Wednesday, December 27, 2023

The Art of Gift Receiving

 

https://ctnewsjunkie.com/category/opinion/cartoons/


Jenn McKinlay: Well, we've survived yet another holiday season. Phew! And now it's time to reflect upon the insanity of the gift giving season.

There is no evidence, at least none that I’ve found, to support my theory that people spike the eggnog during the holidays to get through the arduous process of gift giving and receiving, but I’m pretty sure that’s why they do it. Okay, why I do it. Unless you’re a miserable curmudgeon who refuses to buy anyone any gift ever -- and here I pause to raise my nog to you -- odds are you’re going to have to confront the reality of living in consumer nation and pony up some gifts.

Children make it so easy. I like shopping for kids. You get an itemized list of what they want and if you have a real overachiever on your hands, they’ve already price checked the retailers and will give you a detailed map of the layout of the best store with arrows walking you right to the coveted item or even better a link to the online store. Teens are nice, too. You have to love their clear cut need and desire for cash. Nothing says “I love you” to them more clearly than the notification of a Venmo deposit to their account.


It’s adults who make the whole gifting venture dicey, and unless you’re lucky enough to have only people who collect troll dolls or beer cans on your list, you have now entered the dance of “Do you think they would like this or that or these?”, which is as painful and repetitive as an eighties dance party where they keep playing the Electric Slide.

Gift giving is great if you happen to be the sort of person who enjoys finding the perfect gift for everyone on your list and then revel in  wrapping it in festive paper, decorating it with a snazzy cloth ribbon that you tie yourself and finish the whole thing off with the gift tag you hand stamped. You know who you are, and I can’t even be mad at you for setting the bar too high for me to reach, because, yeah, you just gave me the perfect gift.


The rest of us poor saps struggle through the gifting ritual, and it’s not because we don’t care. We’re just truly flummoxed when we walk into a store and get a Three Stooges double-eye poke at all the sparkly gee-gaws in front of us. Honestly, if you’re not a shopper (and I'm not - unless we're talking bougie thrift, but that's another post), it’s a bit like being a diabetic in a candy store.

So, why is gift giving such an anxiety maker? I figured it out many years ago when I eavesdropped on a father talking to his five children in the Providence airport while traveling for Thanksgiving. Don’t judge me; it’s an occupational hazard…really. 

The dad said, “Last year we gave you everything you wanted and it was the worst Christmas ever. This year you get four things; something you want, something you need, something to wear and something to read.” I wanted to go over and hug him for his genius, but I felt that might be awkward. Instead, I decided to implement his plan with my own hooligans.

It goes without saying that much debate ensued, as in “Isn’t something to wear and something you need the same thing?” For the record, no, it is not. That particular year, it turned out the much needed item was a duvet to cover up the rather well-loved Batman comforter that was too dear to be parted with but also too embarrassing to have on the bed anymore.

When one of my hooligans opened this “something you need” gift, I fully expected a bored look or a groan of disappointment. Instead, the boy went wide-eyed and said, “Oh, wow, I really needed this. Thank you so much!” He beamed at me, and I felt it all the way down to my toes. In that moment, I understood the responsibility of the gift receiver. It is that person who makes or breaks the entire gift giving deal.

Maybe you’re like me and gift giving makes you reach for the nog. That’s okay. You can excel in the art of gift receiving. Yes, this means you have to dig deep and be expressively pleased by all the gifts you receive even the ones where you’re not quite certain of what exactly it is. Yes, that has happened. Also, when you're gift bombed by an over-gifter. That, too, is a thing but also a post for another day because...oof!




And, sadly yes, you must express appreciation even for those passive-aggressive goodies, like gym memberships and self-help books for issues you don’t have. *SIGH* On the bright side, if the gift is well received, you can then re-gift their oh-so-thoughtful presents (because you loved it so much!) right back at them – on their birthday. Ha!

So, how about it Reds and Readers, are you a good gift giver, receiver, or are you just over the whole thing?



109 comments:

  1. Since I've avoided being on the receiving end of gym memberships and self-help books, I guess I'm okay on the receiving end of gifts-giving.
    The something to wear/read part of gift-giving is my favorite part because I love the book-shopping . . . as for the want/need part, either I've managed pretty well or I’ve been fooled by everyone managing to convince me that I got it right. At least I’m certain that I always get the homemade cookies part right :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am a predictable gift-giver. I give homemade baked goods (sweet or savoury) or meal entree, specific to the receiver's preferences/diet limitations.

    And I am also an easy gift-receiver. A book-related gift is gratefully accepted and appreciated. Bookstore gift card, pretty bookmarks, a real physical book (although it's hard for most to know which books I already own).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You sound like a wonderful gift giver, Grace.

      Delete
    2. GRACE: Love receiving pretty bookmarks too, especially handmade or from a local bookshop.

      Diana

      Delete
    3. You're an excellent friend to have, Grace.

      Delete
  3. We only exchange with a close circle of friends, and we pretty much know what each other would like: books, wine, cheese, CDs, coasters, picture frames, that sort of thing. In California we use used to exchange more, but after the move we've more or less agreed "those were the days," but no transatlantic gifts, please, because customs is a pain both directions. So it's e-cards, now, and What'sApp calls and Skype. All very satisfying.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There is a perk to being a grown-up. We have scaled back with all our middle-aged friends as well.

      Delete
  4. I am a good receiver, except I groan inside when the present is some FASCINATING non-fiction book that I know I will never read. This year my older son and his wife sent a digital picture frame, and now it is looping photos of Ida Rose. Best gift ever.

    I love that four-part gift giving mantra, Jenn - thanks for the backstory. I almost always give children books (although 2 1/2 year old Luca is getting a small train set this year). This year several people got new aprons and potholders imprinted with my friend's gorgeous vegetable art photographs (check it out here: https://www.etsy.com/shop/TomatoesAndThyme).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Your friend's designs are BEAUTIFUL, Edith. Lucky friends! Useful gifts are the best.

      Delete
    2. Edith, this is interesting. I was looking for black tomato seeds, which were on Etsy, and said they were from Spain, so I tried to forget it. Now I have to look up and see if I can order from them. You may have made my day! Thank you.

      Delete
    3. Thank you for sharing Satin's designs, Edith! I will definitely be buying some gifts from her, especially for my friend Pam who started a one-acre market garden at her home down the street two years ago. I think she would love the notecards, in particular.

      Delete
    4. Edith, perhaps you know someone who would love that FASCINATING non fiction book that you would never read?

      Diana

      Delete
    5. Love these, Edith, especially the potholders!

      Delete
    6. Thank you, Edith, that took care of 2 post-Christmas birthdays!

      Delete
    7. Children are the best to give gifts, too. Off to etsy to go look!

      Delete
  5. After a number of years of sad gift misfires between us, my husband and I began the custom of assembling a wish list over each year. Amazon later made it easy. We have very different niche interests, in which each of us is near expert; it would be hard for any non-expert to buy for either of us and hit on something 1) we long to own and 2) we do not already have. Thus we don't buy random things for ourselves during the year but save them for the wish list. After Thanksgiving we share these lists with each other. We don't expect to get everything on our list, but we do expect to get a few things from it, and working from the list the giver knows that he or she will make the other happy. We are free to be spontaneous, too, but we improvise with low-cost items, known in our family as "sidecars." (I got a paperback novel set in Chamonix as a sidecar this year, because we are going to Chamonix next fall for our 40th anniversary.)

    Our children have grown up with this system and now create their own Christmas and birthday lists. They consider it normal. My daughter was just telling me on Christmas day how she had been mystified by a friend who said she was going out shopping for the day for her mother and hoped she would see something and be "inspired." She had explained our family's system to the friend, who was equally mystified. I think every couple or family must come to a system that works for it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I should have added, most of the gifts exchanged in our family are books. My husband's specialty is 19th and early 20th century mountaineering and mine is 18th century American history. Our son is interested in early Christianity and veganism and our daughter in climate policy and action. Niche readers, all!

      Delete
    2. Brilliant! Hub and I are very much the same - we share exact item info or my fave is we give the gift of an outing. In our case, it's a Phish concert in the Sphere next year in Las Vegas!

      Delete
  6. My husband and I are so over it. We're at that age where, if we need it, we go out and buy it. Also, we're both so picky, the other one will never manage to get the correct item. So we either find our own gift online and share the buy link, then act surprised when we unwrap it. Or we just buy it and tell the other, "this is my Christmas gift." Of course, when that's the case, we always secretly buy some other small gift to be unwrapped Christmas morning. This year, Hubby's self-bought gift was a propane heater for his workshop, but I secretly bought him a pair of much-needed house moccasins. I bought several small things I've wanted but put off purchasing until now. He added a beautiful Pandora charm for my bracelet.

    Speaking of, he loves that I have a Pandora bracelet. It makes coming up with a gift extremely easy for him.

    The only other gift-buying I do is for my 2 1/2 year-old great grand twins. I get a stack of picture books, wrap them all, stick them in a gift bag with both names on it. Then let them fight over who gets which.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Jenn, we must be separated at birth! I hate Christmas shopping for adults. On the in-law side it is mandatory, unfortunately. I think a lot of it is my mother-in-law is one of those people who truly loves the shopping and wrappinng and gifting. She's actually a pretty good gift giver, but I would give up my thoughtful gifts in a heartbeat if it meant I could skip the stress of shopping. Not to mention the fact we have a teeny tiny house and we are drowning in stuff. I'm always trying to declutter and throw things out and then on Christmas it all comes marching in. . .

    My husband has taken on a lot of the shopping for his family (thank goodness!) and we tend to just get them consumable things year after year. That has made it a lot easier (we even repeat some ideas year after year), but I still have to remind and remind my husband to pick, to buy, and to send, so the presents aren't winging their way at the last minute or some time in the new year. I think his thought is "well, it's the thought that counts more than getting on time." and my thought is "if in the 21st century with all the convenience at your fingertips and knowing when Christmas is on the calendar every year, you can't be bothered to get a gift on time, why bother?"

    Yes, I can be a total grinch! Maybe b/c I don't enjoy the process, I just want to do it and get it out of the way so it's not hanging over my head.

    I love buying for nieces, nephews, and kid friends and friends' kids! and yes, they mostly get books. ;-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I just am not a shopper. Never have been. When I first met my in-laws, my MIL invited me to go shopping with her and my SILs and my husband cut in and said, "She doesn't shop. Thank god." LOL.

      Delete
  8. From Jay Roberts because the system won't publish when I put my name in:

    I'm a fine gift receiver. Because I'm relatively easy to shop for. NO...REALLY!a

    A Barnes and Noble gift card and I'm a happy guy. Or a gift card to the two main sources of food (the 99 or Jersey Mike's). Or a gift card to Purchase Street Records or Twilight Comics. (Sensing a theme yet?)

    I get baked goods from a couple of people. A family friend made a pan of the chicken dish I like so much. My friend Ann gave me books and book-related T-shirts (see my FB post "A Book Nerd's Christmas").

    And usually when people give me books, they know to ask me what I would like and then that's what I get. My sister did that for her Icelandic books and chocolate gift (along with dinner).

    So I receive these things gratefully and appreciate the notion that there are non-blood family people who think enough of me to give a gift.

    Easy-peasy and the only stress involved for me when I give gifts is making sure I have enough time and money to gift those in my life who I want to gift.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You are the perfect person to give gifts to, Jay!

      Delete
    2. In that case, I'll let you know what you can send me next Christmas. LOL

      Delete
  9. I give my adult children something they always need: a nice Zelle transfer to their bank accounts. Takes a couple minutes on the computer and it always fits , is always the right color. Now that all the grandchildren are almost grown, cash it is too. Gone are the days of toys and trains

    Except for Griffin. This year he got a Tonka fire engine. Can’t miss gift for a three year old

    For friends it is either a home baked goodie or a bottle of an adult drink. Or both.

    Julie and I , after almost thirty years, don’t exchange gifts any more. We have all we need or want. Our gifts to each other are cooking and cleaning up after. I do the first and she the latter. It works out well!

    Happy new year to all of us here. It appears to be a wild one but we shall survive. We always do.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I'm pretty much over the whole gift giving thing. Phew. But I love the four things approach, Jenn (want/need/wear/read). It's genius. And I totally agree that gift receiving is an art -- easy when it's easy but sometimes it can require digging deep sometimes for the generosity of spirit the giver (not necessarily the gift) deserves.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. From Jay Roberts - Want: a book Need: Cash for bills or books Wear: book-related T-shirt Read: (continuing a theme) a book.

      Delete
  11. Jenn, I love that your gift giving formula came from a conversation overheard at the Providence Airport. When it comes to gifts, the stress and uncertainty, I say, "Whatever works."

    My father was the best gift giver. He knew exactly what would make eyes sparkle! He also knew how you liked your hamburger cooked, how you took your coffee and your favorite flavor of ice cream. He was born with that gene!

    My husband did not get that gene. It's something you recognize early and make peace with or live a life full of unnecessary disappointment. Somewhere around the 5th or 6th celebration, I realized that my kind, sweet husband needed help. I took over all gift buying including for myself. I inherited my dad's gene and with a little help from the kids' lists now that we only see them every few months, I think we do just fine.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There was more going on than just dissatisfaction with the gift.

      Delete
    2. opps wrong Judy (Judi). :)

      Delete
    3. The Hub doesn't have that gene either. Thus, it's a collaborative affair.

      Delete
  12. I think I'm an okay gift-giver and receiver. In my family, we are past the age when we exchange gifts. We make donations in our family members names to charity. But this year, I went a little bit further. I spotted a memoir of Ted Nolan, the guy who was a hockey player and used to coach the Buffalo Sabres in the bookstore, so I got that for my dad (who loved it). My step-mom likes stuff from Bath & Body Works - check. My Facebook feed advertised a book about the first 50 years of Highmark Stadium, so I bought that for my brother and sister (although my sister-in-law had already bought it for my brother on his birthday - sigh). My 5-year-old nephew got a book and the accompanying coloring book.

    I asked The Boy and The Girl what they wanted. The Boy said, "Surprise me," so we got him a bag for his snowboard - but it's big enough to hold all the other gear as well. The Girl got exactly what she needed, which was a blow-dry brush. I bought The Hubby two books by Winston Churchill.

    As for me, The Girl gave me a necklace with a diamond in it. The Boy bought a fancy copy of DRACULA. The Hubby brought me a box of dark-chocolate covered sponge candy on his last trip to Buffalo (yum) and a 1,000-piece jigsaw puzzle that will either help me relax or make me completely lose my mind.

    My only strike out was my other nephew, who is 2. I know nothing about this child, because, well, my brother has brought him to see me exactly once. So I sent a gift card and told my brother to buy what he needed. In response, my brother chastised me for not addressing the card to his step-daughter as well "because she needs to know she's a part of my family, too." Well, then perhaps you should, I don't know, introduce her to me because aside from the fact she's a young teen and likes to dance, I don't know anything about her and you haven't gone out of your way to make her a part of MY family.

    But on the whole, I'd have to say it was one of the better gift-exchange years.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We do donations every year and I love it! That's one thing I can truly get behind!

      Delete
  13. I’m really over it. After decades of exchanging gifts between brothers and sisters and BIL and SIL, receiving and giving something we didn’t need and didn’t want and, taking into account climate change and overconsumption , I decided, years ago to stop participating. Some understood and others not but in the following years, the idea took root and finally we just simply enjoyed the company of each other .
    I continued to give gifts to nieces and nephews until they were 18 but now they are all adults .

    It doesn’t stop me from offering home made cookies to my widow neighbour or to invite lonely friends to come enjoy a meal. For me it reflects more the spirit of the Holidays than bought gifts.
    Danielle

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, Danielle! "the company of each other" What a lovely sentiment. I also like Liz's idea of a charity donation. My best friend and i do that.

      Delete
    2. Now that the Hooligans are busy, busy, busy and out on their own, being together is the best gift.

      Delete
  14. So many wonderful ideas here! And Jenn, I wish I could have implemented your plan many years ago.

    Now I'm reminded of a git we gave my step-son and his new wife years ago. Evidently it did not come up to her standard of a gift to be received and she let us know exactly that! We had all been together at a large family Christmas dinner/gift exchange. An hour or so later they showed up at our house and sat us down so the young woman could let us have it. I was shocked and speechless, which is really saying something for me. My husband didn't have words either. I had been knitting and continued doing that as she ranted on and on. She didn't like that either and said I could at least put it down while she was talking. It was knitting: I could do it in my sleep and it wasn't anything I had to pay attention to, but something to keep my hands from strangling her.

    Eventually she was finished and they left. The next day his son told my husband that he hadn't been sure that what they did was the right thing. No kidding. Their marriage only lasted a couple more years, which was no surprise to anyone.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Judi, the chutzpah! The unmitigated nerve. I'm stunned that someone thought that was okay.

      Delete
    2. Good heavens, Judi! I've never heard of anyone being so rude! Did you give them any more gifts after that?

      Delete
    3. There was more going on than just dissatisfaction with the gift.

      Delete
    4. The cheek! Not at all surprised the marriage didn't last.

      Delete
    5. Even all these years alter I still find it hard to believe that someone could act in such an outrageous way. She was very proud of her religious faith but you sure couldn't prove it by me. The gift, which really doesn't matter, was a nice set of bed sheets. I would have loved such a present myself. They were not cheap and we spent the same amount on both of my step-children. I still don't know what exactly the problem was. Did they not cost "enough" or if they were too common and she expected something much fancier?

      Delete
    6. Sheets! I would love sheets. ANd I know, I agree, it doesn't matter, but it's so bizarre!

      Delete
    7. My brother and sister-in-law recently gave us sheets for two Christmases. We’re good for a while. Lol.

      Delete
  15. I have to say I really hate it when people do not follow the rules – repeatedly. About 10 years ago we said let’s have a $10 Christmas for the adults, but nothing to come from the Dollar store, but can be a regift. One gift. That is easy. Nope, one person gave everyone multiple expensive gifts including (as usual) white fluffy bath towels. None of us use bath towels – too small – and never would we have white! She gave them to us for about 5 years. I wonder if the Sally Ann liked them.
    Then we said, no gifts for adults – even better! Nope. The first person of the towels finally caught on this year, and guiltily sent me a box of kitty litter – great gift! We were planning on staying at her place and when we didn’t go, I still sent up the wine, the jars of homemade jelly for the meal (was planning on that as a hostess gift anyway) and a very small kalanchoe ($4), for something under the tree if we were all there opening presents. Meanwhile, my sister who always suggests this process, gave me 5 (five) gifts which included yet another casserole dish (“so you can serve in it in May”. You cannot open the cupboard for casserole and serving dishes – send the loaves and fishes and I will feed the 5000 – elegantly!) I gave her a $4 wintergreen plant. Arrrggggh!
    Meanwhile my son (currently unemployed) gave us a set of Langostino pots – lovely. I don’t need them – they are restaurant size. I don’t want them – I have He Who Harrumphs’ mother’s heavy pots which I have always loved that may not be beautiful, but cook so well, and if I replace them, I know they will end up in the dump.
    So, dilemma – I can’t send the pots back, and, like the casserole dishes, I have no place for them. He will eventually visit us, and wonder where the pots are. I like my old pots, which by the way are the right size to cook for 2.
    Meanwhile, the sister is taking the casserole dish back – just as she did last year. As for the new greenhouse (which I don’t really need), if it is anything like the one that he already gave me for 3 Christmases, and Mother’s Days – it will probably take him 3 years to get to it. I will have used up the box of screws by then.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is the problem with Christmas in my opinion. Gifts and the psychological implications (who is getting what, how much are they spending, etc) are such an issue. It makes the holidays troublesome.

      Delete
    2. There's always one. I have a few relatives like that and I have learned to let it go - a challenge. Oy.

      Delete
  16. We gave up adult gifts this year, moving to stocking stuffers. Gifts for the kiddies only. I give books or maybe a quality toy without batteries or electronics.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Addendum: We just opened a gift from our daughter. They adopted a Monarch Butterfly in our name - nice!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. For the second year in a row I've "adopted" a puffin from a sanctuary/research facility in Maine for my dad. He's 80 years old and he and my stepmother are comfortably retired in an old farmhouse on Cape Cod. At this point, if there is any "thing" either of them wants/needs they can get it for themselves. - Melanie

      Delete
  18. Margo, that's a perfect gift for you! And takes up no space. Score!

    I'm hit or miss, mostly because I have picky kids, and people in my life who see something they want and they acquire it. It's nigh impossible to hit on a perfect gift.

    This year I had mostly hits, although I would much rather dispense with the whole gift thing, as we've done in other years. We have had gifting creep, apparently. However, the daughter in Greece gave me a specific request for herself and also for her husband, complete with links. My oldest went ahead and ordered gifts from my grandson's Amazon wish list, and had them sent here, wrapped. I added stocking stuffers for him, and bought my son-in-law a pricey Smartwool shirt, the kind he lives in all winter in northern Michigan. That daughter is always hot, so I found a cooling blanket and a neck fan for her, and both were welcomed enthusiastically. The middle daughter never wants anything, but she loved the lightweight cashmere shawl I sent as a combo birthday/Xmas gift. My mother keeps her brain sharp by working these ridiculously difficult word fill-in puzzles (like a crossword, but with a list of words and no clues), that are getting increasingly harder to find, especially in the large print she needs. I found a bunch online, and she was thrilled.

    My own gifts were received graciously, although I wish my mom would stop giving us money, since she needs it more than I do. C'est la vie. Steve gave me a bottle of good Scotch, with a note that explained that it was a "magical" bottle, and when he started griping about how much the basement work was costing I am to pour two shots. I will hand one to him, and he will swish it in his mouth and leave the room, while I enjoy the calming libation. Very comical. Especially since he hates Scotch, so maybe that will be a deterrent. LOL

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That Scotch -- a gift that comes with imaginative and creative instructions is priceless!

      Delete
    2. This made me snort, Karen! "Magical" indeed!

      Delete
    3. Love the magical Scotch! Much better than Lifeboy for washing out his mouth.

      Delete
    4. That is hilarious, Karen. Scotch! LOL!

      Delete
  19. Worst gift fail: younger sister's 6-month old son--penniless student that I was, I made him a pair of jeans. Sister turned up her nose since he should have received designer jeans. On the other hand, youngest nephew this year said I nailed his stocking (the only gifts I was allowed to get him). Pistachios, halo oranges, jellybellies, etc.--there was a theme--little treats he'd never think to get himself.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Designer jeans for a 6-month-old? SERIOUSLY?

      Delete
    2. You played the long game and won, Flora. Well done.

      Delete
  20. Both of my daughters create a wish list on Amazon or some other gift site so we just have to click on the item and have it shipped to our front door.

    But, I prefer to know what they want and that it can be purchased from a locally owned store, even a big box store that is local. Like in our area a Talbots (women's clothing) or Geppettos (toy store). If it isn't the perfect gift or size it can easily be returned.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Shopping local is a big deal for me. Luckily, being in AZ I can mail desert stuff to New England and it's all interesting to them :)

      Delete
  21. JENN: how serependitious (sp?) it was that you overheard a father telling his children at an airport - something you need, something you want, something to wear and something to read! If it was a Deaf family and the Deaf father said this in Sign Language, would you know what he said? I wonder.

    Love gifting to people whom I know well. I found a gift on my doorstep from a lovely neighbor who gave us Beautiful Christmas cookies that she baked. I love receiving books as gifts, especially books that I would love. One year for Christmas, I received the first Maisie Dobbs novel by Jacqueline Winspear and the first Maggie Hope novel by Susan Elia MacNeal and I fell in love with these series.

    For me, it is the thought that counts. These days I am always trying to declutter so I do not really have room for more gifts. I love receiving Christmas cards in the mail. My elementary teacher writes lovely Christmas newsletters about her year with her husband. Her writing is beautiful with certain phrases in the language.

    Diana

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It was a very lucky moment. The dad was pretty expressive in his irritation, so if he'd been signing I would have noticed his ire but not known what he said.

      Delete
  22. Our family is brilliant at gift giving! When we were in Cornwall this year son Dominic was driving and John had a melt down that he was not taking the best route to Merthen manor where we stay with John’s sister. For Christmas Dom had an old map blown up and framed. It shows Merthen and Ye Olde Best Route is highlighted!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mom used to tell her dad that she wanted to see something different when would she picked her own course.

      Delete
    2. I like this! And feel like I miss seeing new things if I’m always taking the GPS-optimized route.

      Delete
    3. Rhys, just being in England is the perfect gift!

      Delete
  23. I like to think I listen for 364 days a year and write notes to myself about what my nearest and dearest want/need. For my son-in-law it was a cherry-pitter. For my daughter a good meat thermometer. For my other daughter, a mandolin (slicer). Plus a nice holiday check which they can do with wahtever they please.

    This year I insisted I didn't want anything but my daughter bought me a cashmere sweater, which(having never had cashmere before) I find I adore and YES I did need it but didn't know it. THAT'S gifted gift-giving.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am a new cashmere convert as well - bought a pink cashmere sweater in a Vail thrift store last spring. It's just so soft and lovely, although I only get to wear it a few weeks out of the year in AZ and when I travel back east, still I love it.

      Delete
  24. I used to be a champion gift giver, catching clues to what my beloveds wanted throughout the year, conspiring with friendly shopkeepers, and staying up all night to add the final hand stitching detail to some custom-designed object. Yep. It was fun. I don't do that anymore, though. I'm not sure what ran out first: time, energy, or the number of people I surrounded myself with. Maybe I need to go back to that era when I found perfect, funny, sweet tree ornaments and stick to that, but this year it was a book for the youngest, clothes for most of the family, one gift card, and um . . . office supplies? Yeah, we'll call 'em office supplies for Deb.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You do choose the best "office supplies", dear Gigi! But I also love the Christmas ornaments and enjoy them so much every year when I put them on the tree.

      Delete
    2. My mother is gifted in the gifting arts - she's the only one, however. She amazes us every year with what she finds to give - always spot on.

      Delete
  25. This year I received a good mix of things on my provided list and a few fun, yet thoughtful, surprises. It is tricky. If I only get things in my list it feel like it was the same chore for the giver as getting groceries from a list, but sometimes surprises can totally bomb.

    Everyone knows they are going to get a book from me. I try to keep an eye out for reads that fit the recipient’s interests all year long.

    ReplyDelete
  26. I love your "four things" tradition, Jenn. Although, thinking back, we may have come close to that with our daughter when she was growing up. I still give my daughter a book (this year it was SJ Rozan's The Mayors of New York, as she's spending this week in New York!) and I started the same tradition with my granddaughter when she was a baby. I was pleased with my giving this year--when granddaughter opened her copy of How to Draw Cute Things she exclaimed, "Oh, this is the book Mrs (art teacher) has!!!" She also got a mystery, never fear:-)

    And my daughter's other gift was also a big success. Last year when we were in Houston for my book launch, we had dinner at a nice restaurant. The food and wine were good but what we loved even more was the glassware. It took me several months but I found the same glasses (or very similar) and was so excited to order them for her for Christmas. When she opened the box she said, "Oh!! These are the glasses from the Houston restaurant!!!!" and she was so pleased.


    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Perfect! I love when something strikes you and you are able to make it work. I need to work on tracking down the pint glasses with finger ridges my husband fell in love with in a Welsh pub 15 years ago . . .

      Delete
    2. Oh, that's perfect Debs! Well done!

      Delete
  27. My family has had a custom of making Christmas wish lists since the older two kids were in middle school. It's enormously helpful but not definitive, especially if, as I did this year, you wait until December 23rd to do ALL your shopping. (As a gift giver, I think the second most important thing, after being thoughtful, is keeping all the receipts!)

    Santa still fills stockings for all the "kids" who set them out on Christmas Eve, but in the past 6-7 years, they've become completely standardized: A sweet treat in the toe, pocket sized winter necessities (lip balm, hand sanitizer and hand cream) a pair of good-quality socks and a book. This year Santa also left pet toys. I wrapped pet toys for the kids who weren't here overnight. I hope this isn't the first step on a slide to outright Pet Grandmotherhood - if I make noises about buying the dogs and cats stockings, someone please stop me.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No, do it, Julia! We had a little chow mix who was a much-loved member of the family. We put her stocking (containing 2 dog biscuits) on the tree. She never bothered it and when, on Christmas morning, her stocking was given to her as everyone opened gifts, she took it from person to person to show it off!

      Delete
    2. The only stockings I did this year were little ones for the pets. We had a family meeting via text and since the stockings have always been on me -- shopping, wrapping, stuffing -- including my own, I was like, "Y'all, I'm done." And they said, "Okay." And you know what? We didn't miss them in the least.

      Delete
    3. "Y'all I'm done." I am practicing that phrase and plan to use it liberally in the future. Thanks Jenn.

      Delete
    4. Santa Paws has always left dog gifts at our family Christmases!

      Delete
    5. We have stockings for the dogs but not the cats. I suspect the cats don't care.

      Delete
  28. The 4-part gift strategy is perfect! If only it had arrived during my gift-giving years!

    One year I drew a map to the rack in Macy’s that had the trench coat I wanted my husband to buy me. Still have it 25 years later!

    My ideal gift to receive is a stocking with practical household gifts - the kind of things I’m always looking for and can’t find. Sharpies, tape, good scissors, a headlamp or flashlight - I’m in heaven.

    I do not miss the stressful days of shipping gifts from SoCal back to the Midwest where all of our relatives lived!

    ReplyDelete
  29. Christmas has gotten too commercial. All the ads on tv that tell us in order to be happy we have to buy a LOT of presents. I wish it was just about getting together sans gifts altogether! But that won't happy I know. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I always remember that message from the Charlie Brown Christmas special when i was a kid - and we're still doing it. The only winner is Madison Avenue.

      Delete
  30. Oh JENN! Your comment, "And, sadly yes, you must express appreciation even for those passive-aggressive goodies, like gym memberships and self-help books for issues you don’t have." is priceless!!

    ReplyDelete
  31. My new d-i-l has an Amazon wish list as long as your arm and adds to it constantly. So she was pretty easy to shop for - just decide how much I wanted to spend and order accordingly. Not sentimental, but she gets what she wants. Son also has a (much shorter) list so again, easy to shop for. Meanwhile, my husband pays attention to people’s personal likes, but goes w-a-a-a-y overboard. If you like hockey, one signed puck is a treat. Fifteen, not so much. So we’re working on it.
    This year he and I said no gifts for each other. Don’t need anything and we have a remodel coming up so let’s save the money. Then he came home and told me to stay in the kitchen while he brought something in from the car. After he got in, I said “That wasn’t a gift for me, was it?” “I only got you two little things.” Aarrgh! For once I had stayed true to the agreement! I made my way to Barnes & Noble and got him two books from the wish list he’d sent our son and then found an autographed, first edition of Bernie Taupin’s autobiography! Jackpot! He loved it. And the two “little” gifts he gave me were perfect: Barbra Streisand’s autobiography and an out-of-print Bette Midler book! — Pat S
    P.S. I am also going to keep the link to that Etsy shop for birthday gifts! Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. One of my Hooligans is like that. Broke college student with a huge heart. Argh!

      Delete
  32. This is SUCh a great question. Really. I love fining the perfect gift, and probably spend too much time on it. BUT Jonathan and I never--hardly ever--give each other anything on holidays because we do it all year. (I count having someone come paint my bathroom as a fabulous gift, that just happened. And Jonathan really wanted new towels, so that's easy. Ish. One year we got each other new laptops. But I don't really NEED anything.) I try to think of people year-round, and snap up the perfect thing when the time comes--that's so successful! Especially if I can find it again when I need it....:-)
    LOVE your four things plan, Jenn!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If I was on top of my game, I'd pay more attention during the year. Oy.

      Delete
  33. Is it a gift if the big thing is a microwave that had to replace the one that died, the day before Christmas Eve? I say YES!
    Concerning all the gift suggestions reminds me of an invitation that we received from my mother's brother's step-son. It included a list of things registered at Canadian Tire (a Canadian hardware and car-things store). The lowest priced was a generator and went up from there - didn't include a truck, but came close.
    We sent a card with a $10 bill.

    ReplyDelete