Showing posts with label plotting mysteries. Show all posts
Showing posts with label plotting mysteries. Show all posts

Friday, September 29, 2017

Plot Group by Jenn McKinlay

Plot group, critique group, writing club, house of pain, whatever you want to call the shared writing experience, I have never done it. My entire writing career has been me, alone, staring into the abyss (aka, my computer monitor) snatching the words out of the deep dark and twisting them into some sort of storytelling order. I have always been a solo unit and have never even let anyone glimpse my work(s) in progress. Never. Not once. Until this weekend.



This weekend, I am headed off to the Valley Ho Hotel (it’s actually in my neighborhood) with two mystery writer friends where we are going to hole up and plot murder and mayhem of the fictional kind together, taking a short break for my book signing at the Poisoned Pen on Saturday afternoon and then it’s back to the cave.

Am I nervous? A little bit. I’ve never done a collaborative process before. I did some research and found this fabulous post on Jungle Red (naturally) that Hallie posted a few years ago and the tips in it are excellent: http://www.jungleredwriters.com/2011/08/dark-side-of-writing-groups-editor.html So, thank you for that, Hallie!

Why haven’t I done the writing group thing before? Mostly, because up until now, my life was hemmed in by my chauffeuring hooligan duties. Now that H1 is driving (gulp!), I have more freedom for meetings, clubs, groups, etcetera, so I am taking full advantage. Also, it was so very personal in the beginning. I mean, what if fellow writers thought it was awful or that I was a hack? I couldn’t handle that!


I am curious to see how it goes. The three of us are all traditionally published authors with multiple series in our backlists. We’re each looking for a fresh angle for our fictional chicanery and hope that our hive mind can generate some new twists and turns in our plotting, thus it’s called “plot group” as opposed to “writing group”. I hear there will be snacks involved so either way it's a win-win for me. I will be sure to report back in the coming weeks to let you know how it went. 


Chime in, Reds, do you work completely alone, with a critique group, beta readers, spousal input, or what have you? If you do, how do you like it? If not, why not?

Monday, June 1, 2015

Forwards or Backwards?


DEBORAH CROMBIE: The other day a writer friend who was struggling with a plot asked me if I played chess or was good at strategy games, and if so, did it help with plotting?

My answer was a horrified "No!" NO to both questions! My dad tried to teach me to play chess but instead of learning strategy I made up stories about knights and rooks and bishops. My dad could always beat me at gin rummy because I'd forget what cards he was holding. Same with the bidding domino game 42, which my family played passionately. I loved listening to the click of the dominoes and making patterns with the dots, but...  Hmm, it's becoming obvious I'm not a gifted forward thinker.

So how do I plot a complicated mystery? I explained to my friend that I figure out where I think the various parts of the story should end, and then I work backwards, figuring out what things have to happen to get from the end back to the beginning of the story. Is that weird? I do know other writers who only work forwards, but I've always thought it must be really difficult to stitch the pieces together.

Fellow REDS, how do you do it? Do you plot backwards or forwards? And are you good at strategy games?

(I am, by the way, reasonable good at crosswords and Scrabble, so am not completely game challenged!)


HANK PHILLIPPI  RYAN: So fascinating!  I am:  Forward, forward, forward. Absolutely.  Otherwise there's no "this, because of this" to it. And things happen for a reason--because of what happened before. I am a complete cause and effect writer.  I am so impressed, Debs, that you do it the other way.

Scrabble? Love it--and was unbeatable. Until I met Jonathan. He KILLED me, because he plans ahead. Which I can never do. (So I refuse to play with him anymore. He's just too intimidatingly good.) Chess? I still tried to do it step by step, which  spells doom.  And cards? Yeesh, you are supposed to remember? Not me. No way.

HALLIE EPHRON: We'll have to match Jonathan up against Jerry one day on opposite sides of the Scrabble board. I refuse to play with him because I'm a lousy loser. I am pretty good at bridge (better than my husband), and you do have to see a way through from start to finish and come up with "what if's" along the way. So it's not unlike plotting a novel except that SOMEONE DEALS YOU THE CARDS. Oh, how I wish someone would deal me some cards for a novel and then I'd just have to see my way through from start to finish. The ending is always the same in bridge. Someone wins. Someone loses. And you always run out of cards.


 LUCY BURDETTE: Funny Hallie! I'm a decent bridge player too, except for remembering the cards and planning the play out. Okay, I should amend--I'm good at bidding:). I also love Boggle.

With writing, my editor has sort of adjusted to the fact that I don't seem to know what will happen in a book until it happens. At some point in the writing though, I do skip ahead and write a chapter or two close to the end. That gives me something to shoot for the rest of the book. So it's forward, forward, forward, skip ahead, back, back, forward. No wonder I'm feeling dizzy...

DEBS: Hallie, you have just given us the REDS official motto! So it's not unlike plotting a novel except that SOMEONE DEALS YOU THE CARDS. We all want someone to deal us the cards... But in the meantime, we'll have to muddle along by whatever method works best for us. 

But does the backwards or forwards mindset apply to reading as well as plotting? READERS, do you try to stay a step ahead of the writer and guess who done it?  Or do you just go along with the story, then think back over how it was put together when you get to the end? (Assuming, of course, that you were surprised... We'd like to think you were.)

You can probably guess that I fall into the second category, although if the mechanics of the plot hit me over the head in the first couple of chapters, I will probably give up on the book. What about you??

P.S. Lucy, what's Boggle?

P.S.S. Don't you love the red knight in the chess photo? How appropriate. 

P.S.S.S. And one last note, thinking of that master of the crossword, Colin Dexter. Now there's someone who knows how to put a plot together!