CNN published this image for their annual accounting of memorable people who died in the preceding year. Count the men. Now count the women.
Back in 2012, I started counting the number of women (versus the number of men) who had obituary articles written about them in my local paper, the Boston Globe. The ratio was SIX to ONE: six times more dead men had lives deemed worthy of the obituary writer's time than women. The ratio was the same in the New York Times.
It's a little better six years later. Today it's FIVE to ONE in the Times and FOUR to ONE in the Globe. However, in CNN's annual count of notable people we lost in 2017, out of 72 people remembered, only 7 were women. TEN to ONE. And what women did they include? Sue Grafton, Mary Tyler Moore, the woman who played one of the Von Trapp family sisters in Sound of Music, and the woman who played Joanie on TV in Happy Days.
Finally, last week in an article entitled OVERLOOKED, the Times addressed the discrepancy.
"Since 1851, The New York Times has published thousands of obituaries: of heads of state, opera singers, the inventor of Stove Top stuffing and the namer of the Slinky. The vast majority chronicled the lives of men, mostly white ones; even in the last two years, just over one in five of our subjects were female."With OVERLOOKED the Times identified fifteen women who were overlooked, and posted a form for readers to nominate candidates for future "overlooked" obits. The obituaries, written belatedly, attest to truly remarkable lives.
You'll have to read the article to see their justification for the imbalance, which to me seems a bit lame. Because the bottom line is women have ALWAYS contributed. Major league. It's the recognition that's lagging.
So what's your take on this? Is anything changing?
JULIA SPENCER-FLEMING: I hope so. I subscribe to the NYTimes, and read the article - which is terrific - and the most jarring thing for me personally was that I had never realized the gross imbalance between the number of men selected for recognition and the number of women. And I think of myself as a very aware feminist!
To me, that's part of the objective - we have to go looking for the women who made a difference. One of the things I love about Google's doodles? The way it's made me aware of scientists, artists and others who have contributed to history who were women and people of color.
RHYS BOWEN: Women have been systematically excluded from the history books (unless they ended up burned at the stake like Joan of Arc). We know their scientific discoveries have been attributed to men.
Back in the good old days when newspapers ran book reviews they were nearly all male thriller writers. And how many women have won the Edgar awards? (Hallie and I both hope that will change this year!)
I've always been bemused by the fact that many people, men and women see a woman writer as pursuing her little hobby, men as establishing a serious career. On a plane recently I told the woman beside me that I still wrote two books a year. She patted my hand. "That's nice, isn't it," she said.
"Keeps you busy!"
"Hey," I thought, "If I were a brain surgeon and told her I did two brain surgeries a week would she say 'keeps you busy'?
I keep hoping that perceptions are changing, but not sure they are.
HANK PHILLIPPI RYAN: Well, I thought the section was beautiful. Yes, it's a long time coming, but gotta count blessings, give credit for awareness and taking responsibility, and then press on.
Know what I'd like to know, though? Exactly who, in the past, CHOSE who was going to get an obit. Think it was a woman? I'm betting no.
LUCY BURDETTE: Of course it wasn't a woman choosing Hank! Although, now that you mention it, obituary writer sounds like the kind of job they'd give a woman. Rather than first page news reporter, right?
I do love reading the NY Times obituaries--you really get a good sense of the way someone lived. And we thought the Overlooked piece was a brilliant idea. Maybe things are changing, but really slowly. We all have to keep nudging...
INGRID THOFT: Women have always done amazing things, but in American society, it’s only during the last 60 or so years that women have been claiming their place in the public sphere. The lack of representation is an issue of acknowledgment, but also opportunity. There are fewer women than men in most fields, and we need to get those numbers closer to 50/50.
This also raises the issue of what accomplishments are worthy of an obituary. What about the mothers and fathers of all those accomplished men? They should get some credit!
JENN McKINLAY: I believe it's changing.
I look at the girls who go to school with the Hooligans and, yeah, good luck not giving these girls their due.They are smart, they are fierce, and they are not going to stand in anyone's shade. I love these girls!
It's unfortunate that it's taken this long for women to be recognized as worthy contributors to society, but when you realize women couldn't get a credit card in their own name until 1974 or fight in combat until 2013, it's easy to see that the battle for equality is far from over but I believe we're gaining ground every single day.
I was impressed that the Times put forth OVERLOOKED and I look forward to reading about more women of note through the ages.
DEBORAH CROMBIE: I read the piece in the Times--it was fascinating. And, as I've never been in the habit of reading the obits, horrifying to realize that women have been so marginalized even in death. Now, I'll be noticing, not only in the national papers and news but in my local paper, and we can only hope that awareness spreads. Still, I just checked the Friday obits in the Times--five men. Don't you bet that we lost an interesting and accomplished woman last week, too?
HALLIE: Did you read the piece in the Times? Are things changing in terms of women being recognized for their contributions?











