Monday, November 16, 2026

Book Questions of the Day!



HANK PHILLIPPI RYAN: Random questions about book world. What do you think?


I read a big article somewhere about how the trend is for books to be shorter. That instead of 385 pages, for commercial fiction at least, 285 pages is better. Short books, yay, you can read more of them. Do you agree?


I read a big article somewhere :-)  about how the trend for books is to be longer. People love long books! Ariel Lawhon’s  wonderful The Pirate Queen is 500 pages, and hit The Times list! Long books, yay. What do you think?


Have you heard of this thing called "total immersion” reading? It means you listen to the audiobook at the same time you read the physical book. So you’re looking at the words while someone reads them to you. Have you ever done that? What do you think about that?


Listening to an audiobook, some people think, doesn’t count as reading. Like if someone asked you:  how many books did you read last month? The answer could not include audiobooks because somehow that’s not really reading. What do you think about that?


Fewer people are buying physical books now—so publishers have decided that the way to change that is to make the books into irresistible packages. Sprayed edges, gilded covers, elaborate illustrations and end pieces. Sets where the spines match when you line them up on the shelf.  Of course, they can be more expensive. Does a prettier book make it more desirable?




More horror! Everyone wants horror. I hear this every day.   Yes? No? Why?


No more free books! The marketing tactic of sending early readers free ARCs –whether digital or physical – – is a waste of money and does not increase sales. Nobody who gets a free galley is going to buy a finished book, so in sending such a person an early copy, you are losing a sale. Have you ever bought a finished book when someone sends you an advance copy? Do you think free books boost sales?


Free books! Genius.  If you get a cool free book, you’re going to put it on Instagram (or whatever) and say “look at this!” And voilĂ , thousands more people might see it. And they might buy it. Maybe that makes up for losing the one sale? 


What have you been thinking about, reds and readers? And what are your answers to these bookish questions?


RHYS BOWEN:  I think that publishers have no idea what drives sales, what works and what doesn’t. They are always chasing after the next big thing and always surprised when something they hadn’t thought of is a big hit. The only one predictor I have seen is that if they spend money marketing the book it does better than a book with no promotion. Thus books with bigger advances usually outsell midlist titles. Sad but true.


I did a survey of my own readers once and was surprised how many bought more than one format of my books. The hardcover to go on the shelf, the ebook to read and audio when they walked the dog. I suspect that we’ll see a drop in the sale of hardcovers, since they are now $30, which I consider ridiculous! 


As for longer or shorter: I never think about length. I write until I’ve said all I want to and brought a story to a satisfying conclusion. It’s rarely less than three hundred pages and rarely much more than 400. I do find that very long books are often in serious need of good editing. 


JULIA SPENCER-FLEMING: I love a long, long book, but I agree with Rhys they still need to be tightly edited. (There’s a well-loved writer whose novels, if you slashed all the in-depth descriptions of characters traveling from here to there, would be shorter by a fourth.)


On the other hand, WOLF HALL? THE STAND? DR STRANGE AND MR NORRELL? Or how about THE BONFIRE OF THE VANITIES, coming in at a whopping 700 pages? I wouldn’t want a single word cut from these wonderful reads.


As for the rest, as my first publisher told me, “If we knew what sold books, everything we publish would be a bestseller.”


DEBORAH CROMBIE: So many good questions, Hank. No one’s told me to write shorter books! And I love a good long book and will continue to buy them. However, in my experience, anything that goes much over 400 pages needs multiple complicated threads.


Like Rhys’s readers (including me) I often buy books I really like in more than one format. But while I might have a book as e-book or in print AND listen to the audiobook, I haven’t tried reading and listening at the same time. Curious as to other’s experiences with this.


And ARGGH, of course listening to audiobooks counts as reading!!


I think I just read that actually sales of hardcover books are up (hope that’s true) but I don’t know that I’m influenced by the fancy packaging. I love looking at those gilded-edge books in the bookstore but so far none have tempted me to actually buy. 


No on horror. I didn’t like horror when I was younger and am now a bigger sissy than ever.


Who on earth knows about the free books? Certainly not the publisher. I have actually bought hardcover copies of books that  I’ve received as ARCs, but only if it’s a very favorite author. I have no idea if the number of free books sent to influences (gah) and reviewers actually dent sales. Anyone else have a clue? What a crazy business…


JENN McKINLAY: I am laughing/crying too hard to answer in depth. These questions are exactly why writing is such an awesome but also miserable profession.

I suppose that’s true of any occupation that has market trends dictating everything from length of book, type of genre, format of the book, whether free books garner enthusiasm or not, etc and etc.

All I know is that the old cliche “write the book you want to read” is the truest advice I’ve ever been given. The minute I wrote for myself, I was successful but when I wrote for the market, not so much. 


LUCY BURDETTE: What Rhys said makes sense to me–nobody really knows what will take off, which leaves us writing the best book we can and crossing our fingers for the rest! But here are some of my opinions:


  1. I can find the heft of a long book daunting, so it better grab me quickly or I won’t go on. 

  2. Pretty books: This is funny because I recently splurged and bought a book by Abby Jimenez which consists of three holiday novellas. It’s called ‘an illustrated holiday collection’ and it’s beautiful, including sprayed edges and gilt cover LOL. I love looking at it and only hope the stories are good too!

  3. Of course audiobooks are reading, though I don’t listen to a lot of them. I could imagine listening to one, falling in love, and then needing to buy the hard copy. I cannot imagine listening while reading–way too distracting.

  4. No never horror for me!!


HALLIE EPHRON: Hank’s questions had me running screaming from the room! There is no magic bullet in book-dom. Today’s “magic bullet” is tomorrow’s “kiss of death.” And I confess, I do not “read” audio books. Or audio articles (I steer clear of them on the newspaper web sites.) I fall asleep.

Maybe it has something to do with my hearing which is going south. Or maybe it’s because when I read text I can skip over the boring parts.

And in my house, bookshelves are full, and there’s a revolving door. A book comes in one minute, gets read (or not), and gets donated to my library’s used book sale. My shelf of “keepers” numbers about 40. Each one special to me in its own way.

Lucy said it: no one knows what makes a bestseller. Of course it has nothing to do with sprayed edges though those are way cool. 



HANK: Oh, Hallie, please do not go running from the room. That’s so dismaying. And yes, Julia, Bonfire of the Vanities, one of my all-time faves.


So Reds and Readers, if you are not running screaming from the room, what do you think?


No comments:

Post a Comment