Wednesday, December 11, 2013

Macavity-winner Daniel Friedman Talks about Book Reviews: the Good, the Bad, and the Ugly


MISS EDNA: Susan Elia MacNeal (or, as I call her, Miss Susan) is a bit under the weather, so she asked me to fill in for one of her days on Jungle Red Writers. I’m an honorary member, after all! (See my red sweater, red adult beverage, and red nail polish—Jungle Red! And I remember the term from The Women, darlings.)
            
I’m not a mystery writer like the Reds, but I am a long time mystery and thriller fan. I remember reading my first Agatha Christie novel at around age twelve — so that’s about seventy some-odd years of reading mysteries! (Miss Edna is not embarrassed to admit her age — if you looked this good at eighty-two, you wouldn’t either.)
            
And I’m delighted to introduce today’s guest, Daniel Friedman. Dan is the author of Don’t Ever Get Old, a title Miss Edna certainly relates to. It was nominated for the Edgar, Thriller, and Anthony, and won the Macavity award for Best First Novel. (It won against my darling daughter-in-law's Mr. Churchill's Secretary — but we won't get into that
now.) It was also optioned for film by the producers of the "Sherlock Holmes" movies. (Dan, I hope you will remember Miss Edna when you are a Big Hollywood Star.)

Darlings, I must say, I’m reading Don't Ever Get Old now, and absolutely love it. First, Dan — bless him because he’s so young — has managed to capture perfectly the voice of an 80-something, with all of our aches and pains and memories. And he's funny — I bust out laughing at least five times just during the first few pages., and continue to laugh my way through.

And now, Miss Edna is thrilled to introduce Dan Friedman, author of the Macavity-award winning DON’T EVER GET OLD,  to talk about book reviews. 
           
DANIEL FRIEDMAN: Over the summer, there was a minor Twitter controversy over the Los Angeles Review of Books' policy to not publish negative reviews of first novels.  Since then, the popularwebsite Buzzfeed has hired an editor to helm a new books section that will not run any bad reviews at all.  As such "no
haters" editorial policies become more commonplace, there has been a lot of discussion among bookish types about bad reviews and whether we need them.

There's a pretty good argument against many bad book reviews: Knowing what's good is inherently more useful than knowing what's bad, because you can act on a recommendation, but not a pan.  Telling someone they should read a book is inherently more useful than telling someone they should not read a book. 

Publications have limited space or resources to devote to book reviews. Readers have limited attention to devote to them.  And publishers publish far more books than any reader can ever possibly consume, or even be aware of. 

Publishers Weekly reviews 7000 books per year, and the NYT book review, one of the last standalone book-sections still in print, manages to review only about 300 of them.  There are hundreds of books every year that get starred reviews in places like PW and and are completely ignored by mainstream publications like the NYTBR or Buzzfeed.  No good review. No bad review. No review at all.  With space and attention at such a premium, printing a bad review of a bad book, in many cases, means that the publication won't have room to run a review of a good book.  

Nobody proposes a film review site with no bad reviews because there are only about three new wide-release films a week, and publications can just review everything that's playing.  Not all of the films will be good, so some reviews must be bad.  On the other hand, if there are 300 new books out this week, and you are only running five reviews, it's a reasonable editorial priority to tell readers about the best five, rather than running a takedown on one that fails.

On the other hand, among those 7000 books are some more privileged than others; bought with giant advances and backed by enormous marketing campaigns.  When a book is commanding a huge amount of reader interest and is dominating the bestseller lists and the conversation, reviewing publications can't ignore it if they want to remain relevant.  And they shouldn't always have to say nice things about books like that, because books like that aren't always good.

It may be true that haters gonna hate, but it's also true that suckers gonna suck, and the people who benefit the most when the haters are silenced tend to be the people who suck, or the makers of sucky things.  If people hate you, they probably hate you for a reason, and if you don't hate anything, it's probably because you don't care very much. Positivity may garner better social-
networking amplification than negativity, and, therefore, more pageviews.  Saying nice things about products will never offend an advertiser.  But there are a lot of emperors with no clothes in the publishing business, and somebody has to stand up and warn people that Dan Brown is overly fond of airing his junk out.  If you will speak no ill of big books, then you can't effectively speak up for the underdogs.  A culture of positivity reinforces the status quo, and if a well-funded marketing message isn't loudly contradicted by an outlet with authority, it tends to be accepted.  

It's entirely possible for even a fairly voracious reader to exclusively read the biggest franchise authors, and this is exactly what many readers do.  James Patterson has created a network of co-authors that allows him to churn out as much branded content as the market can consume, and, as a result, a significant percentage of mystery/thriller readers read nothing but James Patterson. 

These readers feel they have no reason to look beyond what they're already reading; they might like another book, but they already know they like James Patterson is, so reading something else that they might not like involves a risk.  Before anyone can persuade those readers to explore the larger literary world that Buzzfeed is so positive about, somebody first has to convince them to stop reading ten James Patterson books a year.  Somebody has to persuade them that reading nothing but James Patterson is a bad decision.  The rave review's exhortation to "read this" contains, as a necessary corollary:  "not that."

Bad reviews should certainly be employed judiciously.  There's no reason to use the critical platform to do what Tom Lutz of the Los Angeles Review of Books described as wasting "scant time and resources killing a book that is in the process of dying a natural death."  But there's no point in forging a +2 enchanted sword if you're unwilling to use it, on occasion, to slay a dragon.

Thank you, Dan! And thank you, darlings, for indulging a senior citizen's first "blog post."

What do you think about negative book reviews, especially for debut authors? Are you a reviewer? Have you been reviewed? Will you be checking out the Los Angeles Review of Books's and Buzzfeed's new positive reviews? 

(With all due respect to Dan, Miss Edna must agree with the the Los Angeles Review of Books. And also Issac Fitzgerald, the new book reviews editor of Buzzfeed, who quoted Thumper from Bambi: "If you can't say nuthin', nice, then don't say nuthin' at all." I only tweet about books I love. No time for anything else, darlings. "Too blessed to be stressed" is my motto and I live by it. That's just me.)


Dan’s web site is here.
Follow Dan on Twitter here.
Friend him on Facebook here.

Daniel Friedman’s next novel, DON'T EVER LOOK BACK, will be released in 2014.


And you can follow Miss Edna, who often tweets about mysteries and thrillers here.



(Hatchet image from Randy Robertson via Flickr.)


(Dictated by Miss Edna and typed and entered by Miss Susan.)

Tuesday, December 10, 2013

Kim Fay, Author of THE MAP OF LOST MEMORIES on the "Vice" of Research, and a book giveaway!




SUSAN ELIA MACNEAL: Please join with me to welcome novelist Kim Fay officially to the Jungle Red Writers blog. (Kim's a regular in the comments section, so you may already know her!) Her Edgar Award-shortlisted first novel, THE MAP OF LOST MEMORIES just came out in paperback, and she's here to talk about her "vice" of research — one of my obsessions as well.

If you don't know Kim Fay and her work yet, you should. Kim's the author of the historical mystery novel The Map of Lost Memories, the Mystery Writers of America's 2013 Edgar Award finalist for Best First Novel by an American Author. She's also written the food memoir Communion: A Culinary Journey Through Vietnam, winner of the Gourmand World Cookbook Awards’ Best Asian Cuisine Book in the United States. She lived in Vietnam for four years, has traveled throughout the region for the past twenty, and now makes her home in Los Angeles.

Kim and I were fellow nominees for the 2013 Edgar Award for Best First Novel by an American Author — and when I read her nominated novel, THE MAP OF LOST MEMORIES —I absolutely fell in love with her writing. Booklist gave THE MAP OF LOST MEMORIES a starred review and said, "Fay’s extraordinary first novel has everything great historical adventure fiction should—strikingly original setting, exhilarating plot twists, and a near-impossible quest . . . Every word of this evocative literary expedition feels deliberately chosen, each phrase full of meaning."



Here's a description:

In 1925 the international treasure-hunting scene is a man’s world, and no one understands this better than Irene Blum, who is passed over for a coveted museum curatorship because she is a woman. Seeking to restore her reputation, she sets off in search of a temple believed to house the lost history of Cambodia’s ancient Khmer civilization. As Irene travels through Shanghai's lawless back streets and Saigon’s opium-filled lanes, she joins forces with a Communist temple robber and an intriguing nightclub owner with a complicated past. What they bring to light deep within the humidity-soaked Cambodian jungle will do more than change history—it will solve the mysteries of their own lives.


Today Kim Fay joins us to talk about her research process, 
and also to give away three copies of 
THE MAP OF LOST MEMORIES.


KIM FAY: When I tell people that it took me fourteen years to write my first published novel (I’m also the proud owner of many unpublished ones), it’s true and it’s not true. Yes, from the day I started it until the day my agent felt it was ready to send out, fourteen years passed … but not all of that time was spent writing. Some of it was spent editing travel guidebooks, working on a non-fiction book and indulging in one of my greatest vices: research.

I was that kid who turned her reports in early because I loved investigating the culture of Hawaii or the history of the Bicentennial so much that I’d gathered all the information I needed within a few days. I worshiped at the spines of my family’s set of encyclopedias—I could decide I wanted to know something and look it up, or I could simply open a volume at random and discover something entirely new. My grandpa did not buy me dolls. He bought me Time-Life series. The Old West with twenty-six volumes including my favorite, The Women. This Fabulous Century with a book for each decade, filled with archival photos, newspaper articles and cultural tidbits. 


I have heard some writers say that there’s such a thing as too much research, and when it comes to stuffing everything you’ve learned about a subject into a novel, I agree. As for too much researching? Impossible! It’s a joy, it’s gratifying, and I feel that it makes my work so much stronger.
Take, for example, my first novel, The Map of Lost Memories, set in 1920’s China and Indochina. Although I lived in the region for years, I obviously needed to do a lot of research to understand that part of the world during that time period. My main character loses her job at a museum and sets off for Cambodia to find a lost treasure; to understand her and the world she operated in, I read eight different books on the history of art collecting and looting. Was I going to use all the information I learned in these books? Not even close. But the wealth of knowledge I gained bolstered my confidence and gave me a firm understanding the context for the story I was choosing to tell.

I am working on a few new books now, one being the first volume of a mystery series set in Los Angeles in the 1970s. The idea was sparked by my meeting with a woman who was one of the founders of the L.A. Times food paper. It’s not well-known that in its heyday the weekend food paper was a 50-plus-page magazine and its staff operated one of the largest test kitchens in the country. My desire to know more about this world (by conducting interviews, digging through old food papers and testing old recipes) began to shape a character named Barb, a housewife and food writer whose life changes dramatically when a young P.I. moves in next door.

I decided that Barb was addicted to mystery novels as a young woman in the late 1950s. The next thing I knew, I was on AbeBooks at midnight ordering the first ten Edgar award winners for best novel so that I could understand my character through her reading habits. Turns out I also want to learn about the rise of the Los Angeles Conservancy, which was born with the efforts to save our downtown library. So guess what? Barb’s husband is an architectural conservationist whose career trajectory follows the failures and successes of twentieth-century conservation efforts in L.A. As for 1970s L.A., it has always fascinated me, which is why I find myself at the downtown library prowling through local magazine archives and reading the 1971 Los Angeles phone book as if it was the latest New York Times bestselling page-turner.


One lesson I’ve learned (sometimes the hard way) is to never fall so much in love with a piece of research that you bend your story out of shape just to fit it in. No matter how much I’ve read or know about a subject or issue, it’s important that I let my research be an organic part of the actual writing process. The second it stands in the way of the story’s flow, it must go.

So, how about you? Do you like researching? Do you have a favorite topic? Have you ever OD’d on research? Has too much research ever gotten in the way for you as a writer? As a reader?


All readers who comment on this post with be entered into a random drawing to win one of three copies of The Map of Lost Memories, compliments of Kim's publisher, Ballantine Books/Random House.

Find out more about Kim Fay and her books at her website.
Friend her on Facebook here.
And follow her on Twitter here.

Monday, December 9, 2013

Making a (Book) List and Checking it Twice — Books We're Giving this Holiday Season

SUSAN ELIA MACNEAL: One of my favorite books from childhood is Louisa May Alcott's Little Women. It isn't a Christmas book per se, but the first sentence is " 'Christmas won't be Christmas without any presents,' grumbled Jo.'

And I agree with Jo March. Giving people presents —preferably books — as gifts is one of my favorite parts of the holiday season. And, even though my life is somewhat head over feet with family and work these days, I'm actually on top of shopping this year! 

Here are some of the books I'm giving this year:

The Hubby — Nutcracker by E.T.A. Hoffmann, Maurice Sendak and Ralph Manheim. Not only are we both huge Sendak fans (both books and artwork), Noel MacNeal's newest show: Mouse King: The Untold Story of the Nutcracker is making its debut this holiday season in Miami. The book will make a great remembrance of this very Nutcracker-y and Mouse-y year.

The Kiddo — The current obsession is Adam Gidwiz's A Tale Dark And Grimm, and the last book in the trilogy, The Grimm Conclusion, will definitely be under the tree. It?s a fantastic series and one we've enjoyed reading together as a family. It's funny and irreverent, even while staying close to the original Grimm brothers' fairy tales. Not for the faint-of-heart, but perfect for kids who want a little humor and gore with their adventures.

The Mother-in-law — Miss Edna, aka Grandmama, reads mysteries and thrillers from the library voraciously on her e-reader, so I?m not going to get her books. But I think the perfect gift for a crime aficionado is Mystery Scene Magazine. 

Established in 1985, Mystery Scene Magazine is the oldest, largest, and most authoritative guide to the crime fiction genre. Our lively, expert coverage ranges from past mystery masters to today's top talents and tomorrow's bright new stars. We report on novels, of course, but also films, TV shows, audio-books, kid's mysteries, short stories, reference works, and much more.

Can't wait to see what great reads it inspires throughout the year!


LUCY BURDETTE: Books are my favorite thing to give and get. I'm not going to give the particulars for fear SOMEONE might be reading, but here are a few I'm giving: Sujata Massey's THE SLEEPING DICTIONARY, Kristan Higgins, THE RIGHT MATCH, AN ASTRONAUT'S GUIDE TO LIFE ON EARTH, ORANGE IS THE NEW BLACK. There are others that I can't remember... and I'm hoping for the new Wally Lamb and Donna Tartt--oh the list could go on and on! Luckily my birthday comes in January so I can make another list:)








HANK PHILLIPPI RYAN: This is SO HARD. First, you're assuming I'm organized enough to have figured this out by now, which is--wrong.  I did get a signed Ken Follett for my step-son Paul. (He and Jonathan love to read spy books, who doesn't? So now they each have their own copy.)  For my Dad. I think I'll get that book on Beethoven's Ninth--even though my Dad probable knows just as much about it!  I'm drawn to the new Doris Kearns Goodwin book about Teddy Roosevelt..maybe for Jonathan? (Yeah, exactly, then I'll sneak it.) (In my spare time.) And I'm trying to decide just how pushy it is to send THE WRONG GIRL to far-flung relatives.  And I'm tempt to get that One Hundred Things That Changed the World book--is that cool? Or holiday hype?


HALLIE EPHRON: Books are a big part of every season at our house -- in fact, our collection of books is rapidly pushing us OUT of the house. My husband is the book buyer. He came back last weekend with the most gorgeous coffee table book of Steve McCurry's photographs of South and Southeast Asia. Spectacular color pictures fill each page. It's hard to get mad at him when he brings back a book like that. For him, best buys are beautiful illustrated children's books or anything about Brooklyn. And for my son-in-law, anything Star Wars or Hobbity-y. For my daughters, chewy women's fiction. Then I get to borrow them back.


RHYS BOWEN: I am a great re-reader of old favorites--all the Agatha Christies, The Lord of the Rings, Kate Morton... any book that gave me pleasure the first time around I will re-read when life gets stressful. I love giving and receiving books but I have to be quite specific if I ask John to put a book under the tree for me. Or I'll find the military history of WW II or something that HE'd like on the shelf.  Last year as a stocking stuffer I started my son-in-law Tom on Daniel Silva and he's read everything Silva has written, so this year I want to find a new writer to hook him on. Any suggestions?



JULIA SPENCER-FLEMING: Rhys, he might like Robert Ludlum/Eric Van Lustbader. Classic spy novels brought up to date for the post-Cold War world. Or, for a different twist, how about Barry Eisler's John Rain series? Lots of action, moral ambiguity and exotic locations.

As for what I'm giving - well, Ross and the Smithie read this site, so I can't give anything away for this year. In years past, I've often given Ross a matched series - for his birthday, I
found an almost complete set of Winston Churchill's History of WWII in the original 1951 Book-of-the-Month club edition (yes, collectors, I know it doesn't count for collecting purposes.) For the Smithie, I tend to get a stack of paperbacks for fun reads or that One Special Book she wanted, signed. One year I got her the latest Sookie Stackhouse mystery signed by Charlaine Harris.
For The Boy, who rows for Trinity College (Hartford), a signed copy of FLAT WATER TUESDAY by Ron Irwin, who once rowed for Trinity College. Not a vanity project - the book was blurbed by Nobel Prize-winner J.M. Coetzee. For my sister's little boys, some fun science books from National Geographic (20% off when you buy three or more!) Finally, for my newest nephew, who joined the family by adoption after a long, long wait by his parents, THE SEA CHEST by Maine author Toni Buzzeo, illustrated by Mary GrandPre. It's a beautiful tale of a baby who arrives at a lonely lighthouse station floating in a sea chest and who becomes one of the family.


DEBORAH CROMBIE: Julia, I highly recommend Blood Over Water by James Livingston and David Livingston, for The Boy.  The brothers rowed in the Boat Race the same year, one for Oxford and one for Cambridge. Fascinating story.  I later found out that my English agent's husband rowed for Oxford the same year.

And, oh, Susan, I have the Sendak Nutcracker! It's one of my treasures (a bit battered, but well-loved.) That's a nice reminder that it would make a lovely gift. 

Last year (not for Christmas) a friend gave me the 75th Anniversary edition of The Hobbit--Rhys, if you don't own it, put it on your Christmas list.  It's gorgeous, and has the original Tolkien drawings. 

I love to give books--last year everyone who reads got The Twelve Clues of Christmas! This year I haven't made up my mind what I'm giving, but I think the new C.C. Bennison Father Tom Christmas book may go on my want list…


Are books a big part of your holiday season? Which ones do you like to reread? Give as gifts? Buy for yourself?