JULIA SPENCER-FLEMING: Today I'm going to talk not about what I'm writing, but about something that enables me to write: copyright. Many book lovers will go their whole lives without thinking much about copyright, other than flipping to the front matter and using it to make sure they're on the second, and not the third book of a series.
Then there are the folks out there who have Opinions on copyright. They never seem to spend much time thinking about copyright in the visual arts, for example, or architectural plans. No, they have Thoughts about books and creative works held by their arch-nemesis Disney (and Marvel and Star Wars.) The problem with these thoughts is threefold:
1) Most individual authors aren't in anywhere near the position of Disney. In fact, the biggest money-making writers you could think of - Nora Roberts, Steven King, Neil Gaiman, George RR Martin, JK Rowling - are as but motes in the eye of the Mouse.
2) They treat the intellectual property known as "a book" as if it were some strange and exotic thing completely separate from types of property we call "a business" or "a house."
3) They don't make their living from writing books and they're about as familiar with the publishing business as I am with major league scouting.
About a month ago, blogger and journalist Matt Yglesias, posted the following on Twitter:
He didn't specify what form "copyright reform" might take, but cites a social entrepreneur and information economist that "a 15-38 year range would be optimal."
Now, we have to posit ALL this is totally theoretical. The USA, along with close to 180 other countries, is a signatory to the Berne Convention, a foundational treaty of the World Trade Organization. The Berne Convention sets a bottom limit - life of the author plus 50 years - below which the member countries can't go. They can chose to go up from there; the US is life + 75 years, and Mexico is life + 100. But unless you expect the WTO to fall apart, any discussion of "15-to-38 years after the creation of the work" is in the vein of "How do we terraform Mars" - interesting, but not really front-burner.
Which is not to say people don't get VERY interested in the concept.
Tech policy reporter and computer science guy Timothy B. Lee (no relation to Tim Berners-Lee, although I bet he gets asked that a lot) decided to weigh in with a more direct approach:
People are dogpiling @mattyglesias for his completely reasonable view that copyrights should last for about 30 years. One of the more ridiculous counter-arguments is that royalties from old books can serve as an author's pension.
— Timothy B. Lee (@binarybits) March 5, 2021
I suspect it was calling royalties serving as an author's retirement plan "ridiculous" that did it, but Timothy B. Lee found himself getting dragged by every author on Twitter. And of course, loads of guys (they're almost always guys) had to weigh in with their opinions of why other people's creative work ought to be free right quick. Many mentioned the importance of using older books to create new work, although mostly they seemed concerned with being
able to legally write Spiderman and Tolkien fanfic. Strangely, I never saw anyone mention A THOUSAND ACRES or WIDE SARGASSO SEA or MARCH. Others pointed out they didn't get to inherit their Dad's salary upon his death, so why should a novelist's kids inherit their royalties? Nobody read books more than 30 years old anyway, so why should we worry? Just invest in a 401(k) like the rest of the world does.
I encourage you to read the twitter thread, there were SO many bad takes - including the everpractical "information wants to be free" - it became a sort of art installation of dumbness.
Let me counter with a few facts of life from someone who buys groceries, maintains a car and keeps a roof over her head thanks to royalties:
1. Intellectual property is still property. I make stories, in the same way another person might make cosmetics and a third might make electric vehicles. It's a business, just as much as Glossier and Tesla. If Emily Weiss and Elon Musk can to pass the value of their businesses on to their kids, why can't I? I can assure you, mine will be satisfied with a lot less than little X AE A-XII.
2. I do invest toward my retirement. But it's 100% on me - I don't get a handy employer match. I'm counting on royalties from my back list to help support me in my old age, in part because I plan, like most authors I know, to still be writing into decreptitude. On paper, no one can hear you creak.
3. Oh, and that money I put into my SEP IRA? It goes AFTER I pay 12.5% toward Social Security and 7.9% to Medicare. That's more than twice what non-self-employed people contribute. I'll get it back (I hope, please God) but it's a chunk o' change that isn't available to put away for my rapidly approaching golden years.
4. Let's say we could wave the magic copyright reform wand and change copyright protection from its current term to 30 years after creation. I hate to disillusion anyone, but that won't lead to a Marxist utopia where The People get books for free. First off, The People almost always prefer well-typeset books bound in paper or available to download. Who's going to provide that? Publishing companies. Who will then make 100% of the profit. Yes, Project Guttenberg is out there, bless their hearts, but my kids still bought paperback copies of every classic novel they read in high school and college.
4.a.) And I'll tell you how film rights would work under a 30 year copyright. No production company would even talk to an author. Why go through the expense and hassle of paying Deb Crombie and negotiating her terms when all ITV or Sky TV have to do is wait until 2023 - yep, that soon! - and they can start filming A SHARE IN DEATH for free! Once again, they make 100% of the profit while Debs, I don't know, has to be content with her contribution to human happiness, I guess.
I'll stop myself from going on and ON and on. The takeaway: copyright is there for a reason, and without a generous term, most of us couldn't afford to BE authors in the first place. Also: never go up against a Sicilian when death is on the line.












