Showing posts with label clare mackintosh. Show all posts
Showing posts with label clare mackintosh. Show all posts

Monday, January 8, 2018

Shoulds

INGRID THOFT

Last Monday on JRW we tackled the topic of resolutions.  Some people are fans of setting ambitious goals on January 1st, while others think it’s a set up for failure.  As I contemplated Jenn’s post, I kept coming back to “The Shoulds. What are they exactly, other than sounding like something from “The Phantom Tollbooth?”

“The Shoulds” are all those things I think I’m supposed to do:  the things I should be doing.  I should be eating more protein.  I should be writing X number of words a day.  I should be emailing that friend with whom I haven’t had much contact recently.  I should, I should, I should.  Make no mistake, I do want to do these things, but somehow, the motivation gets quashed by the feeling that I have no choice.  

I decided to pay greater attention to my shoulds for a couple of days.  It was an interesting exercise during which I realized that I should on myself a lot!  Given that I’m a basically productive and healthy human being, it seemed extreme how often I was scolding myself about a potential course of action.  So I decided to start questioning my shoulds.  There are some shoulds that are a given and can be backed up with solid evidence:  You should brush your teeth if you want to hold on to your pearly whites for years to come.  However, should I eat fish when the burger is more appealing?  Should I volunteer for another project when I feel overbooked as it is?  Maybe.  Sometimes, a should is really a building block to a greater desire: I should eat the fish because I want to keep my cholesterol in check.  But sometimes?  A should is just full of should.

Tell me Reds, do you battle “The Shoulds” on a regular basis?  Do you have some you’ve banished from your life?

HANK PHILLIPPI RYAN: That is such a fascinating way of looking at the world. One thing I noticed: I often say to myself--"Oh, Hank, that is SO dumb." And I realize that might be a bit unnecessary.  Why am I criticizing myself? When I should be my biggest fan? 


I guess my to-do list is my shoulds. I SHOULD write the article. I SHOULD plan the class. I should do my words for the day, answer emails. I should call my family more.  That's a very important should which I too often put off.  I should read more broadly, but why, when the next Shari Lapena  or Clare Macintosh is coming out? 

As for the food things, they always change those anyway. So I just say, well, I think they're wrong about bacon, I think it's fine. I should have more.

HALLIE EPHRON: Ah, bacon. And eggs. And steak. And crispy pan-roasted potatoes… and really good heirloom tomatoes.

Yes, I often get a case of the shoulds. Should walk not drive. Should write more words. Should volunteer for X. Should not take credit for getting husband to volunteer for X. Should buy the bargain brand.

I think overall it's a good thing, that inner taskmaster. Until it keeps you up at night. Because really, you should get a good night's rest.

JULIA SPENCER-FLEMING: Do you think this is something that mostly afflicts women? I mean, we're all kind of socialized to take care of things - spouse, kids, house, community - and there is a relentless drumbeat of articles and images in media telling us we're not good enough as we are: lose weight, eat better, entertain more, Martha Stewart your house, etc. 

I really noticed this several years ago, when our church needed another adult to serve with the youth group. NO ONE had stepped up. I didn't want to, because I had just ended a ten-year stint teaching 3 and 4 year olds in Sunday School. I talked to Ross about it: "You should do this. You're a teacher, and you love this age group."

Ross: "No, I don't want to make the time commitment. I want to read the paper at Coffee By Design after church, not sit in the undercroft with thirteen-year-olds."

Me: "But NOBODY is coming forward! And I'd really rather not."

Ross: "Then don't!"

Of course, I did. It turned out to be a wonderful experience - although it did take a LOT of time - but I was struck by how easy it was for Ross, a good and caring guy, to prioritize what he wanted over what he "should" have done. I'm not saying men don't feel it - if you should take out the garbage, you should take out the garbage - but I don't think it drives them the way it does most women.

DEBORAH CROMBIE: Julia, I think you are so right on the gender thing. It's not the first time I've realized that my hubby does not suffer in the least from the SHOULDS. If he wants to do something, he does it. If he doesn't, he doesn't. I, however, live in a universe of shoulds. A lot of them are just practical (should plan meals, should shop for groceries, should pay bills, should WORK) but too many are obligations that I don't have to do. I am getting a little better at saying "NO." 

And reminding myself not to beat myself up, like Hank. Too often I catch myself saying, "That is so stupid. I am such a dummy." Would I say that to my granddaughter? NO. Then I shouldn't be saying it to myself, either. Wait, is that a should?

JENN McKINLAY: Shoulda Coulda Woulda - I find I say that more than I should. Ha! I have really let go of "shoulds" over the past few years. Frankly, I just don't have the time or the stamina. Julia, I think you are 100% correct that it is different for women. I live with three men. I am woefully outnumbered, and it is even worse because all three of them are musicians. If there is an available hour in their day, it doesn't occur to them to give away time they can be playing guitar/drums to volunteer or, say, scrub a toilet, pick up after someone else, etc. and so forth.

And here's the biggest difference, if something isn't done, they don't consider it a reflection upon their character like I do (used to do). I think they are wearing me down (which is a good thing), because I no longer get in a tizzy if the house is a mess (it pretty much always is) and I don't feel like a failure if my world doesn't look like it popped up out of Pinterest. Woulda coulda shoulda  - Meh. Life is too short to spend it beating myself up (that's what book reviewers are for - LOL), but I'm with Hank. Bacon is always a good idea.

LUCY BURDETTE: It's not so much that shoulds feel like a reflection on my character, as I prefer things to be neat and tied up. John is a sweetheart and truly a team player, but he can step right over a mess--he literally doesn't see it. If you don't see it, you don't feel you should do something about it, right? I think that's part of the male/female difference, and it may very well be socialized.

RHYS BOWEN: I think I've spent a lifetime of shoulds. The good child who always got As and turned in homework on time. Vice president and editor of the college newspaper. And after that met every deadline, volunteered at schools and church and community.... I don't think I've ever goofed off! How boring is that?

So I've been overwhelmed with shoulds. Like Julia I tell myself that somebody has to do it and nobody else has stepped up so it has to be me. But now I'm asking why I have to be the only good child. And I'm only now just learning to say NO. It's very kind of you to invite me to speak at your fundraiser, but sorry, I don't really want to.

Rhys' inspiration by poet Jenny Joseph
So from now on I'm going to be the poster child for "when I get old I'm going to wear purple."   And as I'm writing this I'm thinking I have ten minutes before I have to go to church for choir practice and get the breakfast started before John gets back from his church. And I need to write five pages today. So I guess I'm not exactly going to wear purple yet! 



Readers?  What do you think about "The Shoulds?"