HALLIE EPHRON: It’s hot hot hot out there, which means it’s ICE CREAM TIME! In my neck of the woods that means it’s time to go over to The Ice Creamsmth – a tiny store where they make their own ice cream and the best hot fudge sauce ever in the basement of a tiny store on a busy street.
It opened in 1976 and I’ve been patronizing it ever since—the first owners were Robyn and David Mabel who’ve now retired and their kids, Sarah Mabel-Skillin and Chris Skillin, have taken over. (Jerry and I used to go ballroom dancing with Robyn and David. They're amazingly slender and nimble for a couple who have spent half of their lives making great ice cream.)
There’s usually a line out the door. Their special flavors this month: Birthday Cake, Blueberry, and Coconut Pineapple but I’m a sucker for their Sweet Cream (with hot fudge of course).
So are you drawn to a local ice cream spot as the temperature hovers in the 90s (or worse), and what’s your pleasure when you get to the front of the line and it’s your turn to order?
HANK PHILLIPPI RYAN: Oh, that sounds fabulous. I love ice cream– maybe…one bite or two. (And then I don’t need any more because the fear of calories takes away the fun. And the first bites are always the best.)
But my fave of all time is Jamoca Almond Fudge, remember? From Baskin Robbins, and it was coffee ice cream with chocolate-covered almonds. SO delicious! I also love lemon sorbet with chocolate sauce, or with blueberries. Or raspberries. And that coconut pineapple sounds DIVINE! Could we put it in a blender with rum?
RHYS BOWEN: We’ve just come back from Cornwall where we had to eat the clotted cream ice cream. So sinfully good! My favorite flavor is always salted caramel although I’m also addicted to Baskin Robbins pralines and cream.
And when I’m in Italy my favorite gelato is stratiacelli which is like chocolate chip but better.
We do have a local shop here called Silberman’s. It’s been around since our kids were small and every sports team–soccer, baseball, swimteam etc. would wind up there after Saturday games. I’m glad it’s still going strong and the ice cream is still good.
JENN MCKINLAY: Give me all the ice cream. It’s supposed to be 110+ here in AZ so I’d bathe in the ice cream if I could. My flavor preference changes from day to day and there is no flavor that I don’t like but I can give my top three: coffee, salted caramel, or mint chip.
These flavors have endured as my go to choices over decades. I don’t see it changing any time soon and they all pair quite well with hot fudge and whipped cream. Yum.
LUCY BURDETTE: In our CT hometown, the best ice cream is at Ashley’s.
It may sound a little odd, but my favorite thing to order is a root beer float with sweet cream ice cream. I don’t think too much about calories as Hank does–everything in moderation, but since my triglycerides came back a little high this time (everything else excellent!), I’m going to have to eschew the hot fudge…
JULIA SPENCER-FLEMING: In my area, there’s a favorite ice cream shop called Beals - no indoor sitting, just a couple of benches and picnic tables, but the line always stretches to the parking lot.
Lots of happy memories of stopping there with the kids as a special treat on a hot day.
My faves? Homemade strawberry (not the boxed kind, it has to be really thick with macerated berries,) mint chocolate chip (always good everywhere) and my new fave, salted caramel, which I only had for the first time a couple years ago.
Oh, and I haven’t been, but there’s a small shack on Sabbathday Lake, Bresca & the Honeybee, which is getting national attention for its ice cream. The chef/owner is a multiple James Beard nominee and ran a highly regarded restaurant in Portland until it all got too much, and, much like many heroines in a cozy mystery, relocated to a very small town to start her own ice cream business!
DEBORAH CROMBIE: Hallie, you got me started looking up gelato places on our town square and there are three! Obviously we need to make a point to go out for ice cream…
I'm not normally a big ice cream eater, but when I was in London it was ice cream, ice cream, everywhere! I had a scoop of strawberry gelato a couple of times at restaurants, but the biggest treat was the day I went to Teddington Lock. Everyone walking along the river had ice cream, sold from an Airstream trailer called The Flying Cloud Cafe, so i couldn't resist. I got a scoop of Marshfield Farms (made in the Cotswolds) Black Currant with Clotted Cream, and it was so good that I'm still thinking about it. Maybe it's a good thing that it's very far away now…
HALLIE: Now I'm on the hunt for "clotted cream ice cream" to have in my rootbeer float... So, where's your favorite ice cream place in your neck of the woods, and what are you craving from there?





























