7 smart and sassy crime fiction writers dish on writing and life. It's The View. With bodies.
Thursday, May 22, 2025
Hallie's going on about what makes us stop reading
My talk: "DEADLY DOZEN: How not to shoot yourself in the foot writing a mystery novel."
Here's me, revving up the crowd with the still sturdy Detection Club Oath, coined in 1930 by Golden Age British mystery writers who included G. K. Chesterton, Agatha Christie, and Dorothy L. Sayers.
In the process of preparing for my talk, I unearthed an article ("What makes me stop reading a mystery") that I wrote in 2009 for (the sadly now defunct) THE WRITER magazine. As part of my research for that piece, I'd interviewed our wonderful Boston area mystery bookseller Kate Mattes, mystery reader/reviewer and librarian Lesa Holstine, St. Martin's Minotaur editor Kelley Ragland, and literary agent Janet Reid.
So pause for a moment and think of the mystery novels you've started, read a chapter or maybe two, and then set the book aside. What made you abandon it: Reasons?
Here's some of the reasons the experts I interviewed said they stop reading:
1. Taking too long to get going. "That doesn't mean there has to be a murder right away but I have to be interested enough to get to the murder." (Kate Mattes)
2. A main character who doesn't actively solve the mystery. "I have to care what happens to the main character." (Lesa Holstine)
3. Too much introductory material, background information, or one-by-one introductions to the main characters complete with description. "A savvy writer jumps right into things and feathers in the necessary information as she moves forward." (Kelly Ragland)
4. A dull narrator's voice. "Voice and character can keep me reading even if nothing is happening." (Janet Reid)
What would you add to (or strike from) the list?
Wednesday, May 21, 2025
Rhys is in Scotland (vicariously).
RHYS BOWEN: When you read this I'll be on a plane, about to land in London. It will be a short trip just long enough for John to visit his sister in Cornwall and for a few days in London. We'll be seeing family and maybe doing a little shopping (and eating cream teas, Cornish pasties, full English breakfast and all those delicious things that make your cardiologist turn pale.)
This was supposed to include a trip to Scotland, to check on sites for the novel I'm writing at the moment, FROM SEA TO SKYE, but we both felt that John was not up to changing trains and going through rugged scenery. So my trip to Skye has to be entirely in my head this time.
Luckily I have been there and can picture all the scenery and there are all kinds of wonderful tools to remind me of the island. I've been gazing at the map, watching YouTube videos and spent most of last week on Google Earth. As you know, I like to keep things as accurate as possible, so I've been checking on exactly what I would see at any point in a journey from A to B on Skye. The one thing that is very clear to me is that there are so few people on the island, apart from summer visitors who come in campers. It truly is a remote and fairly hostile sort of place--bare hillsides, steep and craggy mountains and a few tiny villages, even today.
And the weather? I remember the weather so clearly. We had had a glorious week driving through Scotland. We took the ferry across to Skye with the view of the mountainous island ahead of us, and watched a magnificent sunset. It was indeed a magical sort of place. The next morning the mist had come in and had blotted out every single feature on the island. We drove around with me in the back seat, reading from the guidebook :To our left is probably the best view of the magnificent Cuillin mountains..
"Shut up," the other occupants of the car snapped. We could see literally ten feet around the car and that was it. So I never saw the famous rock formation or the Cuillins close up. We stayed three days with permanent rain, mist, cloud and finally gave up and retreated back to the mainland. So now I'm seeing the sights I missed via YouTube. Thank heavens for the internet.
I'm almost finished with the first draft and there will be a lot of editing and shifting scenes around because it's a book within a book--an old woman who is writing a story we think is fiction, but turns out to be fact. So I've a character in 1965 reading a story set in 1935 but that really took place in 1903. Yes, it's complicated!
Here is a snippet to whet your interest:
Excerpt from THE WILD GIRL, by Iris Blackburn
When McIntyre saw the size of the car ferry he was even more grateful that he had not accepted the offer of a vehicle. This car ferry was a recent addition to the crossing but it was not a huge steamer, rather a flat bottomed crate that didn’t look as if it was sea worthy, with space for only two cars at once. He watched a driver trying to maneuver his delivery van on board while the swell of the sea lifted the ramp up and down.
To his relief he found that the passenger ferry to the island was a bigger craft, a proper steamer that looked seaworthy. He paid his money and walked on board, taking a seat at the prow of the vehicle. Across a strait of shining silver water he saw the island, a low shoreline rising to a chain of blue-grey mountains in the distance. It was a fine blustery spring day and whitecaps dotted the sea. Remembering the way his stomach had reacted on that coach ride as a boy he hoped he was not prone to sea-sickness. It would be ironic since his father had spent his life building boats, although to McIntyre’s knowledge his dad had never actually been on one.
Exactly on the hour the gangplank was raised, the engine sputtered to life and the boat moved away from the dock. As it met the oncoming waves it rose and fell, sending fine spray over the side and making McIntyre hastily move into the center. He found he was holding his breath, waiting for the sea-sickness to strike. When it didn’t he looked around, rather surprised. The other passengers across from him, two women with shopping baskets and local tweed shawls wrapped over their heads and shoulders, a man with a suitcase and an older couple, were chatting easily as if this crossing on the wild seas was the most normal thing in the world. McIntyre heard the soft Gaelic sounds of their speech, so different from the harsh Glasgow dialect. It look him a while to realize they were actually speaking Gaelic, not English and he found himself wondering if he’d be able to communicate once he got to Skye. Surely all school children had to learn English, didn’t they?
Once away from shore the boat settled into a more gentle rhythm, rocking from side to side as it turned toward the island, as if it was in a giant cradle. Unbidden the words of a song came to McIntyre—a song learned by every school child in Scotland. Speed bonny boat like a bird on the wing, onward the sailors cry. Carry the lad who was born to be king over the sea to Skye.
The Skye Boat song, telling of Bonnie Prince Charlie, escaping from the English after his failed attempt to gain the throne. He’d been assisted by the local Scots and got away safely after risking the stormy sea crossing, remaining a romantic figure for all Scots. Anything that defied the English was treasured here in Scotland, where they were still seen as the invaders and conquerors after all those hundreds of years. As McIntyre hummed along to the rocking of the boat a strange felling came over him. His first time leaving the shores of his birth, being transported, like Bonnie Prince Charlie, over the sea to Skye. It almost felt like a rite of passage, as if he was leaving the shackles of his past life behind him and was somehow being reborn, free to be the person he wanted.
The story takes place in an inhabited castle and there are several for inspiration. Such atmosphere. I'm having fun writing it.
So fellow writers especially, who uses Google Earth? Isn't it wonderful, how you can go down to street level and there you are? I love it.
From Sea to Skye comes out July 2026.
Tuesday, May 20, 2025
What Hank's WRITTEN!
HANK PHILLIPPI RYAN: Fanfare! Ruffles and flourishes! I am so incredibly excited. I am writing this at 6:11 PM on Monday, and yes, that is very very late to be writing a blog for Tuesday but there is a reason.
My book was due Monday. Yes, ALL THIS COULD BE YOURS will be out this September. It’s all done! But I’ve been working for the last year on the next book.
But here is the year in the life of my new book.
1. I will never have a good idea again.
2. I will never have a good idea again and my life is over, and I am utterly and totally doomed. I have no idea how I wrote my other books, and I will never be able to write another one. What am I going to do? I'm going to have to tell everybody that I cannot do it, and no one will be happy about this. Plus, I will have to give back the money.
3. I have an idea!
4. It's a terrible idea. I will never have a good idea again.
5. I have a possible good idea. Possibly. It's possibly a good idea.
6. It's a terrible idea. I am so doomed, there isn't even a word for that.
7. I have a good idea. I do, I really do. This is going to work.
8. It's a fabulous idea, I cannot wait to write this. I type “Chapter 1.” I am so excited, I fly through the first chapter. I fly through the second chapter. New York Times bestseller, here we come. There’s a story question, there’s conflict, there’s a wonderful main character. Or two.
9. When I hit page 36, I know it is a big turning point, if I can get to page 37 the idea will hold up for the rest of the book.
10. I hit page 37! I rock, I am such a rock star, the process never fails me, this is absolutely going to work.
11. Page 100. And without even working on it very hard there's a massive twist. I am a genius! I am an utter genius! This is my calling and my passion. FABULOUS.
12. Page 105. Okay, now what. I've got 285 pages to go, what the heck is that going to be. How is this story going to last for all those more words? Plus, this was a TERRIBLE idea. Whose idea was this, anyway?
13. What does someone want, and what will they do to get it. How far will they go to get it. What would someone really do. What is the worst thing that could possibly happen, and what is worse than that. What will happen if the character fails? I ask myself all the questions that are supposed to work. Sometimes they do.
14. Time to reassure myself! Writing a book is a process, I say. One page at a time, one word at a time period don't worry about the end. The end will come when you get there. Just type type type type type even if it's terrible just keep going, just keep going. Just keep going.
15. Sometimes this is OK. Sometimes this is terrible. Most of the time I don't know which. Procrastinating. Maybe I’ll alphabetize my books. NO. Write.
16. Page 300. Ohhh no, it's going to take too long to get to the ending. The beginning is way too long. I'm really going to have to cut the heck out of the beginning because if I write at this rhythm, this will be 500 pages long and that's never going to work. I will just keep going, and cut later. But what should I cut? How do I know?
17. Still, maybe I should go back and cut now.
18. No, I'll just go ahead. I can’t cut until I know the ending.
19. Page 350. Getting there! If only I knew what the ending was.
20. I totally don't know the ending. I’ll edit from the beginning, editing is good. I’ll also take out all the uses of “baffled” and “somehow” and “maybe.” Edit edit edit. And the momentum will swing me right into the ending.
21. Nope. Lots of wonderful edits, but I still utterly and totally don't know the ending, and moreover I have created a mystery that I cannot solve. I should have thought of this. I wish I had an outline, but I don't know how to make outlines. And I don't want to make an outline. I just want the ending.
22. I don't have an ending. I have 110,000 words, and no ending. This is not good. Who lives, who dies, who tells the story. I have one of those.
23. See #14. One word at a time. Something will happen. It’s worked before. Keep going keep going keep going.
24. I totally don't know the ending. Still. And the deadline is two days away.
25. The deadline is one day away.
26. Wait! I might have it! Yes. I have it.
27. Deadline day. Typing like a maniac. Typing like crazy. Working working working working working. EDITING EDITING EDITING. Taking out” actually” and “of course.” And “little.” Wearing my special deadline hoodie.
28. Done!
29. Not really done. Checking checking checking. Rewriting. Cutting. Cutting cutting cutting.
30. DONE! For now at least. But that is enough.
And I hit SEND. At two minutes until deadline, and I am incredibly grateful.
Now. I need a new idea. Ahhh. See #1.
Reds and Readers, thank you for being here through this! ALL THIS COULD BE YOURS will be out in September, and I wish I’d had this chart then to reassure me it’s ALWAYS this way. Next year, when I complain, you’ll remind me, right?

















