Showing posts with label The Bone Orchard. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Bone Orchard. Show all posts

Thursday, July 10, 2014

J.K. Rowling, Fan Fiction, and Everything Authors Leave Out of Their Books; a guest blog by Paul Doiron


Kathy Reel is the winner of Anna Lee Huber's A Grave Matter! Kathy, please contact Anna at annaleehuber dot com.


JULIA SPENCER-FLEMING:  I don't have to say too much to introduce Paul Doiron, do I? He burst onto the mystery scene four years ago with The Poacher's Son, which introduced Maine Game Warden Mike Bowditch and nabbed a brace of prestigious nominations and awards, including the Edgar and the Nero.  

Fast forward to today. The fifth Mike Bowditch novel, The Bone Orchard, launches next Tuesday to rave pre-pub reviews (I can add mine to them; Paul slipped me an ARC last month and I read it in one sitting. Really good stuff.) What's Paul going to talk about? Moose? Maine state parks? 

How about J.K. Rowling and fanfiction?





Like most authors, I probably think as much about the things I don’t put into my novels, as the things I do. My new book, The Bone Orchard, is the fifth in my series about headstrong but big-hearted Maine game warden Mike Bowditch, so I’ve come to know a lot about him, not all of which has yet made it into the stories themselves. With each new novel, I fill in a little more of Mike’s unwritten history. 
 



So for instance, in The Bone Orchard I flash back to his first year as a warden to give him a friend I’d never mentioned before—a young man Jimmy Gammon, who is on his way to Afghanistan as an MP with the Maine National Guard. He returns home badly wounded and suicidal (a very real crisis among our returning vets), and the violent confrontation he provokes at the beginning of the book is the catalyst that triggers everything that follows in the story.



In my notes about Mike, I have many details about his past, but no matter how many more books I write, I know I’ll never fill in all the gaps in his back story. And that’s the way it is with every fictional character. A single author can only write so much. 
 



The emergence of fan fiction is an organic response to this problem. Readers want more Bella and Edward and so they tell stories about them set in an alternate dimension of Stephanie Meyer’s Twilight universe (and some of them get quite rich doing so). The same thing happens with movies (Star Wars) and TV shows (Star Trek). If you want to bring on a case of the vapors, Google “Kirk and Spock sex scene”—or better yet don’t. Poor Gene Roddenberry is already rolling in his grave. 
 



I’ve been thinking about fan fiction this week because of J.K. Rowling. Unless you’ve been holed up in a cabin deep in the Maine woods (and if so, I envy you), you’ve probably heard that the richest woman in England has come out with a new Harry Potter story. Like most sentient beings I am a Rowling fan (No, I won’t apologize for reading the Potter books as an adult. Nor will I begrudge Rowling’s recent forays into crime fiction under the pen name of Robert Galbreith.) The story itself — set sixteen years after The Deathly Hallows—didn’t do much for me, it was fun but forgettable, but I’ve been struck by the media response to it.
 



While many reviewers found it delightful, others responded with a collective “meh.” A few, including, Esther Breger writing for the New Republic, saw the story as part of an off-putting pattern of behavior with Rowling, in which she can’t help herself from continuing to fill in the holes she left in the original books:



“Since ending the series, she’s revealed that Dumbledore was gay, that Harry and his cousin Dudley reconciled, and that Harry and Voldemort were related by blood. You don’t have to be a Barthesian grad student to chafe at Rowling’s impulse to clarify the words on the page. When writers adopt the paratextual world of fanfic as their own, they both diminish their books’ literary authority and interfere with the freewheeling spirit of fan writing.”



The language in that paragraph takes me back to my comp-lit days at Yale, but I think it roughly translates to: “Rowling should either put this stuff in a new book or keep her mouth zipped because it’s confusing for readers to learn about a beloved character’s unexpected sexual orientation from an author’s offhand comment.”



Put another way: “This new story reads more like fan fiction than the work of the genius who created Hogwarts.”



What do you think about J.K. Rowling’s decision to keep adding back stories to the characters in her books? Should she leave more to the imagination of her readers, or are you grateful for any new tidbit about the world of Harry Potter? Do you think writers should keep explaining their books by filling in information that never made it onto the page? Or should they leave these holes to be filled in by the readers’ imaginations?



And for the Reds and my fellow authors out there: have you had anyone write fan fiction about your characters and if so, how did you feel about it?



No one has written fanfic about Mike Bowditch yet (that I know of, at least). If they ever do, I’m curious how I’ll respond to it. Will I feel possessive: like the fictional world I’ve created belongs entirely to me as the author? Or will I be open to letting my readers flesh it out with their own imaginings? I doubt I’ll know the answers myself until some fan writes a scene where Mike Bowditch and his beefy blond friend Billy Cronk get it on.



Gulp. 





Paul will be giving a signed copy of The Bone Orchard to the commenter who provides the juiciest answer.



You can read more about the Mike Bowditch series, including excerpts from the books, at Paul’s website. Like his page on Facebook or follow him @pauldoiron on Twitter.

Wednesday, May 2, 2012

Daniel Judson - Confidence Man

ROSEMARY HARRIS: We all suffer from it occasionally. That niggling feeling. A loss of confidence. After all the hard work...can we really do this thing? Can we finish that book? Or write another? Here's JR pal Dan Judson's take on confidence, a little perspective and coming full circle. And just to prove that Dan did survive his crisis of conscience and CAN keep writing great books, he's offering a free download of one of his best books.


DJ: I started my first book on May 11, 1982.  I was all of nineteen and ending my sophomore year of college.  My summer job as a cemetery worker was waiting for me back home in Connecticut--mowing the grass, trimming hedges, and yes, digging graves.  When school ended, I headed back home determined to actually finish the book I had started.  (I’d started several books before that, the first when I was fifteen, but could never get any of them past 100 pages.) 

Upon my return home I quickly established a routine:  I would work from eight to five, eat a steak and baked potato for dinner as I watched two reruns of M*A*S*H, then write until ten or so.  Whenever it rained (and it rained a lot during the summer of ’82), I didn’t have to work, so I was free to spend all day on my book, which probably explains why, even now, thirty years later, rain often plays a part in so many of my stories.
I had a draft finished by the end of that summer, so I brought it back to school with me.  But instead of going to classes, as I should have been, I found myself staying in my dorm room and obsessively rewriting.  By the time November came around, the book was done—a whopping 180 pages, but that was the same length as The Great Gatsby, so I thought I was in good company. 
Shortly after my twentieth birthday I submitted my less-than-epic manuscript to several editors at New York publishers, having gotten their names and addresses from a library copy of The Literary Marketplace.  Then I sat back and waited for the inevitable acceptance letter, and subsequent riches.   That book never sold, of course.  But I had found what I wanted to do.  I wanted to be a novelist.  And I knew what I would have to do to make that happen.
I would have to write and rewrite obsessively. But more importantly, I would need a confidence that bordered on delusion.  I mean, I was twenty and sending my manuscript to Knopf.  Without an agent.  What the frick?
The thing about confidence, I’ve learned over the years, is that it comes and goes so easily.  Too easily.   Over the next eighteen years, I wrote nine novels, and not one of them sold.  My tenth book, though, that one felt…different.  Things were coming together in ways they hadn’t before.  I knew this was the one.

It took me over a year to complete that book, entitled The Bone Orchard.  And within a matter of weeks of my finishing it, it sold to Bantam.  (ROSEMARY: Here's a snippet of one of TBO's great reviews " THE BONE ORCHARD is an exciting private detective mystery that belies the fact that this book is D. Daniel Judson's first novel. The story line is loaded with action as readers take a tour of the underbelly of the Hamptons.")   And that, strangely enough, was when my battle with confidence really began.  I’ll spare you all the ups and downs of my career (there’s a longer version of this essay on my website, www.danieljudsonbooks.com  should anyone want the gory details), but after ten years and eight novels, I found myself, along with a disturbing number of my fellow midlist authors, suddenly unable to find a publisher. Just like I had been for eighteen years.
Frustrated, I decided to take a break from writing.  I began reading every memoir written by a WWII paratrooper that I could find.  I don’t know why I was drawn to paratroopers in particular, but I was, and I trusted that, and with each memoir I read I began to see something. Every single man had who jumped out of an airplane in the middle of the night over Nazi-Occupied France had carried with him one thing.  Confidence.
M1 rifles, trench knives, hand grenades--these were important, but what was crucial—what would ultimately make the difference—was confidence.  In fact, the courses paratroopers ran during their training weren’t called “obstacle courses”, they were called “confidence courses”. 
Now, I hadn’t given up on writing, but I had stopped.  My confidence was shot.  Publishing was in chaos.  Things were, and still are for many of us, bleak.  I had been unable to find a publisher for my last book. Did I really want to write another one? Did I even have what it took to write another?  Send it out?  Wait?  Been there, done that.
And then one morning it just dawned on me:  if some kid could jump into France to fight Nazis, then maybe, you know, I could write another book.  I mean, compared to what those who served in WWII risked—not to mention what was at stake if they failed—what, really, was I risking?
I’m not a kid anymore, but somehow that reckless confidence that had set me on my way—and that had carried me through eighteen years of rejection—returned.  Or at least enough of it did.  I’ve been working on a new project for almost a year now.  Will it sell?  I don’t know.  But I like this one.  It’s…different.  And things seem to be coming together in ways they haven’t before…

Also, it seems that traditional publishing isn’t the only game in town these days.  However you may feel about Amazon.com, it is, right now, offering “out of work” authors like me a chance to reach readers.  A lot of readers.  And new readers, too. 
I hesitated at jumping into that, though.  Maybe it was a confidence thing—my books have always benefited from the editorial process, and putting your stuff out there without that seemed…daunting.  I could of course hire a freelance editor, but there is a difference between an editor you pay and an editor who pays you.  At least in my mind there is.

But I had two early books of mine—The Poisoned Rose and The Bone Orchard, both published in 2002.  A Shamus Award-winner and a Shamus- and Barry- nominee.  I should feel confident about those, right?  And I had a third book, The Gin Palace—the final book in a trilogy, actually, that had started with Rose, and that ten years ago Bantam didn’t want, then wanted, then didn’t want again (long story).
They’d all been edited—and the first two had already been read and enjoyed (for the most part) by tens of thousands of readers.  (Heck, Bruce Willis had wanted to buy the film rights to The Bone Orchard—yet another long story.)  Why not put those up on Amazon as e-books and see what happened?

So that’s what I’m doing.  I don’t claim to be a trailblazer here—many others have made this jump before me.  (In paratrooper terms, those brave souls jumped into Normandy on D-Day, and I’m coming in around, say, Operation Market Garden.)  And while those authors did it all on their own, I’m taking advantage of a new division that sprang up at my agent’s agency—Trident E-books Operations.  The theory is, TEO will do a lot of the “leg work”—get the books up on Amazon, assist with marketing, and actively pursue all sub rights—which will/should free me up to actually write. 
Maybe that book I wrote last year and couldn’t get published will go up on Amazon soon.  Not sure whether I’ll do it through TEO or on my own—the jury is still out on that.  And maybe the book I’m working on now will go up on Amazon as well.  We’ll see.
One way or another, I’m determined to get my stuff read by readers.
Just like I was when I was nineteen.   I tend bar these days—at the same hotel, in fact, where I was working when The Bone Orchard sold.  I guess that brings me full circle.  I no longer eat steak, and my work routine has flipped; I write in the mornings instead of at night.
It’s May 2nd, 2012, which means nine days from now will be the thirty year anniversary of the day I started my first book.
And today it looks like it just might rain…    

ROSEMARY: That's a pretty inspirational story! Let's get Dan off to a good start with his Amazon promotion. (I'll be publishing with Amazon in a few weeks too!)
Read more about Dan at www.danieljudsonbooks.com