I’ve just returned from a trip to England, mainly to let John be with his many relatives. It was a lovely time, full of big family dinners, delicious lunches, cream teas and an endless stream of people coming and going. I enjoy being there, I love Cornwall and John’s family, but it is not home. Cornwall was somewhere we took vacations when I was very young. As sort of magical place that was different.
We also spent some time in London. London again is a place I know well. I spent a big chunk of time there, both at university and then living on Queen Anne Street behind Oxford Circus, working for the BBC at Broadcasting House (I could get up at eight thirty and be on the set by nine!). But again London is not home.
Which made me consider what exactly home is. I have lived in California for over fifty years. I have raised a family here, but is it home? I do find myself longing for the simple life in England, going to the village shop or the pub and meeting the neighbors. California is always fast paced, lots of traffic, new buildings.
So it was interesting for me to spend a few days in Bath, the city of my birth. I didn’t live there after the war when my parents moved to Kent where my father ran a factory, but I was a frequent visitor. My aunt Gwladys lived there, my godmother,--I could almost say my fairy godmother because that’s what she felt like to me. A single woman who had had a high powered job in the Admiralty during the war only to be kicked back to a secretarial position when the men came back. She quit and started teaching business instead. Long summer vacations gave her plenty of opportunity to travel and she traveled constantly. Everywhere she went she brought me back a doll. .I have them all in a cabinet and can name where they all came from.
From a very early age my parents would put me on a bus in London and Aunt Gwlad would meet me in Bath. There we would do exciting and different things: we’d go to a Persian restaurant and sit on cushions to eat. We went to plays and the opera. We visited her many and diverse friends like the old lady who lived alone in the mansion above the city, and we’d often have morning coffee with her friends in the Pump Room where an ancient orchestra played.
I left John in the hotel and wandered around Bath on my own. That was the road to my grandmother’s house, a lovely Georgian with molded ceiling. That’s the Francis Hotel where we once had an elegant lunch with my aunt’s haughty friend. And Pultney Bridge had a wool shop where I once was bought yarn and skirt material. It all came back to me. Look John,Jollys. They used to have lovely cream cakes (it was now shuttered). I remembered swimming in the Roman Baths before they discovered the bacteria content was not safe! This time I indulged in the safer but more expensive new Thermae Spa with its rooftop warm pool. Such a treat.
I think a place knows when you were born there. I could feel it whispering ‘welcome home’ to me, and then, more disturbingly, ‘you don’t want to leave again, do you? You could come back here. Live a simple life here. Sit in the Parade Gardens and watch the river fall down the weir.’ So tempting. But we packed our bags and caught the train to London. Now home will have to wait until next year.
So Reddies, do you have a place that is definitely home for you? Or are you still looking and hoping to find it?
Jean and I were born in New Jersey, so it really feels like home here . . . but John and I have lived in several different places, and with John and the children there, they pretty much felt like home, too. I think home is more about the people with you than the place where you happen to be . . . .
ReplyDeleteI agree
DeleteRhys, I understand how that feels, but my first "hometown" is spoiled for me with memories of school bullying and friendship betrayals. My second hometown, I arrived here just before my 14th birthday, is full of happier memories, long friendships and love. Is isn't as though there isn't pain associated with the place I really do call my hometown, but not the deliberate, purposeful pain of my elementary school years. Irwin and I moved to my hometown when our son was two and we have lived in our home here for over forty years.
ReplyDeleteI think home towns need happy memories
DeleteFor me there is something special about Prince Edward Island, and I have never lived there. It always was that way, but I know not why. My mother came from the island, and we would go to visit my grandmother, and the relatives twice a year, but other than knowing that they are relatives, have never really bonded with any of them. Homemade ice cream when we visit, with fresh strawberries and stilted conversation – okay, but just for a while.
ReplyDeleteHowever, there is something about the feel that comes to me as soon as the car departs the ferry, and the red soil comes into view that just descends, envelopes me and peace is there. The slowly descending houses as they meld into the soil, the lure of vegetables left to honesty for sale at the end of the laneway, and the view of potatoes far into the horizon is somehow home. Not to mention the mud, and sand and of course the smell of pig manure – ambrosia!
That ancestral knowledge!
DeleteRhys, Bath is one of my favourite places in England, it is an enchanting place and I felt extremely good in this place.
ReplyDeleteI call home where I’ve presently lived for forty-five years. It’s also home for my daughter who likes to come back and take a bit of calm and fresh air.
Once in a while ( a couple of years) I go through the streets where I’ve been brought up but it changed so much, it is almost impossible to recreate my memories there.
DANiELLE: it was the opposite for me. When I went back to my childhood neighbourhood in Oct 2021, I was shocked that nothing had chsnged. The same suburban homes, my elementary, junior high and high school were frozen in time, unchanged from when I left home in 1985!
DeleteWhat lovely memories, Rhys, and how lucky you were to have Aunt Gwladys. I visited Bath once with my sons when they were wee boys.
ReplyDeleteI've lived in Boston and points north for 44 years, and it feels like home. But I'm a fourth-gen Californian who grew up near Pasadena in the shadow of the 6000-foot San Gabriel mountains (never mind that smog obscured our view of them half the year). I still love mountains on the horizon.
When I fly west and cross the Rockies, I feel like I can breathe better. When I drive through golden rolling hills, sit on my uncle's Mexican-tiled patio overlooking the Alexander Valley north of SF, or dip my toes in the Pacific and watch the sun SET over the ocean instead of rise, I know I'm really home.
No smog these days, Edith, but more threat of wild fires I also love the feeling of expanse in California
DeleteI can relate to your feelings about California, Edith and I have mostly been a visitor there. I get a special feeling flying over the Rockies, and when I step out of the airport, there is a sense that comes over me that I never feel anywhere else. I was just 17 the first time I visited California with my mother and father. We stayed with my aunt in Beverly Hills and did all the touristy things possible in a week's visit. My mother died the following Christmas and my aunt invited me back every year after school ended. Good memories.
DeleteI think only Portland is home to me, since I basically never moved away. I've loved and felt special connections with other places I have visited, but not that sense of home.
ReplyDeleteI love your stories of your young adventures with your Aunt Gwladys. We all need adults other than our parents to show us new things and adventure with us.
Gillian I have mentioned before but, even though I was dbt live in Portland, Or it is one of my favorite cities. There is truly something magical and special about it. Nt just the environment but the people too.
DeleteRHYS: I love visiting Bath, your birthplace. And I enjoyed visiting York & walled cities such as Chester &
ReplyDeleteI was born & raised in TORONTO. I lived there on & off for 35 years.
DeleteI now have a love-hate relationship with T.O.
I love the eclectic neighbourhoods & diverse food.
I have kept my cell phone # with a rare 416 area code. That will always ID me as a Torontonian.
But I hate commuting across my sprawling hometown. Never ending construction & unreliable public transit are the worst. The promised Eglinton mid town LRT (in my old 'hood) was being built when I left in 2014 & still not opened!
Doing a mind numbing 2.5 hour daily commute for 13 years finally broke me and I gladly moved back to Ottawa (for the 3rd time) in 2014. I have not been back to Toronto since October 2021 when I spent 3 days packing up my late dad 's retirement apt & dealing with banks & lawyers during the pandemic.
Connecting flights at YYZ is a dreaded chore but I reluctantly go there since it is a major travel hub.
Toronto definitely feels like a huge city!
DeleteToronto gridlock & traffic is worse than L.A.!!
DeleteGrace, I take that as a warning.
DeleteA warning to NOT visit Toronto?! The much-delayed Eglington LRT I mentioned above now has a Sept 2025 opening date. With a new transit line covering 9 km/25 new stations becoming available across midtown Toronto, maybe fewer people would be forced to drive?
DeleteI am an eternal optimist that T.O.'s public transit would improve some day. Traffic delays and transit breakdown are a constant part of life right now.
Such an intriguing question, Rhys. I'll answer simply by saying that home is more a feeling than a place for me. With both my parents now gone, I am realizing that 'home' is that feeling for which I am now solely responsible. A bit daunting...
ReplyDeleteAMANDA: I do get that. With no living relatives left in Canada, I am on my own, too.
DeleteI do know that feeling but I can now look to grandchildren as the future
DeleteAmanda, such a good point. I have such fond memories growing up in a small beach community across the bay from a large metro area in the 1950-1960's. It was like a Mayberry surfing community! But now when I go back there (it is just a 30 min car drive away) I don't feel the same way about it. It's still nice but no longer a place I could live. But having the memories is better!
DeleteNice to know I'm not alone in this feeling. Thanks!
DeleteRhys, when I think of Bath I think of the romantic comedies of Georgette Heyer. So nice to read more modern take, both with your magical Aunt Gwlad and on your own today.
ReplyDeleteMy hometown in coastal CT became far too rich for any of my four sibs or me to afford when she died. Though when I moved to the Adirondacks in 1983 its dark forests of balsam and spruce and mountains on every horizon were foreign and vaguely frightening to me, now they cause me to exhale in relief. And on my rare visits to coastal Connecticut, all the deciduous trees and undergrowth now strike me as a jungle! My hometown has been mostly knocked down and rebuilt. It's almost unrecognizable. The decent 1950s colonial my parents had built is still there, but with various additions it now looks as if it's painfully bulked up on steroids. Lake Placid is home and I worry about the day when a need to be closer to decent medical care -- we currently drive 1-2 hours -- will force us to move. (Selden)
oops, when "my mother" died.
DeleteThat’s the thing about English home towns. They don’t change ! Even the shops are the same after years.
DeleteGood point Rhys. That is so true. You can drive thru the quaint Cotswolds towns and feel like you are transported back into time. Even parts of London you can feel you might be in a Shakespearean pub, or walking across a medieval bridge, or wharf area where a Dickens character might be.
DeleteSeveral years ago I sold my house and moved to a different part of the country. It didn't take me long to realize where I truly belonged. Not only did that new house not have a dog - so that felt very strange - but it was far away from most of the people I needed to be near. Home was where my grandchilden were and that has not changed for me, even though they are almost grown up now.
ReplyDeleteI also need to be near family and love it that my grandchildren drop in to see us.
DeleteI'm fourth generation on our property, so where I am is definitely home. I admit, it doesn't feel quite as much that way anymore. My cousins once lived next door and my parents in the house I grew up in, one door over from them. Three houses in a row, all family. Now, those other two houses are owned by people who are relatively new to the area and don't share or even know the history. Still, my roots are so deep, I can't imagine living anywhere else.
ReplyDeleteHow lovely to live next door to family. My dream house!
DeleteI was born in Erie, PA but I moved when I was a child and have no memories of living there. So that's not home.
ReplyDeleteI go back to visit my sister, who lives less than a mile from the house I spent most of my pre-marital time in - 1979 to 1996. But although it and the village are familiar, they are no longer home.
For a long time, "home" was our house in Pittsburgh. My son is still there, but I definitely feel at home here at The Cottage, tucked up against my hillside, mountains all around me. I think I take "home" with me wherever I live.
I love looking at mountains. I hated it when we lived somewhere flat.
DeleteI love the mountains too but having grown up in a beautiful seacoast town and in a state largely influenced by Spanish culture I can spend my vacations in the mountains but the ocean and good Mexican food -- are great !
DeleteIt's true, home is where the heart is, no matter where you were born or grew up. Your heart is clearly in England, Rhys.
ReplyDeleteI don't identify much with my hometown, for a lot of the same reasons Judy feels about her birthplace. Too much pain, sadness, and hard times to yearn for. There were some happy times, and I loved being with my maternal grandparents, but they've been gone for a long, long time. My oldest daughter and her husband, born in the SW corner of Ohio, have both spent most of their adult lives getting closer and closer to where they are now, their own spiritual home of Northern Michigan. She is the most content she's ever been there.
Now I tell people I'm a born-again Cincinnatian, since I've lived here since 1970. There's been some pain here, too, but balanced by a lot more joy and happiness, and I've made it my Home home, in particular the neighborhood and community where we have lived for the last 43 years. I've thought hard about what I/we would do if we needed to be closer to our daughters, for health reasons, maybe, and always concluded I would rather stay here, or at least keep my homebase where it is.
That's a decision I don't want to make ever, but who knows? I'm glad you're happy where you are.
DeleteI grew up in Beverly Hills which is SO TRANSFORMED now from what it once was, you could drop me in the middle of it and I wouldn't know I was in the town where I once lived. Well, maybe if I landed on one of the residential streets, but even there, relatively modest homes have been replaced by mega-mansions.
ReplyDeleteThese days HOME is right here in the house we bought back in 1978 or thereabouts and moved into with our toddler. Every time I look around I see something that needs to be repaired... and I feel so lucky.
Those yearnings sometimes never leave us, do they? This post reminded me of my grandfather's burial in Eastern Kentucky. My mom by that time had lived in northern Ohio nearly 40 years. Her family was mostly there in Ohio--all of her children, many of her siblings. Yet, she stood by herself at the cemetery, arms clasped about her, and looked away over the hills and ridges falling away into the distance. Whenever we went to visit our grandparents, it was always 'going home.' There was a deep, deep connection to that place, even though she wouldn't move back.
ReplyDeleteI am content in my place, although I've lived elsewhere and called those places home as well.
Flora as Anon above.
DeleteInterestingly, when I lived in Australia people there spoke of going home to England, even though their family had been in Australia for generations.
DeleteI spent a lot of my childhood in the small town of Cambridge, Ohio, but it has changed so much since then that when I visit I am hard-pressed to find familiar landmarks. I finished growing up on the west side of Columbus, and again, the neighborhood is almost unrecognizable to me now. Hubby and I lived in two different small Ohio cities (Newark and Mansfield) before moving to Worthington, a north Columbus suburb, 30 years ago.
ReplyDeleteBut here's the interesting thing (to me, at least): when it came time for us to retire, we talked about relocating somewhere for better weather, but ultimately decided the most important thing for us as we age would be our social network. People matter more than weather. And although we had lived all those years in Worthington, our social network was centered in Powell, where we had gone to church for that whole 30 years. So in many ways, we decided to move "home" to Powell, where we had never actually lived, but spent much of our time for a lot of years.
Worthington has also changed a lot, hasn't it, Susan? But it's a lovely place.
DeleteSusan, my last home in the area was in Mt. Air--I loved my home, but the drive to build ever more housing developments in southern Delaware County made traffic a nightmare, especially as I lived on Olentangy River Road. Powell is a lovely area.
DeleteI so agree. People do matter more. You can have nice vacations but ultimately want to be surrounded by people who care about you.
DeleteHome is truly where the heart is. My heart used to belong to Brooklyn, NY but NYC has changed not for the better, in my opinion, so my heart is moving to where my family currently reside. Looks like I retired at the right time.
ReplyDeleteI'm glad it worked out for you, Dru
DeleteYes, most definitely, but it is lost to time and progress. I first set foot in Miami, Florida at the age of 4 - in fact, I turned 5 there. I fell in love. So much so, that I used to tell people Miami was my home town. I thought it meant a place you loved. Now it's a series of high rises and traffic. Not the same at all.
ReplyDeleteIt really has changed! I'm not a big city person.
DeleteI think of the Connecticut coastal city where I live now as Home. I’ve been here since the late eighties. I know more people here than I did in the city where I was born and raised. Because I’m single and have no children, and my surviving siblings (we’ve lost two in the past eight years) live elsewhere, people sometimes ask if I’ve ever thought of moving closer to one of my sisters. While I love visiting with them, I don’t want to leave here. I do miss my family, but this is my home.
ReplyDeleteDebRo
That's a big debate, isn't it? To move near family but away from a place you like...I'm not sure I'd know the answer
DeleteI would say my home is Nebraska/Missouri/Iowa/Minnesota and the place where I live is Florida. Hopefully, Florida will eventually join the others in feeling like home. Somehow in my heart home must be where my parents are as I have been feeling more connected to their hometown where they are buried than ever before.
ReplyDeleteI hope it does feel like home, Brenda
DeleteI grew up in Indiana, lived there since I was, what, six? But it has changed so incredibly much between them and now, I honestly don’t even recognize it. Hilariously, maybe 15 years ago? I went home for a visit, and when I got off the airplane I was absolutely flummoxed. I thought wow, this is not the Indianapolis airport! how did I wind up in the wrong city? Turns out, the Indianapolis airport had been completely moved to a different place, totally different airport! But I had no idea.
ReplyDeleteHank, I have found that you really can’t go back. The place changes from what you remember and you have also changed.
DeleteBath is a beautiful place. I remember taking a bus trip with friends from Germany from Oxford to Bath. We walked around the city of Bath. My Mom and I visited Bath on my first trip to the UK several years before. Home is where happy memories are.
ReplyDeleteCalifornia is my birthplace, though my heart is in Scotland.
That's an interesting question, Rhys. We moved around a bit when I was a child, then a teenager. We moved around even more when I married. Who said you can never go home again? It is so true. People move on without you, the city keeps changing.
ReplyDeleteI have lived in San Diego for all of my adult life, but when I get back to my birthplace in the San Francisco Bay Area (the Peninsula, specifically), I feel like I am home. However, when I have been away from San Diego on a trip and return to my house, I feel happy to be back home. — Pat S
ReplyDeletePAT s. I live and grew up in San Diego too in Coronado. I now live in La Jolla which is also beautiful. But I have to say the San Francisco Bayarea is an absolutely beautiful city and a great place to live.
DeleteA question to ponder, Rhys. Unlike you, I haven’t experienced a place saying to me come back, this is home. It seems that wherever I am living feels like home, but visiting former homes does not make me want to be back there. And after living in Seattle/Tacoma for 20 years, a photo of Mt Rainer always clutches my heart. But photos of other places lived for equally long…meh. Home is now the Atlantic Coast of FL, a place I never imagined wanting to live or living. And, now, can’t imagine leaving. Elisabeth
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing such wonderful memories with us Rhys!!
ReplyDeleteI feel a special connection to the land when I am in Oahu And Kauai. The lush forests, beautiful sandy beaches, warm ocean waters, mild breezes etc.
My husband (I did not) went to college in Princeton NJ but only for college. However I have this strange and strong attachment to the town and the university which I can't explain.
I loved this essay, Rhys, and your memories of Bath, a beautiful city that I've visited several times.
ReplyDeleteI have a deep connection to my part of north Texas. I live twenty miles from the suburb where I grew up, and forty-ish from the town where I went to college. I love our old house, our historic downtown, our community, so I'm very rooted where I'm planted.
But.
The first time I stepped off the plane at Heathrow I had the most bizarre sense of homecoming and that has never left me. London is the city of my heart, and weirdly, even though I've lived in Edinburgh and Chester, I didn't feel at home in those places in the way I do in London. Past lives, maybe?
P.S. Rhys, your wonderful dolls! My parents traveled a lot, too, and brought me a doll from every country they visited. They all lived on the shelves in my childhood bedroom. Alas, they disappeared in one move or another, so I envy you yours.
ReplyDeleteGrowing up in a small town where "everybody knows my name" was as close to picture-perfect as it gets. Maysville, Kentucky sits by the Ohio River, and had a population of around seven or eight thousand when I was growing up. When very young, I had a whole street of playmates, and we usually spent the day outside making up adventures and riding our bikes. As I got older, into elementary school, my world of friends expanded to the next two streets over. We walked or rode our bicycles to friends' houses, and I kept these friends through high school. Of course, there were friends who didn't live right by me, too, as I got into junior high and high school. But, my father having a real estate business, there were few people we hadn't have at least heard of. My father's office was downtown, so I could explore downtown and always have a ride home (my mother didn't drive). There was one theater in town with the inside walls covered with magical scenes and stars. My mother was a housewife who had previously taught for 20 years (she was 43 when she had me). She taught kindergarten in our finished basement the year I went, where I met many friends I still have. My elementary school was close enough to walk to, but junior high and senior high required vehicle assistance via carpooling. I had quite a few memorable teachers, who showered us with love as well as learning. We actually had plenty of snow during my time there, and we had lots of sunny days in the summer. The falls were especially pretty there because the town sits in a valley, not tall mountains around us, but hills. I really missed those hills when I married and moved to the western part of the state. It's interesting that I've lived where I live now for 48 years, but the place I grew up and lived for 22 years has always been home.
ReplyDelete