RHYS BOWEN
Anyone who knows me knows that I am a big softie. I can’t watch horror movies. I can’t read really noir novels. Take someone down in the cellar and I close the book. I even hate killing spiders (of which I’m mortally afraid). Instead I try to put a glass over it, slide a sheet of paper between us and carry it outside. I once did this with a brown recluse (I only found out what it was later). So I hate killing things.
This applies to my books. Sometimes I have a victim who is so obnoxious that I am quite happy to bump them off. But more frequently I am sorry they have to die. When I was writing young adult novels, back in the time of stone tablets, I had to write a mini-series in which each book had a different telling of the life of a high school boy who ends up killing himself. During those four books I grew very fond of him and I didn’t want him to die. I put off those last chapters until the publisher was yelling at me.
I’m going through the same thing now. I’m in the throes of a new stand-alone, part of which involves a woman parachuted into Nazi-occupied France during WWII. I know bad things have to happen. The life expectancy of a female operative undercover in France was three months. I have read all the personal accounts and biographies of the female spies and I know what awful things Nazis did to captured women. Some of them I can’t get out of my head. But I can’t bring myself to write the worst of them. I simply can’t make my character suffer that much. And yet a brave rescue wouldn’t be realistic. She’s got to survive, but to survive a great cost and with a passionate hatred for her captor.
And so I am hesitating, procrastinating. Also I am aware of my fan-base. They like my books because they can handle my stories. So I can’t shock them too much. Any torture will have to be off-page or more psychological than physical. I simply can’t pull out her fingernails one by one. I once got a piece of wood under one fingernail. I tiny sliver of wood. It was excruciating. So I can’t do that. I’ll get her through it somehow but I don’t want to have to write that scene.
I’m curious, Reds, do you have problems inflicting pain, writing violence, killing someone on the page? Maybe I should have stuck to children’s books. “There was once a happy little duckling who lived in the farmyard pond…. Until the fox came one night and… Oh right
That’s it. I think it makes the reader shudder in horror and sympathy, without ever resorting to a description of the violence or it’s effects.
Jenn McKinlay: Rhys, I adore your posts. Ducklings..fox. LOL!
Well, I think we all know that I’m no good at torture and grisly killings as I’m always looking for the joke and it’s hard to find the humor when someone’s head gets lopped off or their private bits are being electrocuted in a torture scene.
I try to craft victims that I can’t abide (I have a running list of potential victims based on real people who severely annoy me – don’t judge, it’s therapy), and hopefully the reader can’t stand them either, so that when they do die it’s not terribly surprising or sad but justice is still served and the murderer is caught at the end. I can admit it. I like things tidy, even my murders.
HALLIE EPHRON: I’m with you, Rhys, on eschewing pain and violence. But I don’t write about female operatives parachuting into Nazi territory, either. It’s easier to avoid in domestic suspense, since the angst is usually mental. In real life I save spiders, too. And right now I’m torn over a mouse (or two) that I think is visiting my kitchen nightly. Trap or kill? Huge ick factor.
HANK PHILLIPPI RYAN: I don’t like killing people in the first place, which I know is odd for a murder mystery author. That’s why I go for violence of the mind—how much people can hurt and mislead each other emotionally and psychologically. Selfishness and manipulation and gaslighting. Jeffery Deaver once had a scene where a truly bad guy plugged in an iron. And that was the end of the chapter. We never saw anything specific that happened after that about the iron, we just had to imagine. Which I did. And still do.
And yes, I’d rather have it be in the reaction. And the only thing I can kill with only a brief regret is a clothes moth.
DEBORAH CROMBIE: I'm with you, Rhys! I am such a softie. I hate for bad things to happen to people (or animals) in books or movies. But if nothing bad happens, you don't have much of a plot for a murder mystery, and I think if you only kill off unlikeable characters, your readers will not be very invested in the outcome. So I have made myself do in characters that I absolutely loved, and have probably needed therapy–or at least a restorative retreat– afterwards. A former editor once told me that I was "too nice to be a mystery writer." Probably true.
LUCY BURDETTE: You are awfully nice Debs! I too can’t take a lot of violence, and certainly no torture. Luckily, writing cozies, I’m off the hook for that. Someone does have to die–it’s expected–but I don’t have to show it in my pages. If I should forget and happen to shade into something a bit too graphic, my editor nudges me back on track. I try very hard to work on finding a reasonable motive, and have the bad guy not be too much of a cardboard character. It feels important to take something as intense and extreme as killing another person very seriously.
RHYS: You see--we're a bunch of softies. I knew it. But since we've all chosen to write mysteries then occasionally bad things have to happen. How about you, dear readers? Can you handle on page violence? Or do you prefer anything awful to take place off screen?










