows that a ticking bomb is planted beneath the
table, it’s suspenseful.
The writer’s job is
to create tension and then let it build for as long as possible. Be cruel. The
page is the one place where cruelty’s a good thing.
2. Commit howlers. I don’t
mean minor errors about arcane facts. I mean clanging mistakes about common
knowledge. Writers should know that the capital of Brazil is not Rio de
Janeiro. That the president’s airplane does not have AIR FORCE ONE painted on
its flanks. That Interpol doesn’t strafe fugitives from fighter jets (to name
three errors I’ve seen in books or movies). Ludicrous mistakes kill suspense by
pulling readers from the story, thinking, Oh,
come on. Do your research. And after you’ve done it, have knowledgeable
people check it.
3. Write idiot
plots.
Plots that depend on characters acting like idiots kill suspense faster than
cyanide. You’ve read this story: an unarmed woman fails to call SWAT and
instead wades into the swamp alone, at midnight, in heels, to rescue her best
friend from the maniac with the chainsaw. Go on, honey. Readers will be
cheering—for the maniac.
4. Mistake mystery
for suspense. Mystery propels our genre. But withholding facts from readers
doesn’t always increase suspense. Sometimes it just annoys. Say the hero keeps
everything he’s learned to himself until the final pages, when he reveals all.
This is meant to make him sound brilliant and the revelation seem huge. But if
the audience hasn’t struggled along with him as he digs for the truth, they
haven’t experienced the story. They’ll feel shortchanged. (This is another
reason to show, don’t tell.)
Or say you hide the identities of characters in a scene. “Two men
sat at the dingy bar, scowling.” Maybe the scowlers are assassins, circling for
a kill. But if they’re your hero and his brother—and it’s the tenth time you’ve
used this ploy—it’s not suspenseful. It's a cheap trick.
5. Put the main character in a tight situation where
the only question is whether she’ll
survive. Here’s the problem: Readers
figure that in mysteries and thrillers, the protagonist is going to live. If
your novel’s in first person, they know it. So don’t have the bad guys abandon
the heroine in the desert, then spend 50 pages depicting her trek back to
civilization. There’s no question she’ll make it, so her tough slog to town
contains no suspense.
But what if you truly want
to abandon your protagonist in the desert? Then create real, looming danger… to
other characters. And put a clock on it. The heroine must get to a phone by sundown—or the puppy farm will be
blown up. Otherwise, cut everything after the bad guys dump her in Death
Valley. Skip to her stumbling into the 7-11, dehydrated, covered in cactus
needles, and hauling the corpse of the rabid skunk that attacked her.
Sometimes I’ve caught
these mistakes when revising. Sometimes an editor has noted, “Tiresome…” And
sometimes I’ve decided a cheap trick is exactly what I need.
In my novel Ransom River, a
juror finds herself fighting for her life when gunmen storm the courtroom. Then
Rory Mackenzie discovers the attack is connected to an old case that was never
solved. It's connected to her, and dark skeletons in her family's history. And
bringing the truth to light might destroy her and those she loves.
My first draft opened with a long, procedural courtroom scene in
Rory’s point of view. Then, boom—gunmen
burst in. (Hello, surprise without tension.) I rewrote it to add scenes in a
gunman’s POV. Now, while Rory hears testimony about two cops gunning down a
teenager, the attackers circle the courthouse, arm themselves, and stalk toward
the building. Readers know something bad’s coming, but they can’t tell Rory: Get out of there.
Then, to create a sense of real danger that would loom over the
whole book, I revised again—so the story doesn’t open in the courtroom. It
opens when Rory is nine years old. Late one night, she and her best friend see
something they shouldn’t—something that scares them. They don’t understand it.
They only know something's wrong.
Something bad. But what—and how does it come back to haunt her
twenty years later?
I’d tell you, but I’ve gotta keep you in suspense.
HANK: Thanks Meg! I'm off to look at my WIP one more time... How about you, Reds? Do you go back and add the suspense? Or write it a you go? I find when I'm in the suspenseful parts, somehow, I'm typing as fast as I can.
The most suspenseful thing I've ever read? Hmm. Dracula? The Stand? The most suspenseful movie I've ever seen? Hmm. The Vanishing? Rear Window? How about you, reds?
Remember--you can win!
*******************
Meg Gardiner writes the Evan Delaney and the Jo Beckett novels, best-selling
series that have been translated into twenty languages. China Lake won the 2009 Edgar for Best Paperback Original. The Nightmare Thief won the 2012 Audie
Award for Thriller/Suspense audiobook of the year. Meg practiced law in Los
Angeles and taught at the University of California Santa Barbara. She lives
near London. Her latest novel is the stand alone, Ransom River.
Her blog: Lying for a Living.
Twitter: @MegGardiner1















