Thursday, October 23, 2025

The Changing of the Gar...ment

JULIA SPENCER-FLEMING: There are many, many fall chores to be done when you live in the northeastern US. You want to check the doors and windows for drafts, get the oil tank filled, start (or finish) stacking the wood, clean up the garden and the lawn, etc. etc.

There's one chore I always dread and put off until I absolutely can't any more, so I'm pleased to be able to say I finally did it Tuesday. Yes, I changed out my summer wardrobe for my winter clothes.

I suppose there are some places this task is unnecessary. Southern Florida, Southern California, Southern Arizona... you get the drift. But most everywhere else, the weather change is enough to require a different collection of garments. At the very least you need a few light sweaters and a jacket and coat.

Up here in Vacationland, we're serious about our winter wear. (I know you readers in Canada and the northern midwest are nodding along.) Summer is sleeveless tops, cropped pants, canvas sneakers.  Winter is long-sleeved T plus a flannel shirt plus a wool sweater. Corduroy pants and insulated, waterproof boots.

Again, some of you lucky readers live in contemporary houses with abundant closet space. Maybe switching up your attire is a matter of moving everything from room A to room B, hangars and all. But I, alas, live in This Old House, where the tiny closets were created years after the place was built, by boxing in part of the walls. So my off-season clothing is stored, you guessed it, up in the attic.

We have a traditional attic - low, sloping ceilings waiting to give you a concussion, a single hanging bulb to illuminate the whole-house-wide space, and 2-3 generations of STUFF crowding what should be a clear center aisle. Oh, and don't forget the rickety pull-down ladder (partial handrail on only one side) that's the only was to get up there. (Don't worry, family and friends, I take my phone with me, so if I fall and break something, I can still dial for help.)

You can understand why I eke out my warm-weather attire well into October. I'll layer two cotton sweaters over a 3/4 sleeve shirt, and pull knee-high socks up to cover the gap created by pedal pushers. This being Maine, I always have a couple light-weight turtlenecks in my drawers even in July, and they see HEAVY rotation between mid-September and mid-October.

But eventually, a combination of increasingly cold temperature, boredom with wearing the same three warm items over and over, and embarrassment over being seen in public with cropped pants and woolly socks forces me into action. It takes about three hours to do the changeover - as long as the cat doesn't make it up the stairs and into mouse hunting heaven. (She's getting on in years and is mercifully less inclined to do this these days.)

By the time I'm done, my knees hurt, my shoulder aches from hauling outfits on hangers up and down the ladder, and it feels like I have permanent dents in my fingers from the aforementioned hooks. 

But it's always a pleasure to be reintroduced to clothing I haven't seen in months (particularly this year, as I've lost some weight and am finding tops and bottoms that are a bit large for me!) Obviously, I've never done the Millennial shopping haul thing, but meeting my wardrobe again feels close. (Also? Much cheaper.) Oo, brushed velveteen! Yummy cashmere! Cozy vests!

I'll do the whole thing over again in May, by which time I'll be sick to death of all these thrillingly newish clothes. I'll go through the same process, and find the same pleasure in the reappearance of the sleeveless shirts and bright colors of the summer. Who knows, maybe I'll drop a little bit more weight, and I'll be able to justify actually buying a few new items...

Dear readers, do you switch up your clothing seasonally? 



 

59 comments:

  1. Oh, my goodness, what a task . . . it never even occurred to me to switch up clothes, so, no, this isn't something that happens here.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Oh, yes. It all sounds quite familiar to another New Englander. I keep most of my winter stuff in tubs under the bed, so no attic "shopping" here. Some cardigans stay in use all year long.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have a tub beneath my bed a well, Marianne, but it's too low to use anything except the 4 inch high kind. I need a taller bed!

      Delete
  3. It's very familiar, Julia. Last week I switched the cotton tees and sweaters for the wools and cashmeres. Although we have an attic, the access is impossible. We have a cedar closet in the garage where most of the sweaters are stored in big soft-sided bins. I spent one day last week schlepping armloads up and down the stairs. I try to wait until we absolutely won't need those lightweight garments anymore, but autumn is so fickle. I have needed my sweaters already, so it's all good.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's the real art, isn't Judy - judging when the weather has REALLY changed for good and you won't unexpectedly need any of the summer stuff.

      Delete
  4. We have the same attic and access, but it holds summer fans, Christmas decorations, and suitcases (we did put the fans away last week, all draped in big plastic bags).

    All I do in my closet is slide the long-sleeved shirts closer and the short-sleeved ones farther away. I do have to wash all the sweaters that have been languishing folded on the closet shelf, because I'm severely allergic to stored clothing - dust? Dust mites? Maybe it would help if I stored them tightly wrapped in plastic ... but spring is too busy to remember to do that.

    Yay for you on losing weight!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It was the one good thing about having Covid for several weeks, Edith!

      Delete
  5. My idea of "Changing of the Garments" is when I switch from shorts to long pants. Which hasn't happened yet. Usually I am to make it to November 1st before I have to wear long pants.

    But it is T-shirts all year round. In the colder months, I put a sweatshirt over said T-shirt for warmth but that's about it. I wear sneakers all year round. I only put boots on if I have to shovel snow. Oh, and a hat on my head when it gets chilly enough for Jack Frost to be nipping not only at my nose but the rest of my head as well.

    I guess being a creature of habit helps in not having to change the wardrobe up every six months or so. Plus, I'm way too lazy to do all that switching around work that you described Julia.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jay, you sounds a lot like my late husband, a born-and-bred New Englander. I swear he just didn't feel the cold like I did!

      Delete
  6. I love the switch from winter to warm spring and summer but am not so fond of the reverse. I’m not a lover of winter weather, although, I love living in 4 season New England.. I do however love sweaters. And my L.L.Bean “barn jacket”. And scarves! And turtlenecks. I am lucky I only need switch from closet to closet, which I’ve been doing for the last 2 weeks, bit by bit. Someday I may figure out real spring and fall clothes.😆

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Spring and fall are SO tricky in New England, aren't they Suzette? One day the high is 48F/9C and the next day it's 80F/26C. How do you plan for that?!?

      Delete
    2. Isn’t that the truth, Julia! Layers, and layers…

      Delete
  7. This year in southern Maine: no need for winter clothes yet! But our gov't still says no climate change? I beg to differ! I've read that we finally will be getting 50 degree weather as a standard the next week or so. Up until now, it's been so warm, I haven't made the switch.... YET! But now it's inevitable, the cashmere and corduroy must come out soon! I'm thinking I will have those finger dents this weekend.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It has for sure been an unusually warm October, CT. I still have summer potted annuals out, because there's been no freeze yet! Living in the same house for almost 32 years, I see the differences...

      Delete
  8. I wear all-season clothes, but will pull out the sweat pants, hoodies, sweaters, flannel, heavy jackets, coats, scarves, and hats during the winter months. I'm told I won't need my heavier stuff down here in the south, we shall see.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Where are you, Dru? Did you move from NY? Or just visiting somewhere?

      Delete
    2. There can be some surprising cold snaps in the northern parts of the deep south. My grandparents lived in Tuscaloosa, and while I never saw snow there, there were days in the winter when you definitely needed a sweater and a heavy jacket!

      Delete
    3. Karen, I moved to North Carolina.

      Delete
  9. “Clothes switch up’ around here means find the long pants for daily use – which coincidently have been worn all summer as you need them to get on your knees to weed. Probably should wash them as they stand up on their own. Probably should invest in a new pair, as there seems to be a lot of air-conditioning in them…they are only about 10 years old, and baggy in all the right places.
    Take the sweatshirt off the back of the couch where it resided most of the summer except for at night or when I was cooking as I like to watch telly with the hood up and my hands in the pouch, and hate getting splashed with hot anything while cooking. It also works as a bib if I ‘dress’ to go out and need to keep the outfit clean for a bit. Air conditioning seems to be an issue there as well…
    My granddaughter went to camp this summer – she is the daughter and therefore a carrier of a hemophiliac so has the hereditary gene. She brought me back a purple (her favourite colour) sweatshirt with a big stylish B for Brigadoon on the front. #2 son sent me a present in September for my birthday in November – apparently, he is monthly challenged – a lovely wine sweatshirt. I wonder if they are both trying to tell me something.
    I am curious as to how long it will take to get them to the right part of wear-in-ability, and even more telling how long until I spill egg yolk down my front?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Margo, I'm laughing at your properly broken-in and conveniently air-conditioned clothing!

      Delete
  10. I do switch, because I have an old house too and a small closet in my room. I put the stuff I am not wearing in a storage container under the bed. It's time to do the old switcheroo. Some clothes (my jeans and henleys) stay out all year long. It's the winter sweaters and capri pants and sleeveless tops that get switched.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Same here, Gillian, although my bed is low and the storage container doesn't hold a whole lot. Jeans and long-sleeve Ts are available all year. Also, fortunately, by heaviest wool sweaters are in a cedar trunk at the foot of my bed, so i don't need to worry about moth-proofing them up in the attic.

      Delete
  11. Paula B here, good morning all. I’m a switcher. I used to live in the snowy part of Washington state so switching is normal. I do love to see the winter clothes as those are “normal” for me and there’s such a great variety. In the desert, well, not much variety at all. Bermudas, no longer in the shorts age range, and tanks at home with short sleeves ‘out there’. Somehow those hot weather clothes are boring. It took many years of living here before I could part with my down or wool coats. I didn’t wear them, but apparently there’s comfort in the memory of clothing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Paula, my "memory of clothing" was the dress-up outfits and very nice work suits I had back when I lived in DC. Maine is the flip of that city when it comes to dressing up - people cheerfully go to the opera in canvas pants and LLBean flannel. I finally realized I was never going to wear that clothing again and let it go on to its next life. But it took a good long while.

      Delete
  12. In the great downsizing of 2024, I reduced my wardrobe to the extent that everything for the entire year now fits in one walk-in closet and the chest of drawers in our room. Well, with the exception of a chest of drawers in the guest room that holds things I maybe should let go but still use just a few times a year, and a few pieces of formal wear that hang in the guest room closet. So I have not been engaged in a full-on changing of the garments. But I have opened the clear boxes that house the sweaters on the shelf in my closet and rediscovered my options there. I really need to go through the hanging part of the closet and reorganize those items based on what will be worn for the next five or six months.

    For those who helpfully contributed to my thinking a few weeks ago about what to take to Rome, I will post this update. The trip leaves November 3 and I have whittled my packing down to more of a capsule wardrobe, as advised. I didn't quite make it down to just four outfits, but I guess I am down to five, (with maybe a stray extra piece or two,) all in black and shades of light blue. I am glad that it finally cooled down some here, as it helped make it easier to think about what I would need for November there.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Susan, I find it so difficult to pack for a dramatically different climate (unless I already have a designated cold/hot capsule.) Standing in your bedroom when it's 80F/27C and trying to think 'cool' is really hard!

      Delete
  13. Living in the Adirondacks in a 1915 home, where the closets are sized for one good garment and two work wear, I just switched over Saturday. I’m lucky to use the closet in the next bedroom for seasonal storage.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If I can ever get my offspring to take away the stuff in their closets, Anon, I plan to do just that!

      Delete
  14. From Celia: I was back in Maine from MA a couple of weeks ago specifically to collect my winter wardrobe. This must be the third or fourth time of reorganizing clothes this year
    First turnout was clearing out Victors clothes - some to friends then Goodwill etc. a pretty easy task as I was only emotionally attached to one lovely robe i had bought him from Garnet Hill which continues to hang in the bathroom but that is enough sentimentality.
    Then with the cancer diagnosis a temporary move to my room in my daughter's home as I get treated at Dana Farber. This was in the spring so my packing was bi-seasonal and minimal. Then a gap into summer before returning home to gather more appropriate seasonal clothing.
    Each trip with this years final one I hope, has moved more clothes to my little apartment leaving two bare Maine closets. My last trip involved my taking a ruthless approach where I gave a lovely, with regret, LLB cashmere sweater to a dear friend. No it's not too small but I've developed a cashmere itch to all but THE most expensive cashmere. I left very few clothes in Maine now and will move my summer here to my room in my daughter's home so that I have room here for winter's warmth.
    No attic for me. Yes the Maine home has attic space but the entrance is through the garage and I made a vow on moving in that I wouldn't be tempted to use the space for storage. And I've kept the vow.
    I have no particular rule for clothes other than one in - one out together with when did I wear that last? In this Fall sort I finally gave away a lovely wool mix skirt I bought around the time of my fiftieth birthday and that was a time ago.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You have great discipline, Celia!

      The hardest part about having multiple homes is remembering where you left something. My daughter does that all the time.

      Delete
    2. With a winter home in Arizona we keep two separate sets of clothing. It’s always fun to discover the other wardrobe ! I hope everything is progressing well for you, Cynthia

      Delete
    3. I need to take a lesson from Celia and start paring down my clothing - then it won't be such a chore to switch from spring/summer to fall/winter!

      Delete
  15. There are two closets in my bedroom. One contains clothing for the current season, and the other holds the clothing from the upcoming season. This is now the time of year when I don’t know if I should wear my warm weather or my cold weather clothing.
    I’ve been switching things around in the last couple of weeks. And then wondering if I should switch them back! Oh, to live in a climate where it’s not necessary to switch out types of clothing depending on the weather!

    DebRo

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. DebRo, I've often wondered what people in Hawai'i do with all their extra time and money, not needing two wardrobes!

      Delete
  16. Here in SW PA, we made the switch from short-sleeves to long sleeves, sweaters and sweatshirts in the last week. I don't tend to change around my pants as much. It's always leggings or yoga pants (air conditioning) and I don't need to throw on shorts unless I venture out in public. But most of my clothes for all seasons fit in the combination of closet and dresser.

    The Hubby, however, has to do the "go up in the attic and swap things around." This house doesn't have the rickety pull-down ladder, but the old one did.

    We've also taking to running the gas fireplace first thing in the morning and Koda refuses to go outside at six - too cold and dark. This morning I have a hooded sweatshirt over a mid-weight fleece pullover. I'm beginning to wonder if the boiler is on.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I just did that last week. Summer dresses down to a spare bedroom and winter clothing up to mine. Then, the very next day, it was 80 degrees!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Here in the SF Bay Area, it can be chilly in the mornings. If the sun is out early in the morning, then you know it is more likely there will be warm weather during the day. I switch my light summer jacket for my winter jacket when the weather becomes colder around October or November. Even in the summer, I wear long sleeved T because I was mortified that my bra showed while wearing short sleeves! Long sleeves all year though in the summer the material is lighter than in the winter. I love sweater weather too.

    ReplyDelete
  19. First, Julia, I hope the weight loss is a happy thing. If so, congratulations!

    What a job, and one I am not looking forward to, but need to get busy on. We have two guest bedrooms where I could put seasonal clothing, but most of the space is filled up with Steve's business stuff. I'm going to have to assert myself here. One of my changeovers is easier than others: boots from sandals. My boots, some of which are decades old, usually live in plastic boxes under the bed. This year some will have to get donated, thanks to wonky older feet, and that will help a lot.

    My mother is the Queen of the Seasonal Changeover, and more than a little OCD about it. She insists on washing every single thing in her closet before putting it away, even if it was just laundered. Then every single thing stored from last season gets laundered before it goes into her closet, despite have been washed before it was stored. She drives herself nuts, frankly, but she has done this for so many years and is obsessed with getting it done. Bless my sister-in-law for accommodating her (Mother lives with her and my brother).

    ReplyDelete
  20. Here in Switzerland, we definitely make the clothes switch, and I've already made it. I'm layered up: tucked-in undershirt, cotton t-shirt, maybe a blouse if I'm going out, part-wool sweater, and fleece hoodie plus long pants and wool knee socks--and that's what I wear INDOORS with the heat on in an apartment with triple-pane windows. The most significant switch is from wearing my indoor sandals with no socks in August, to wearing them with socks in September, to wearing my sheepskin-lined suede slippers with wool socks in October. Oh yes, I also switch from my summer duvet to my winter one (much thicker)--I did that in late September already.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Been dreading it and so grateful for this year's extended fall. I figure this wash day will be the one where I change the cotton sheets out for flannel and haul out the midweight down duvet - the heavyweight one stays folded until January/February. Closet space is tight here, too. I'll be taking the clothes from the winter spacebags and replacing them with the summer attire. Sigh, I'll miss my comedy tee shirts! Oil ordered, wood stacked, plow arrangements made - yep, winter will be here!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Changing the duvet is always the hardest for us, Kait. Typically we change it and the very next day the temperature goes up to where it's ridiculously hot and we need to switch back. This continues until at least Christmas. It's very thick and 100% goose down, so unless the overnights are in the 20s, it's way too warm for me.

      Delete
  22. I haven't done any real clothing switch in years with the exception moving the shirts with longer sleeves to the front of the closet. They magically moved toward the back during the warmer months.

    ReplyDelete
  23. I used to switch, but am lucky enough to have a big closet with an attached cedar closet so aside from storing sweaters for the winter in cedar to avoid moths (which I've had when I got too lazy to bother- --I learned the hard way by losing all my sweaters) I leave everything in place. My granddaughter came in this summer and was ruthless--discarded piles of clothes she said she has never seen me wear and never wants to see me wear!! She'll be home this weekend to get rid of the rest that I don't wear. Maybe then I too will get some new clothes!!

    ReplyDelete
  24. Central AZ confirming that we do not switch out our wardrobe, merely shift from shorts to pants and short sleeves to long with the occasional light hoodie thrown in.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Oh, brave woman! I don't even climb to reach top shelves any longer. I've told the niblings that anything on a high shelf is theirs for the taking, as I'm clearly not using it. (They have also been taking the too-small clothes from the spare room closet -- they call it "vintage"). I have pulled jackets from the coat closet, as it's finally getting a bit chilly in Missouri. No big changeover, just gradual transition as I choose the clothes I want and then put them away closer to front and center. Enjoy the "seem like new" clothes. <3

    ReplyDelete
  26. Chicago here! Oh yeah, twice yearly ritual that includes switching summer (bigger) and winter (snugger under outer layer) t-shirts.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Susan Nelson-HolmdahlOctober 23, 2025 at 12:54 PM

    We have eighty degree weather in the Bay Area until after Thanksgiving.
    When working at home I switch to long sleeved T-shirts. I wear shorts year round.
    I wear summer weight slacks snd blazers for professional meetings, I am an Attorney, but most of the time work from home.
    My few light weight hoodies are in the far side of the closet.
    I do not have sweaters or coats.
    No switching wardrobes at all.

    ReplyDelete
  28. San Diego also confirming that we make the same switches as Jenn reported. I started wearing jeans a couple of weeks ago when we were a little cooler than usual (high 60s vs mid-80s), but that only lasted a couple of days. We were promised, okay, it was hinted at, some precipitation yesterday, but alas, nothing.

    My parents in the San Francisco Bay Area used to do the switch after my sister and I had moved out. The seasonal storage was upstairs in my sister’s and my old bedroom closets. Mom would send Dad up to get the seasonally appropriate clothes and put away the others. — Pat S

    ReplyDelete
  29. Old Maine house with 1 closet for entire house! Yes, switched over to winter wear a couple weeks ago.Move tubs of clothing ,empty dresser, fill dresser, fill tubs back again and move tubs back into space over garage. Then there's the hats,gloves, mittens, boots & coats.They are in LR closet,wiating for colder weather to move. It's a great time to toss /donate what you no longer want. GREAT JOB loosing some weight!

    ReplyDelete
  30. When we added to our house, I treated myself to a walk-in closet, and now I have entirely too many clothes that I *never* wear. Why is it so hard to weed, and why does it seem as if it's always the one thing I decide to get rid of is the one thing I'm looking for soon after?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I try to comfort myself with the thought that without the clear-out, I wouldn’t have missed the item for a particular occasion because I probably wouldn’t have remembered that it existed.

      Delete
  31. Yup, lay in bed last night (in Toronto--Go Jays!) saying....TIME FOR THE FLANELLETTE SHEETS. Stripped the bed first thing this morning.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Clothes switching is a thing here in north Texas, Julia! My daughter did hers yesterday, but I am of course the laggard. However, since I never managed to switch most of last winter's things to summer, I should be ahead of the game, right?

    Really, I did actually switch all the casual stuff, short-sleeved tees to long-sleeved, etc. Off season things go in plastic tubs in the attic, and our attic, thank goodness is walk-in, so no climbling ladders. The nicer, hanging things get switched between my closet in our bedroom (old house, so it's shallow and built into one wall of former attic space) and the horrible mess of a closet in my office. But we have suddenly started to drop down into the 40s in the early mornings, so progress must be made...

    ReplyDelete
  33. Just did this last week! Our weather change is a bit less dramatic than Maine, but sweaters come out to play in October.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Even after moving to SoCal, I kept my Great Lakes ways. For work, mainly, swapping between the black, grey and brown suits with mock turtlenecks and the cream, bright colors and silk shells. No attic in the house, so the attic in the garage, also up the pull-down ladder with the sharp bits that would catch the plastic dry cleaners bags.
    Between the warming climate and menopause, I haven’t used any of my light jackets in years. Looking forward to using them in Nice - it looks like it will be a bit cooler there in winter, plus so much of the dining is outside.

    ReplyDelete
  35. I have a double closet in my bedroom, and that should be plenty of space for holding wardrobe choices for year round, but, alas, I need to do a weeding. I don't switch up my warm and cold weather clothes. I just gradually move the clothes I need for the particular season to the center and front. I have a coat closet in the foyer, so it holds jackets, raincoats, and heavy coats all year.

    ReplyDelete