HANK PHILLIPPI RYAN: Are you in a book club? Have you ever been? Every author will tell you they are the absolute pinnacle of delight. To be surrounded by people who love your books and want to talk about it --what could be better? And for readers, please know that so many authors are thrilled with a book club invitation.
The fantastic and brilliant Hannah Mary McKinnon, my dear friend, and founder of First Chapter Fun and now my partner in fictional crime, and wildly successful best-selling author (whose marvelous new THE REVENGE LIST is an instant Canadian bestseller!) has been on both sides of the book club couch: as an honored guest, and as host.
And today, she has some inside scoop on everything you need to know about book clubs.
HANNAH MARY MCKINNON: So, you want to start a book club?
As an author, I’ve had the pleasure of being invited as a guest to
several book clubs, in person and online. Each time has been wonderful, and what struck me the most was the camaraderie amongst the members, so much so that I decided to start a book club in 2019.Unfortunately, Covid hit three months later, but we persevered online, and have kept going for over three years already. It’s been great fun, and I thought I’d share some tips and tricks on creating your own book club, in case you’ve been toying with the idea but aren’t sure where to begin.
1) Find members
You could drop off a flyer at your library, community centre, or book store (or ask if they have an online option) — these all fabulous places to start. Personally, I posted about starting a book club in a local Facebook mom’s group and was inundated with replies. Although I only expected a handful of participants, over 60 women indicated their interest. That number initially settled at 18 and, over time, naturally reduced to around 10.
On average, 6-8 people attend monthly because of e.g., vacation, family commitments, and scheduling conflicts. It’s a great number as everyone gets to chat, and we’ve been able to get to know each other better in a smaller group.
2) Have an introductory meeting
I held the initial meeting at my house as a “meet-and-greet” where we introduced ourselves, chatted about the genre of books we enjoy (or don’t care for), and talked about the structure of the group. The biggest problem was figuring out what to do with all the food everyone generously brought.
If you don’t have the space or you’re not keen on hosting at your place, look for a local restaurant or coffee shop where the noise levels work with having conversations. I’ve found round tables work better for group discussions than rectangular ones.
3) Figure out how to pick your books and if there are rules
We opted for five rotating genres: Book Club Picks, Suspense/Thriller, General Fiction, Historical Fiction and “Wild Card” where anything goes. We plan the books two months ahead, and members make suggestions on which we vote afterward, so it’s always a consensus. Having themes means we read a variety of genres, and don’t have the same genre multiple months in a row. Other options could be whoever leads the meeting picks the book, or pulling book suggestions from a hat.
Will your club have rules? For example, do members have to finish the book to join the discussion (ours don’t). See what works best for your group.
4) Create an online group
While I initially managed all communication via email, it was much easier to shift everything to a Facebook group. The group is hidden, meaning only book club members have access, and I scheduled all our events for the year so everyone had the dates well in advance. The online group is also an easy place to share information about where we buy or from which library we borrow the books.
5) Invite authors
Admittedly, this is easier to do when you’re an author and you’ve made connections with other writers, but you might be surprised by how many authors love to be book club guests. Fortunately, with the wonders of technology you can beam them straight in via e.g. Zoom.
Whether they charge for their time depends on the author, but regardless, sharing photos and positive reviews of their novel on social media will be greatly appreciated.
Just do me a favor, please? Ask your book club members to withhold negative comments about the author’s work until after the author has left the discussion. Instead, focus on e.g., how they crafted the story, what research they undertook, which scene they had the most fun writing, and if they’d considered an alternate ending or title.
For a list of 101 questions to ask authors, click here, and if one of your group members forgets to be kind, gently jump in and recalibrate the conversation.
Still unsure about inviting an author? Two initiatives, https://invitd.ca/ and www.theauthorsbookclub.ca connect book clubs with writers who are happy to join your meeting—all you need to do is ask.
6) Ask for help
I have the great fortune of having branched out into writing romantic-comedies as well as my annual thrillers. That means I have two books publishing this year — The Revenge List (thriller) on May 23, 2023, and The Christmas Wager (romantic-comedy penned as Holly Cassidy) on September 26, 2023.
Writing two books a year means I must cut down on other things, and when I mentioned this to the group, two of the book club members immediately volunteered to take over. I can now attend as a member only without having to worry about all the coordination, and it’s been great to have fresh leadership.
When you create your book club, it’s worthwhile considering who’ll co-lead the group with you, so you don’t have to manage everything all alone.
Do you have a book club? How did yours start, how long ago, and what other tips can you share?
HANK: I was in a book club once, and it was great, and we all got to choose books. (When it was my turn, I chose one of my dear and forever favorites, Custom of the Country by Edith Wharton. Reds and readers, they all hated it. HATED. Anyway. We parted ways soon after, because I was about to be on the other side of the chat!
(And to find the perfect book, there’s also https://novelnetwork.com/ which will connect your club with 128 fantastic authors! Check it out.)
(And oh, we can all tell funny-now stories about questions we’ve been asked. SO true, dear Hannah!)
But now, in this life as an author, I give thanks for book clubs every day. And we’d love to hear more about YOURS!
Hannah Mary McKinnon was born in the UK, grew up in Switzerland and moved to Canada in 2010. Her suspense novels include THE NEIGHBORS, and bestsellers HER SECRET SON, SISTER DEAR, YOU WILL REMEMBER ME, NEVER COMING HOME, and THE REVENGE LIST.
She has also written the romantic comedy THE CHRISTMAS WAGER as Holly Cassidy.
Hannah Mary lives in Oakville, Ontario, with her husband and three sons.
Connect on Facebook and Instagram @hannahmarymckinnon, and on Twitter @HannahMMcKinnon. For more, visit www.hannahmarymckinnon.com