JENN McKINLAY: I'm thrilled to have Paige Shelton, one of my plot group pals and a Book Talk member, here with us today! Paige writes two of my very favorite series--the Mary Higgins Clark Award nominated Alaska Wild series and the Scottish Bookshop Mysteries. You can't go wrong with either one of these as you'll see in her post below, Paige loves her research and she's very good at it!
![]() |
| BUY NOW |
PAIGE SHELTON: The Poison Pen, the ninth book in my Scottish Bookshop Mystery Series, published last week. The story begins with the main character, Delaney, mourning the death of the queen. Shortly thereafter, she is thrown into the middle of a murder whose suspects just might have ties to the royal family.
Though it’s a murder mystery series and those are, of course, all about finding killers, writing these books has not only allowed me to fictionally do away with some bad guys, but it has also given me a surprising and enjoyable education in Scottish and English history. This time I dug into some of the drama around King Edward VIII’s abdication.
Edward VIII - Edward Albert Christian George Andrew Patrick David (seriously, that was his name) abdicated the throne in early December 1936, after having been king for just under a year. It’s widely thought that he “gave up the throne for love,” but my research uncovered things that made me think there was a little more to the story (isn’t there always?). I suspect some people just aren’t cut out for the royal life. We’ve seen some of that recently, of course. I don’t think Edward liked the job. He wasn’t about the traditions and protocols that might have been expected of him. Maybe it was love, but maybe love was just a convenient way out. I’m simplifying, of course, but I really don’t think he enjoyed being king.
I wondered what might have happened to the royal succession if he hadn’t abdicated. If Edward had remained on the throne and never fathered any “legitimate” (I’m using that word on purpose because it hints at a twist in the The Poison Pen) children, Elizabeth II would have been queen anyway. Her father became king when Edward abdicated, but he died before Edward, making Elizabeth II the next one in line. But if Edward had remained on the throne and had fathered children, everything would be different. It’s hard to imagine.
Though it seems the family was close, once Edward left his royal life, he lived in virtual exile in France. It is said that Queen Elizabeth II did visit him when he was on his deathbed. He is buried in royal ground, which would not have happened if the queen had objected. Again, as we’ve seen recently, even royal families have their share of dysfunction.
Abdication isn’t all that uncommon in other monarchies. For example, Queen Margrethe II of Denmark abdicated after back surgery complications; Emperor Akihito of Japan, for health reasons; and King Juan Carlos of Spain for “personal reasons.” Those sorts of abdications aren’t usually followed by exile though. Abdication has been going on for a long time, back as far as 318 BC from what I discovered.
I don’t use most of the research I do for my books – there’s not enough room or it doesn’t fit. There was one thing I tried hard to include in The Poison Pen, but I couldn’t make it work. On July 10, 1296, King of Scots, John Balliol abdicated. Nicknamed Toom Tabard by his subjects, which means “empty coat,” he was not well-liked and thought to be ineffective. Additionally, Robert the Bruce disliked him so much (they were rivals for the throne, so there is that) that Bruce joined the English forces to fight against the Scottish king. The defeat meant that abdication was probably the only choice for King John. Oh, the drama that must have stirred up.
Thanks to Jenn McKinlay and all the Jungle Reds for inviting me to post today. And thanks to all the readers. We couldn’t do what we do without you.
So, what do you think about the abdication, Reds and Readers? Do you ever wonder how things would have turned out if Edward hadn't declined the throne?
Paige Shelton is the New York Times Bestselling author of the Farmers' Market, Country Cooking School, Dangerous Type, and Scottish Bookshop, and Alaska Wild mysteries. She's lived lots of places but currently resides in Arizona. Find out more at www.paigeshelton.com
















