Showing posts with label to kill a mockingbird. Show all posts
Showing posts with label to kill a mockingbird. Show all posts

Thursday, September 3, 2015

A Journey of Character?

HANK PHILLIPI RYAN:  A writer can change her mind. No question about that. Or...“realize” her mind. No question about that, either. Anyone who’s ever written a character they thought they understood—and then discovered, with a bang or a whimper, that they were wrong wrong worng has experienced the wonderful magic of character growth.

And its not only fictional characters who grow and change, of course. Sometimes the author grows, and then our characters follow.  I’m such a Lynne Raimondo fan. Her “Dante” mysteries—and more about that below—are flat out terrific.

And Lynne’s here today to talk about some inside scoop on her own real life—wow, I did not know this stuff! And how it may connect her to another author. And to you.






On Harper Lee And A Writer’s Journey
                    By Lynne Raimondo

Last month, author Harper Lee set the literary world on fire once more with the publication of Go Set A Watchman, a “rediscovered” sequel to her Pulitzer Prize-winning novel, To Kill a Mockingbird.  I’m not going to delve into all the controversy surrounding Watchman’s publication, or whether, as some have claimed, it would have been better to leave the manuscript in the safe deposit box where it was hidden, a rough draft to be read primarily by future literary scholars.

Still, Watchman has given me food for thought about how a writer’s work grows and changes over time.  The revelation that Lee originally conceived of Atticus Finch as an unapologetic racist has shocked the public, and rightly so.  Learning that this revered icon was a white supremacist is like finding out that Jo March was actually Lizzie Borden.

It all makes sense, though, if you keep in mind that Watchman isn’t really a sequel.  It’s an early draft, or maybe the debut novel Lee would have published if her wise editor, or  Truman Capote, or her own amazing intuitive sense hadn’t sent her back to the drawing board for two more long years.  The Atticus of Watchman isn’t the same man as the Atticus of Mockingbird because, as Lee continued to spend time with him, she changed her mind.

I haven’t read Watchman and I’m not sure I will.  By all accounts its central theme is disillusionment, a young woman’s bitter discovery that the father she revered as a child has gigantic feet of clay.  Like several others have mentioned on Jungle Red, I think I’d rather remember the Atticus of Mockingbird, a book I read over and over as a teenager and that played a major role in my decision to become a lawyer. 

Perhaps Lee’s earliest writing efforts were autobiographical.  “Write what you know” isn’t just good advice, it’s also a lot easier when writers are first starting out.  We feel more comfortable testing our ability with what’s already familiar.  It’s only later, after we’ve gotten a handle on the basics, that we become more confident of ourselves as storytellers, free to abandon the narrow script of our lives for the much broader territory of the imagination.

It’s conceivable that the Jean Louise of Watchman more closely reflects the relationship Lee had with her own father.  I haven’t read Lee’s biography, so I don’t know this for a fact, but it seems likely there was some friction between them.  Perhaps too, as Lee flexed her talent, she grew bolder and more willing to experiment.  The first-hand experiences that originally inspired her weren’t suited to the narrative she eventually settled on, one in which Atticus wasn’t a hateful bigot but a hero.

Then too, the circumstances had changed.  Watchman was reportedly begun in the 1950s when Jim Crow was at its zenith.  By 1960, when Mockingbird was published and Lee was 35, segregation’s grip on the South was beginning to weaken.  I also suspect Lee had changed a bit herself.  What seems hard and fast in our twenties often takes on a different, more nuanced aspect as we age.  Perhaps this growth enabled Lee to better understand the social pressures that shaped her original Atticus, and to find the seeds of humanity that would transform a despicable Klan sympathizer into a champion of equal rights.

These speculations are very much tied to my own path to becoming a writer.  I’m by no means comparing myself to the great Harper Lee, but looking back, I see a similar kind of journey.  When I first started to write, I had just gone through some professional upheavals that were, to say the least, depressing.  For those who don’t know me well, I was a senior lawyer at Arthur Andersen LLP when it was indicted by the Justice Department and then convicted by a Houston jury.  After the firm collapsed, I became its general counsel, helping to wind down the affairs of this once-proud, ninety-year old institution.  A few years later, a unanimous Supreme Court reversed Andersen’s conviction, but by then it was too late:  the firm was already in its grave.

After living through this debacle, I wasn’t just exhausted.  I was angry and disillusioned and close to quitting the practice of law.  But a friend of a friend coaxed me into taking a new job with the State of Illinois, in the administration of Rod Blagojevich.  You may remember him as the Illinois governor who was later convicted of trying to sell a Senate seat.  Suffice it to say that it didn’t take me long to realize that job wasn’t for me either.

It was around this time that I took my first stab at writing a novel.  Given how I was feeling, it’s not surprising that I started out with a protagonist a lot like me:  a middle-aged lawyer fed up with the world and unsure of where to go next, the very personification of the mid-life crisis I was then caught up in.  I had no real plot in mind except that she – because of course she was a she – would eventually find happiness and professional fulfillment.

I made many mistakes with that manuscript, but the biggest was not understanding the difference between writing and therapy.  Like the imaginary Harper Lee I’ve conjured up here, I wasn’t writing first and foremost to create fiction, but to get something off my chest.  I knew how to put a few words together, but that was only the start.  It was only later, with the intervention of time and and a great deal of practice, that I could move out of my autobiographical comfort zone and write something a reader besides me might care about.  In other words, a story.

Even then, Mark Angelotti, the non-lawyer protagonist of Dante’s Wood, my first published novel, had a lot of emotional baggage I might not give him today if I were starting out fresh.  In fact, by book three in the series, Dante’s Dilemma, which released on August 4, he’s grown into someone considerably less bitter.  But that’s the beauty of writing a series.  Unlike Go Set A Watchman, each of my books is a true sequel.  So I’m free to keep modifying the script without shocking anyone, to grow and change my character in ways that make him a more sympathetic, if not always perfect human being. 

How about you?  Have you ever made a major change in a character? And if so, was it because of something that happened to you in your own life?

HANK: Oh, what a fun question! And a hard one. I know good guys in my books have turned out—little had I predicted!—to be bad guys. I do know, also, on days that I get good or encouraging news, like a great review, it’s MUCH easier to write.


 How about you, Reds and readers?

********************************

Lynne Raimondo is the author of Dante’s Wood, a Library Journal Mystery Debut of the Month, Dante’s Poison, and the recently released Dante’s Dilemma, all featuring Mark Angelotti, a blind, psychologically troubled forensic psychiatrist.  Before turning to writing, Lynne was a partner at a major Chicago law firm, the general counsel of Arthur Andersen LLP, and the general counsel of  the Illinois Department of Revenue.


Blind psychiatrist Mark Angelotti is faced with his most troubling case yet when he is asked to evaluate Rachel Lazarus, the wife of a slain University of Chicago professor. 
Months earlier, the professor’s body was found stuffed into one of the exhibits at “Scav,” the school’s world-famous annual scavenger hunt, and – in a feast for the press – missing a vital piece of its anatomy. Though she’s confessed to her husband’s murder, Rachel is mounting a battered woman’s defense.

Forced into helping the prosecution, Mark becomes unsure of his objectivity when his investigation uncovers uncomfortable parallels between Rachel’s history and his own. That concern proves well-founded when his damaging admission at trial all but convicts Rachel. Then a tip connects the case to another suspected murder and evidence that Rachel may not be guilty after all. As he plows ahead during a brutal Chicago winter, Mark soon learns he has far more to worry about than treacherous snow and ice:  someone will do anything to guarantee that Rachel takes the fall.

Reviews of Dante’s Dilemma:

“A must read . . . [The] writing is first class and readers will love having to guess the finale right up until the reveal on the very last page.” – Suspense Magazine

Saturday, July 18, 2015

Some Thoughts on Harper Lee

 RHYS BOWEN: Here at Jungle Red Writers we tend to avoid anything too controversial, topical or political. However something happened this week that had concerned me greatly and think affects our industry.  I'm not talking about the Iran nuclear deal, I'm talking about the publication of
GO SET A WATCHMAN, the new/old book by Harper Lee.
It was published this Tuesday by Harper Collins. I haven't read it yet and frankly I don't know if I want to. I find it very disturbing that a woman who guarded her privacy so fiercely and who shunned any kind of limelight is now a topic of universal discussion. A woman who never wrote another book in sixty years now decides to publish an unpolished prequel or sequel of her magnum opus. What disturbs me most was a quote I read that the publisher has never spoken with her directly, only with her lawyer. How is that right? How can they know that her wishes are being observed? We don't even know that she is mentally capable of making decisions. We don't even know if she was even asked. Isn't it more likely that her lawyer got his hands on an unfinished manuscript and decided to cash in on it?So what do other Reds and readers think about this? I would hate someone to find a first draft or early manuscript of mine and thus tarnish my reputation. I admit that the only facts I know are those I've read or heard on radio. So please set me straight if I am wrong.

LUCY BURDETTE: I haven't been studying this carefully, but lots of the facts seem bothersome. I totally agree that I wouldn't want an old piece of work that I'd deemed unpublishable put out into the world. Gosh it's hard enough to feel like a finished manuscript is good enough. Because the recently published book is so "valuable", it certainly opens the process to accusations of exploitation. This reminds me of the struggle over Steig Larsson's unpublished work after his death. the stakes are very high in both cases.

I'm not sure I will read Watchman either Rhys. If you are curious about the change in Atticus Finch's character, you'll want to read this blog post by James Scott Bell: https://killzoneblog.com/2015/07/the-whole-truth-about-atticus-finch.html

HANK PHILLIPPI RYAN:   Jonathan is afraid to read it, because he doesn't want to ruin his vision of Atticus. And I talked to a person yesterday who was trying to explain to me how the change of Atticus's personality was a logical progression, envisioned through Scout's brain.

And I think it's fascinating, because in reality, to an author, we are creating characters, and with the stroke of a pen or the delete button, the characteristics can change. I have certainly made a character I thought was good into a bad guy, and it is not difficult to do.

But the good guy AND the bad guy can exist, just in different universes. One does not have to develop out of the other, or even be connected to the other, it's just a completely different character in a completely different story.

 It's not contradictory, it's just a different snapshot of a different time. It's not exactly the same, but it is kind of like the Wizard of Oz and Wicked.
(Yes, I admit, I have been relieved that Gregory Peck is not alive to read Go Set.)

I am looking at it as an interesting insight into the author's process. And the editor's process!

Jonathan, looking at it a different way, says it is terrible that the reputation of Atticus is getting ruined… For money.

DEBORAH CROMBIE: Lucy, that's a very interesting piece by James Scott Bell. It made me wonder if it doesn't make Atticus Finch's defense of Tom Robinson in To Kill a Mockingbird more admirable, rather than less, when we know his political views. He upheld the law in spite of his opinions on race and segregation, which is what a lawyer should do, isn't it? I'd love to know what Jonathan thinks, Hank. Still, that doesn't make the older Atticus (from what I've read) any more appealing, but people are often both complicated and flawed.

Will we ever have a definitive answer to "Should it have been published?" Probably not. Has anyone actually read it yet, and if so, what did you think?





RHYS: Please share your thoughts on this. I really don't want to leap to judgment on this. I could be possible that the lawyer really has her client's best interests at heart and wants the world to be able to share this very different aspect of Atticus Finch. It could be a new national treasure. However.......







Monday, October 15, 2012

Oops, they did it again...movie remakes


ROSEMARY HARRIS: Whenever I hear that a classic film is being remade I can't decide if it's hubris or simply a dearth of original ideas. On a recent rowing machine kick, I've rowed through three different versions of Pride and Prejudice, three of Little Women, two of Dr. Zhivago and three of Anna Karenina. Now there's a new Anna coming.

My admiration for Keira Knightley is unalloyed and unalterable. Girl crush. I've loved her ever since Bend it Like Beckham. But I do wonder if the world needs another Anna Karenina a mere 35 years after the splendid PBS version.

Maybe it's good that every generation has it's own Anna - and Elizabeth Bennett, and Lara. And Sherlock (but more about him later this week...) But I can't imagine another Scout Finch. The young Jena Malone would have made a good one, but who could step into Gregory Peck's shoes? And could there be another Holly Golightly?

Which films would you like to see remade and which are "NO, don't mess with perfection!"

(For the record, my faves of the above classics..David Lean's Zhivago, Keira's Pride and Prejudice, Katharine Hepburn's Little Women and so far the Nicola Pagett Anna. Which are your faves?)

LUCY BURDETTE: Okay, so anyone who watched the Jungle Red Family Feud knows that I am weak on movies! But I hope no one messes with SLEEPLESS IN SEATTLE, or for that matter, anything starring Meryl Streep. And TOOTSIE, remember that one? Could not do better than Dustin Hoffman and Jessica Lang.

DEBORAH CROMBIE: Urgh. Can you imagine a remake of Casablanca?  Sacrilege! Key Largo?  And I'm with Ro on Breakfast at Tiffany's. No one else could play Holly Golightly. No one but Juliette Binoche could do Chocolat. And I agree on Sleepless in Seattle. A remake I did like? The updated version of The Italian Job. Great fun.

Oh, and Lucy, we get that you like Dustin Hoffman:-) Speaking of, nobody better dare mess with The Graduate!

HANK PHILLIPPI RYAN: Well, of course they ruined THE WOMEN (the genesis of Jungle Red, remember.) Even with the wonderful Annette Bening, it stunk up the place.

Can you IMAGINE a remake of To Kill A Mockingbird? NO way! And I bet they wouldn't dare try it. Not a chance to replace Gregory Peck, RO.

They could do a new WORKING GIRL, one of my everlasting favorites, but no one could be like Melanie Griffith and Harrison Ford. Sigh. That was SO good.

The remake of Music Man with whats-his-name was a bomb, wasn't it? And it is interesting, though to see the incarnations of James Bond. Do you all still imagine Sean Connery? Or has Daniel Craig crept into your consciousness?

And don't even think about Lawrence of Arabia.

HALLIE EPHRON: Speaking of Dustin Hoffman, I can't imagine a remake of Midnight Cowboy.

When an actor has nailed a role, it's hard to imagine anyone remaking that movie with a new cast. Audrey Hepburn OWNS Holly Golightly. And who else but Humphrey Bogart could be Sam Spade (even though he's not remotely like Sam Spade in the book) or Lauren Bacall Miss Wonderly? Or Anthony Perkins as Norman Bates? Or Sandra Bullock as Gracie Hart? Or Kathleen Turner as Peggy Sue.

JAN BROGAN: The beauty of Netflix is I just finished rewatching the Old PBS Anna Karenina and Ro, you are right. It was awesome. But I would love to see what Keira does with the role. Interesting, when her version of Pride and Prejudice first came out, it got terrible reviews - mostly because the new Darcy couldn't match Colin Firth, but I still loved it. It's just so visually rich, and I think she was a terrific Elizabeth.

ROSEMARY: Now...as much as I love Colin Firth - and Kristin Scott Thomas was a ninny to prefer Ralph Fiennes in The English Patient - I thought Matthew McFayden did a wonderful job as Darcy. Less wooden and more believable, although not nearly as hot.

JAN: Isn't Sleepless In Seattle sort of a remake itself?  Of An Affair to Remember Or is it just an "ode" to An Affair to Remember.

ROSEMARY: Ode. You've Got Mail was a remake of In The Good Old Summertime which was a remake of Shop Around the Corner. All charming.

JAN: I would hate to see a remake of The Philadelphia Story. Who else could pull off that Katharine Hepburn hyperactivity?

ROSEMARY: But they did...that was High Society with Grace Kelly, Frank Sinatra and Bing Crosby! I don't think it matched up to the original.

JAN: Okay, can you imagine anyone but Jimmy Stewart in It's A Wonderful Life?  Hmmm...maybe Tom Hanks. He always reminds me of Jimmy.

RHYS BOWEN: I can't actually think of a single remake that I enjoyed more than the original. Every time I've seen one I've wanted to shout "Why? Why?"
I would never go and see a remake of Roman Holiday (one of my all-time favorite movies,because nobody could equal Audrey Hepburn-- or West Side Story, Casablanca, or Out of Africa. I agree--don't touch anything starring Meryl Streep.

And sorry, I did not think the Keira Knightley version of Pride and Prejudice measured up to the TV version with Colin Firth (coming out of the lake soaking wet). 

ROSEMARY:...yeah the lake scene alone was worth the price of admission.  Sad to say I could not find a pic of him dripping wet but this one is mighty fine.